HomeMy WebLinkAbout7.2 Sidewalk Sale TUP
'.
.
.
,.
CITY CLERK
File # D~[5][Q]-[2J[CJ
AGENDA STATEMENT
CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: March 2,1999
SUBJECT:
Outdoor Sale Not-Related To A Dublin Business (Sidewalk Sale)
(Report Prepared by Dennis Carrington, Senior Plarmer/Zoning
Administrator) 10~
A TTACH1\1ENTS:
1)
~)
Temporary Use Pemlit (TUP) issued on February 8. 1999
Letter from Dublin Chamber of Commerce dated February 16. 199q
RECOMMENDATION~I 1)
~1 2)
~N 3)
Receive Staff Report
Deliberate
Give direction to Staff to draft an amendment to the Zoning
Ordinance prohibiting an Outdoor Sale Not-Related To A Dublin
Business (Side\\'alk Sale) except as provided elsewhere in the
Temporary Use Permit chapter of the Zoning Ordinance
FINANCIAL STATEMENT:
None
BACKGROUND:
Original Ordinance. The City Council adopted Ordinance 8 - 95 amending the Zoning Ordinance on
August 8, 1995 to add '.Outdoor Sales Not Related to On-Site Established Business" approved as a
Conditional Use Permit by the Zoning Administrator. This allowed certain outdoor sales by non-Dublin
businesses.
New Zoning Ordinance. The City Council adopted a new Zoning Ordinance on September 2, 1997.
The language in the new Zoning Ordinance does not allow Outdoor Sales Not-Related To A Dublin
Business (sidewalk sales), however the language in the current ordinance is somewhat misleading. The
section reads as follows:
N. Temporary Outdoor Sale Not Related To On-Site Established Business (Sidewalk Sale). A
temporary outdoor sale of goods by an established Dublin business, at the site ofthat business, of
goods and merchandise which are of the same and type as the goods and merchandise sold indoors
by the business. Promotional give-aways, such as free food, are allowed if they are related to and
subsidiary to the sale. Each individual outdoor sales event shall be subject to standards
established by the Director of Community Development and shall be limited to a maximum of 4
consecutive days, and no business may participate in more than 6 events during a one-);ear period
at one site.
-._----------------------------~-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
COPIES TO:
Nancy Feeley
Senior Planner
ITEl\1 NO.
1':2
G :agendas/1999/3-2srl
Temporary Use Permit. On February 8, 1999. Community Development Staff inadvertently issued a it
Temporary Use Permit (Attachment 1) for an individual to sell roses at the Shell Gas Station at 8999 San
Ramon Road from February 11, 1999, until February 14. 1999. The permit was issued in error. A review
of the Temporary Use Permit log revealed that the TUP in question is the only one to have been issued for
... Outdoor Sales Not Related to On-Site Established Business since the adoption of the revised Zoning .
Ordinance in 1997.
Chamber of Commerce Letter. The Chamber of Commerce sent a letter (Attachment 2) to .Mayor Guy
Houston on February 16, 1999, regarding a complaint received from a business member regarding a street
vendor selling merchandise on a street corner in the City of Dublin. It was the understanding of the
Chamber of Commerce that only Dublin-based businesses would be allowed permits for outdoor sales.
RECOMMENDATION:
In order to clarify the language in the current ordinance Staff recommends that the City Council give
direction to Staff to draft an amendment to the Zoning Ordinance that would read as follows:
~. Temporary Outdoor Sale Not Related To On-Site Established Business (Sidewalk Sale). A
Temporary Outdoor Sale Not Related To On-Site Established Business (Sidewalk Sale) is prohibited
except as provided elsewhere in this Chapter.
.
.
~.:"'-
.
. .
. .
- City of Dublin
Zoning Clearance Application Form / ~
~- ~
Temporary ProillotionaI Signs -'
.
] C~rljfy that I b\'e the a,nhorization of the Propen)' Owner to file this application for Zoning Ckarance. I l..mjers:~nd that the
proposed Temporary Promotional Signs shall not be set in place prior to recei"ing Zoning Clearance appro\'al from t:le Communi:;.'
DeveJopl.lent Director.
I agree to remo,:,e lhe }emporar)' promotional sign(.<;) wil!rinlhirt)' days jrom irs installarion as required hy [he. Zoning
Ordinance. I understand that keeping lhe s(!;n outside and displayed beyond the Tlziny-day period is a Dublin Zoning
Code l'irJ/mion and lhat I am liable to a riolaTiOI1 citatiol1 without an)' H'riltel1nO!icc heing iSSlied.
~2.:71e (Print or Type): " \ '\ r...,,- lJ \ \ \ ," AJ/, S Title: )/\Qrj ~-{:..
!. d ,.:-p~~ (,'"U' -;:'.' /'. -;.,). .<6 -::t?-- H."I\ Q:('''_ (JJ 1', '-[ ?-d (0 lltJJJ,-r, Ie 'l41~ Phone; C1'&-7 - ,~//- (?{ '/
S;g:~~u~<.""rJltit,~" .
Date:
'/
-
\ PROJECT L'\FOR'\1A TIO~
\'
.."
, '--
Proiect ~-\ddress: ~" . 511 . Ql..Mt,1J 'J A-1 (c-1 ~tv0 .
' 1''\'1 Project AP::-';::
- .~ 1.1
I ~ 7; r+~/ J "h I \
. Proje:::t'3usiness :--;arne: \< t> <; e.- '5 U -;/ 11;7 Lt .';/1 0n~~
n 1..t (2. L- I-L I~~,j rJ /'c- ~,~ - ,.- ~
Pro?erty Owner's ~ame: Phone: ':""" / t')')...S- - l1 S ;?-..u
.
Des:::ription:
Number of signs Purpose (sale, grand opening, etc.!
J ~~'1~'~~~ \M S~
Type (Banners, Pennants and Decorative ;:Iags) Material (CanV2S, Pl2stic, etc., No plywood)
'RC\ \ \ Cfi-j V t.-(,
\ ,h. \ ~J -e.t)
Sign: Height Width ArEa Method of sign attachment (Strings, rope, nailS, etc., to
P\ ~D a building wall, fence, posts, etc.!
\ S---<.fU\,) c, / Q~(7~ / f.;CwC-te Co'2- 0 5
Sian will not exceed 2!~' by 24' per Zonino Ordinance
copy (words and graPhics, it must be promotiona/l Location I
L D ~j C- K-c:>e 5 ~fA~+- .
s 1 E ['-" ~ "m" ,
5r ciIYJ)
Color(sl: Letter(s) Logo Background I Printed one or two sides
K~ ~ vJl+c"r(.. b~je...
Tethered Height (flags, balloons, pennants) I Time Displayed 'e.g. December3, '97 to January 3, '931
Fee: S25 per Sign or Pennant Line (cash or check payable to the City of Dublin)
. ,"
-~ -~
f ciiY'OF"DUSlIN
ATTACHMENT f ' ZOUING C!...EARANC-
i~~;'~0~/O~~~~c;l1!1 '
1-
::X 1/ ~f ~ ~It I /~ A /110/\17:')
-~. - .... '1o~'-""--...a.-. ~ .
.
..
.
City of Dublin
h Temporary Use Permit AppIicarion Form
:/ ~ FTHORIZ Ie,. TJO\' OF PROPERTY O\V\TR A \'1> A..PPLIC A.. "'T:
\----/
PROPERTI' OW!\:ER: In si,gnL.'1g this appii::a:io:l., I as Property O\\l1er, cerJ:"y that I have full legal capa:i:y 10, :onc ber::::-)' .:i:
autho;-lze the filing of this application. I unde::-stand that the proposed Ternpo:a:")' Use Pe!TIl.it use requi:es cO;;Jpi;2..'l::e \\'ith
:be spe::iiic Standard Requirements adopted by the City of Dublin Planning Commission for the propos.ed r:-p:.' of us.e.
1 :.:.n:ie:s::a....-Jd that the proposed use shall not be es::abiished p:ior to receiving Ternpo:ar)' Use Pe:-::nit Zpp;-o\'aJ t-Or:J :'~e
Dep2.."'!I:Jem of COm..-nuniI)' Development I agree 10 comp~r with all Srandcrd Rcquircmcr..!S unlcis a rcquircmer..r is n()[c:! ':.'
waived and initialed by a Cif)' of Dublin Flenner.
.
;'~_~D'
~'.:.......u.....
(?;int or Type)
/J1 HI:- k.
II
{j.,!-l/V f,..J A-
Title: PrC';1e;7\' nv,'ner'A."enT
C::>~?2..t-::y:
/+ / C'C' S-+?{
?hone:
...'7 ':' S
' ,
,-
SZS-i62D
~/!~ /(.Ci iJ/lj) - D J 3/. >J
/ '
Date: :'/11/ f f
/
A?P!.IC4...\"T (OT.H~ER TH4... \" PROPERD' o Ff?\'ER): 1 certify that I have LCJ: 2:iw.1:J:::::atiO:l OfL1: ?;-::;;:e;-::' O\\';;::-:,:l i;:::: :'~:5
a:l:>ii:3.:io:J for a Te::::mo;-a.,' Use ?err:::lit I unde;-s-...z....,d Liat the pro:Jcs::::l Temt.Jo;-a,' Use Pe::nit use re.::J:.:i:'e5 ,::o;;J:Jii2.,..,:e \\'j:.-. :.~~
s?~.::ifj:: Stznca.d Re-quir;ment5 adopted by the CitJ of Dublin Planning Comrr:ission for th: p;-op8~d type of ":25e.
I w:ies...z....,::j :::at the p:-oposed use sn21l Dot be es::abiished p:ior to re.::eh'ing Ternpo:a"')' lis: Pe:mit app:-ovai f;-Oill L~e
~e?~-::::ne:J'1 of Corr:::-J:l!li7)' DeveJop::ne:1t I egret 10 comply with all Slandard Requiremen:s unl:::ss e requirement is n.OlCC CJ
wc:vcC end initia.lcd j,J' a Cit)' of Dubiin Planner.
5 /~~ 1--L
r.>r- r7 Q'
Aci.:i:-e;:s (s=ee!, :i:)'& ::ip): 3 ( St'1'fv j.:.\;/T c),v
5if=z~e: 7l/:~/( //fN"~
('
,-'
L,' ".. ,
1 y) .f:
I
J" 2/'1"'" I~ c.
I~ " Iii;
J;;'2:TIe:
~.--:i:lt or Type)
, ~ -\ r\'\
v}\ \ YI(lJ",--S
Ti:]e:
'fl\~J L C -S!.fL-
.
CO:i:par.y:
,L). GJ. NOR-I H\;~e5\ DiSl ~
Phone:
q'd-~ - ;;177- (Cit/
Ad:i..-ess (s(J~-" -iry& :zjf7i iJ n,;'<3-
Si~arure:\~ (1/;hj.~ '
7/
n. PROJECT p..;-PORMA TIOl\':
t-l.62T'Z- WA"(
-<, 0 ;''It' d- L 0 f>~.'l J, \ k
7(-1,-,...
Da:e:- ~ ! '1 '7
\
(jJ.. C145?-L
?7oje.::t Address:
'is '1 '1 '1 "'5 A-I~
k S-e ~
KAN\ t!-.l 'J f1 \t'l\ D\ Ij) Project Ai'}\!:
?;-oje:t'3usine.ss Nzme:
;:vent Type (Le. Ca.""Ili\'al, Outdoor Sale, Christmas Tree Lot etc.):
Ou fDc~1L
'S .!lr\e5
,
III.. PLl='ASEA. ITA CH THE FOLLOV.'TNG ITEMS TO TmS APPLlCA nON (Unless noted as wai"ed and initialed j;Jy :3
Ci::' of Dublin Planner, Refer to individual event requirement sheets ior additional information):
./ ?e~: S25 (:asb or che.::k payable to the CiTY of Dublin)
,/ Written Statement
,/ Diag:;-aw. of Site (1 copies)
,~/ Signage De:ai.ls (irlclucie ZO:J.mg Clearance Form and Fees)
Ce:-tificate ofInsu..-ance :m:ming the City of Dublin 2.S
adcii-::ional insured in the 2WOunt of Sl,OOO,OOO
5500 Deposit ?ee to er.stre :::iean up of the site
Other requIred items:
I
ell Y OF DU3LlN .;
TEMPORARY USE PERfll}T I
APPROV=D /.7 , --
TU?#OLl-O f D.!,T::) J:' -( 1
BY 1/11 C,A ,(, /'L ^ /. /i'/1/j)
~:\::;?\:u?fc::n
~ ,~
.
-,
-..-----.
,,"
-----
~"
e:;-
e
....--------
--
~
-"
, -
--
,~
-
:.--
:;-.
-
.,"
--
-
-'
---:
;::-:
-
'-
.::..
.~\
-.
-::;-
.~....>
L~"
.-
.........
~
I
I
I
'".-..-- - . I
-;-.:"7~---.l \
!:-\ !
, -
!r~
---
-'
,-'
~
--' ~
- ^,
"'
^.
---..,
-
\ '
::>
---------
'-- - ... ...
(
f
\
\
..
---
./ ' \
.::> ) ---\_"
, ' . "" \.; /
'- - . \.. \ ':'.
.- ------ .----.-
.....-..
/
--
\
~/
./
\'
:.....:::...
,I
, I
'J~
--:
.-.
r"-'-
--~
.------
,- !
~
-'/\
, I '
.......
-.'
.. ~,...-:
--
~
.i
----
___...-.""..-----~-.-..--------- _,. _,. r
\
\
-
,-
l
.,..'
~-
--
_.~..~_. ____r .~_....._ ~
...
-
l
---
C(l ( /:::-
-..-> -;- ;.....
,....,. 13'
1_..:'/
I ~'
fi ' ,.-
-l 0.:- C
{ ",/
v V\...
---;- " ( . ---
/ /~( j
iU..--
f t { (
I
,17/ /-{,.-: I(
1'2. '[;5:: ..J
, - /..I
/ Y /; I.
- ,
/~ ,
f?5
(i:-' /1::( (f /I t'/
il C< V {'
( , "
it: /- rl1.
!v':o
,-
.
)/~~'.:;.
c-- //
I
1/
/--' P /./ /'v /f c;; III
j-::" ,-
~ ;
/ ';7 '
-~ /
/ /...J( ," I, , __
v' " ~ I / -I ~ :..- J
;.-. ~ f-! 1>1. j' J, ,'~ iv, /Ir ,:..,
,!) ,', /:;.. ",'1 J::;?' II _'/:,
--,' I/, ", -,' c ...' / ' ,.'
{,..J. . ((, >1'7 S ;;/'" ....,/c.. :..,/.'-.!~
/ / - -
;7 ~ .J . I~ ~.~
/
(0
~ ~"'I ~('
~ I .....
,
(":(..""":-c-c..15
".., - /
L ::,-'..> /"-1. / i1 :::.."- .s;
.!-,'{":' b (-::/ t. ~ ;'--;'(,Jl.'t I~: // t.;7/' /2 c.J := S'
/- --' , j -.
/ '7 I - - '1' ( - / ,...., /'. I (
L-- r:? T -=: /:..r.11 /''''; 'Z.,-::.'.;:' \ <-{ T '::/7' TI /"'7 C'
c:- 1...- C .:: r-:;.,., / ,7 Y I i"'{-/ ~/";. ;,? /._' ..;.7.
(,\ I / I 0/,';.-- >,-/-'7" ,/" ,[,-" _f/~" .v/'
>/4:1-1- r .
c ro/V
/ C (; (..f /-1 ',; ,"v ; S
"I) (j;j /, (Yl . A / C OJfr-'-
,
/ll&.z.!r- II.
('~:LL- ~
/L7n~-,- (t-eC-SE~_)
.:;r.., - __
/t:.~ ..:::. /7- 3/;= z.
, .
.... :
.
.
.
.
FE3-15-99 MON 12:59 DU3LIN.CHAMEER
925 828 4247
P.t;l2
old in heritage ~ new in ideas
.;.
In
u
---
Chamber of Commerce
February 16, 1999
Mayor Guy Houston
Dublin City Council
P. O. Box 2340
Dublin, Califo:nia 94568
Dear Mayor Ho~ston;
On February 12, 1999 the Dublin Chamber of Commerce office received a complaint irom one of it's
business members regarding a "street vendor" selling merchGIloise on a street comer in the Cit"/ of Dublin.
The City Pl~Jl.'1ir.g Department v.-as contacted regarding this matter and the Chamber was infor::J.ed by staff
member Dennis Carrington that a three day tempora.')' use per.r.1it was issued to the yendor by the City in
accordance with the guidelines of the Ctt:Tent ordinance for outside sales.
It W<,".S the understanding oftbe Chamber 2.Ild members of the Committee thst worked on the revision
of the outside s.s.les ordinance several years ago that only Dublin based businesses with Dublin commercial
addresses and a Dublin city business permit would be allowed penn its for outdoor sales. It is disappointing to
think a temporary use permit was issued to a street vendor selling the same merchandise as several other
businesses within the City of Dublin.
Dublin businesses pay a fee to the City of Dublin for the privilege of operating a business within the
City. In addition, there are the normal business expenses ofrent, ta.xes, etc. not to mention the ::r!~ation of
jobs. It is difficult to understand how the City Planning Department can justify issuing a use permit for
$25.00 to en individual that does not live or nave a business within Dublin and, most importantly, does not
support the Dublin community through donations to schools, communit)' projects, sports programs, etc.
The Dublin Chamber of Commerce and City have worked diligently over the years on the image of
Dublin. Street vendors selling products out of the trunb of their vehicles on eveI}' corner and in parking lots
is not the best image for our City.
The Chlunber urges the City Council to review the outdoor sales ordinance again and td:e the
necessary precautions to "close the loopholes" to insure our City streets are rree of outdoor vendors selling
their v,7..res. We believe Dublin should look it's "best" at al1 times.
Thank you for your consideration of this matter.
v1L~:~UFf -v--t<-d
NA1~CY FtELEY ;r
Executive Dire;:tor ~. e'!l:~:~~ ~' (.~ ~+ rf. f.'"'f~f f ~F
A"rt :c l':: i ," '." ~. t<.'" ,'" f,:,,"'i p;
~~, " ~ f< ~. ..~ 't' ~~.f:/r" r~'~~ t'
.... ii: '=::---/-. ;;'4....... ~ a-
7080 DONLON WAY, SUI7:; 110. DU9uN, CALIFORNIA 94568
(925) 828-6200 · FAX: (925) 828.4247 · E-MAIL: dblncofc@pacbell.net
?
~