HomeMy WebLinkAbout6.5 PGE StrLights&Lighting
y
:.
.CITY CLERK
File # D~~rpJ-~
AGENDA STATEMENT
CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: February 13,1996
SUBJECT:
EXHIBITS ATTACHED:
RECOMMENDATION:
~
.~.
Public Hearing: To Consider Adoption of a Resolution of Necessity
Directing the Filin~ of Eminent Domain Proceedings to Acquire
Street Lights and Street Lighting Facilities from Pacific Gas and
Electric Company (pG&E)
Report Prepared by: Lee S. Thompson. Public Works Director
1)
2)
3)
Resolution, with listing of facilities attached
Most recent offer letter to PG&E
Copy of Notice of Exemption
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
Open public hearing
Receive Staff presentation and publicconunent
Question Staff and the public
Close public hearing and deliberate
Adopt resolution (requires 4/5 vote)
FINANCIAL STATEMENT: A deposit in the amount of$133,689 will need to be filed with the
State Treasury. The ultimate price paid for the street lights may be higher. Acquisition Group Staffwill
continue to negotiate withPG&E and will return to the City Council with progress reports. Legal and
consulting costs will be incurred as necessary during this process. Funds have been budgeted in the Five-
Year Capital Improvement Program for acquisition of the lights.
Once the City takes possession of the lights, the monthly billing from PG&E will decrease substantially,
and the City will begin to incur additional maintenance costs. The annual savings to the City is estimated
to be between $68,00d"and $70,000, based on current rates and excluding replacement costs. (See body of
report for additional information on rates.) At the public hearing regarding the City-Wide Street Light
Maintenance Assessment District on July 25, 1995, the City Council discussed several funding options and
determined that the funds for the street light acquisition (including the deposit noted above) should come
from a combination of assessment district reserves, any savings realized' in Fiscal Year 1995-96, and the
City's General Fund.
:..
."." -.~
COPIES TO:
g:\agenmisc\ltlites
PG&E
Don Maynor
Russ Harnm
ITEM NO..6. 'j
..
~. ,'.
, .....,
DESCRIPTION: The City's adopted Goals and Objectives includes acquisition of .','
street lights as a goal. In addition, the City's Five- Year Capital Improvement Program identifies a project . ,.,
for purchase of street lights and street light facilities from PG&E. City street light ownership provides the
following public benefits:
1. The City can substantially reduce its PG&E street light bill by taking electric service under the LS-2
rate tariffinstead of the LS-1 (see Financial Statement above and additional information below
regarding gross and net savings). Since electric service for street lights is a major expense of the
City, reduction of this expense also reduces the cost of local government.
2. The City can provide a higher standard oj maintenance than offered by PG&E and can also ensure
prompt repair oj street light outages, thereby improving public safety and convenience.
3. The City can impose higher construction and installation standards to assure greater public safety
and maximize energy efficiency.
In December of 1993, the City of Dublin joined the Alameda County Street Light Acquisition (ACSLA)
Group. This group consists of the County of Alameda and 10 cities within the County. Over the past two
years, the group has met to discuss various aspects of the acquisition, including appraisals, financing,
development of standard specifications, maintenance alternatives, and the mechanics of the acquisition.
The majority of the City's street lights (1,354) are currently owned by Pacific Gas and Electric Company ."'.
and are billed under the "LS-l" rate, which includes a considerable charge for maintenance.' PG&E
performs aU maintenance on the lights under this rate schedule, including bulbs, photoelectric controls,
lenses, knockdown replacement, and underground or overhead wiring replacement. The City currently
owns 415 lights which are billed under the LS-2C rate. This rate also includes a charge from PG&E for
maintenance; however, the charge is lower and only includes replacement of bulbs, photoelectric controls,
and lenses. The City is responsible for any other maintenance needed by the City-owned lights.
Once the City acquires the PG&E-owned lights, the rate schedule for these lights would change to the
"LS-2A" rate, which includes only energy cost and a small amount of overhead. This rate is substantially
lower than the LS-l rates. For example, the current LS-IA rate for a 70-watt street light is $7.75 per
month, and the LS-IE rate is $10.87, as opposed to an LS-1A rate of$2.67. The majority of residential
area street lights are 70 watts. There are a number of variations in the LS-l rate schedule; these ac~unt
primarily for differences in pole type and ownership: When the City acquires the PG&E lights, it is also
proposed to change the City-owned lights from the LS-2C to the LS-2A rate.
The City will incur maintenance costs for the street lights, as well as some increased administrative costs.
The feasibility study that was performed in 1993 estimated $1.55 per light per month for normal
maintenance (bulbs and photocells), exclusive of extraordinary repairs such as knockdowns, with a total
annual maintenance cost of$40,000. It is proposed to expand the scope of the existing traffic signal and
street lighting maintenance contract with Alameda County to include the newly-acquired lights. Staffhas
further estimated the administrative cost to be approximately $9,500 per year (same as budgeted for FY '.
1995-96). After deducting the estimated maintenance and administrative costs, the total net annual savings e:.
is estimated at approximately $68,900, based on the current LS-l rates. :-
Page 2
.
.
.
,~-
,""
PG&E recently filed a rate adjustment request with the CPUC which provides for a 20% reduction in LS-l
rates. When these rates take effect on July 1st, the spread between the LS-I and LS-2 rates will change so
that the annual savings to the City is less. The Acquisition Group's appraiser has analyzed the proposed
rate schedule and estimates the gross annual savings to be $89,100. After deducting the estimated
maintenance and administrative cost, the net annual savings is estimated at $39,600.
The City's street lighting energy and maintenance costs are funded entirely by the City-Wide Street
Lighting Assessment District. The City's property owners therefore pay the cost of street lighting based
on various factor rates. A single-family lot, which is assigned a factor rate off~I," has been paying $19.34
per year. Conunerciallots are assessed on the basis of lot size. The reduction in the cost of street lighting
energy and maintenance can therefore be passed on to the property owners in the form of a reduced
assessment.
The Acquisition Group has submitted several offers and counteroffers to,PG&E for purchase of the street
lights. PG&E has, to date, rejected these offers and counteroffers. The latest offer is attached as Exhibit
2. In, order to achieve the cost savings at the earliest possible date, Staff is reconunending that the City
Council adopt the Resolution of Necessity, so that the City can take possession of the lights and begin
paying the lower LS-2A rates. The other jurisdictions in the Acquisition Group have agreed to take this
same step toward acquiring the lights ,within their respective territorial limits.
A Categorical Exemption has been tiled regarding the acquisition of the street lights and street lighting
facilities (see Exhibit 3). Staff recommends that the City Council conduct a public hearing, delibc;,rate, and
adopt the Resolution of Necessity. .
Page 3
RESOLUTION NO. - 96
.'-
"
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
OF THE CITY OF DUBLIN
*********
NECESSITY OF ACQUISITION OF STREET LIGHTING FACILITIES
BY EMINENT DOMAIN
WHEREAS, the City of Dublin, a General Law city, is authorized to acquire by eminent domain
public utility facilities for the public use of street lighting pursuant to, among other provisions of State
Law, California Code of Civil Procedure Section 1240.110; California Constitution Article XI, Section 9;
Government Code Section 37350.5; Government Code Section 39732; and Government Code Section
40404(f); and
WHEREAS, the City of Dublin desires to acquire certain public utility facilities, namely all Pacific
Gas and Electric Company (hereinafter "PG&E") street lighting facilities located within the territorial limits
of the City of Dublin that are on PG&E's LS-l rate schedule, and which are generally described in the
Attachment "A". and
,
.
WHEREAS, the City Council has provided the notice and has held the hearing required by
California Code of Civil Procedure Section 1245.235, and no legal impediment to proceeding with the
acquisition has been shown;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that:
1.
following:
The City Council of the City of Dublin declares that it has found and determined each of the
a. The public interest and necessity require the proposed acquisition of all PG&E street
lighting facilities located within the territorial limits of the City of Dublin that are on PG&E's LS-l rate
schedule, and which are generally described in Attachment "A".
b. The project for which the public utility facilities (generally described herein and in
Attachment "A") are to be acquired has been planned and located in a manner that will be most compatible
with the greatest public good and the least private injury.
c. The public utility facilities (generally described herein and in Attachment "A") are
necessary for the proposed project.
d. The public utility facilities (generally described herein and in Attachment "A") are to
be acquired pursuant to California Code of Civil Procedure Section 1240.610 and, as provided in
. California Code of Civil Procedure Section 1240.650, said facilities are a more necessary public use than
the present use to which said facilities are appropriated.
E)f~~Rr:r' I
l,r~" a'!w.Ja/. ~_""'''''---'~~~..Q~:'~
~(}jO~-h~
e. The offer required by Section 7267.2 of the Government Code (to the extent
appropriate) has been made to the owner of record of the public utility facilities generally described herein
and in Attachment "A".
e
2. The City Attorney is directed to commence proceedings in eminent domain against the
owner of the public utility facilities, including but not limited to PG&E pole space on which street lighting
luminaires are currently located, and any and all interest therein or claims thereto, for the condemnation
thereof for the public use of the City of Dublin. The City Attorney is further authorized to seek a
consolidation of such action with any similar eminent domain action of streetlights by any other public
agency in Alameda County.
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this 13th day of February, 1996.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
ABSTAIN:
Mayor
.':,
.'
ATTEST:
City Clerk
g:\agerunisc\resostlt
e:.
ATTACHMENT IAI
.-: PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY
CITY OF DUBLIN STREETLIGHTS
INVENTORY
LINE
NO. ACCOUNT DESCRIPTION QTY YEAR
(a) (b) (c) (d)
1 215 SERVICE ST. LT. OVERHEAD DROP 100' EA 8 1964
2 215 SERVICE ST. LT. OVERHEAD DROP 100' EA 1 1965
3 215 SERVICE ST. LT. OVERHEAD DROP 100' EA 11 1966
4 215 SERVICE ST. LT. OVERHEAD DROP 100' EA 126 1967
5 215 SERVICE ST. LT. OVERHEAD DROP 100' EA 235 1968
6 215 SERVICE ST. LT. OVERHEAD DROP 100' EA 6 1971
7 215 SERVICE ST. LT. OVERHEAD DROP 100' EA 1 1977
8 215 SERVICE ST. LT. OVERHEAD DROP 1 DO' EA 3 1978
9 215 SERVICE ST. LT. OVERHEAD DROP 100' EA 1 1982
10 215 SERVICE ST. LT. OVERHEAD DROP 100' EA 4 1984
11 215 VERTICAL RUN 3' EA 26 1964
12 215 VERTICAL RUN 3' EA 10 1965
13 215 VERTICAL RUN 3' EA 94 1966
14 215 VERTICAL RUN 3' EA 17 1967
15 215 VERTICAL RUN 3' fA 17 1968
.:-, 16 215 VERTICAL RUN 3' EA 5 1969
-0'
.. 17 215 VERTICAL RUN 3' EA 6 1970
' "
18 215 VERTICAL RUN 3' EA 2 1971
19 215 VERTICAL RUN 3' EA 3 1972
20 215 VERTICAL RUN 3' EA 2 1974
21 215 VERTICAL RUN 3' EA 3 1979
22 215 VERTICAL RUN 3' EA 21 1983
23 215 VERTICAL RUN 3' EA 130 1984
24 215 VERTICAL RUN 3' EA 30 1985
25 215 VERTICAL RUN 3' EA 2 1986
26 215 VERTICAL RUN 3' fA 5 1987
27 215 VERTICAL RUN 3' EA 1 1989
28 215 VERTICAL RUN 3' EA 2 1990
29 215 VERTICAL RUN 3' EA 2 1993
30 216 INTERNAL WIRING ST. LT. POLE EA 7 1966
31 216 INTERNAL WIRING ST. LT. POLE fA 7 1966
32 216 INTERNAL WIRING ST. LT. POLE EA 2 1971
33 216 INTERNAL WIRING ST. LT. POLE EA 2 1975
34 216 INTERNAL WIRING ST. LT. POLE EA 3 1979
35 216 INTERNAL WIRING ST. LT. POLE EA 41 1980
36 216 INTERNAL WIRING ST. LT. POLE EA 27 1981
37 216 INTERNAL WIRING ST. LT. POLE EA 74 1982
38 216 INTERNAL WIRING ST. LT. POLE fA 10 1983
39 216 INTERNAL WIRING ST. LT. POLE EA 29 1984
.-" 40 216 INTERNAL WIRING ST. LT. POLE EA 41 1985
41 216 INTERNAL WIRING ST. LT. POLE EA 113 1986
42 216 INTERNAL WIRING ST. LT. POLE EA 67 1987
43 216 INTERNAL WIRING ST. LT. POLE EA 55 1988
2/8/95 Page 1 A2378.XLS
PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY .'
CITY OF DUBLIN STREETLIGHTS
INVENTORY
LINE
NO. ACCOUNT DESCRIPTION CTY YEAR
-
(a) (b) (c) (d)
44 216 INTERNAL WIRING ST. LT. POLE EA 14 1989
45 216 INTERNAL WIRING ST. LT. POLE EA 34 1990
46 216 INTERNAL WIRING ST. LT. POLE EA 4 1991
47 216 INTERNAL WIRING ST. LT. POLE EA 5 1992
48 216 INTERNAL WIRING ST. LT. POLE EA 1 1993
49 216 RISER MOULDING U-SHAPE 2"/30' PVC EA 1 1973
50 216 RISER MOULDING U-SHAPE 2"/30' PVC EA 1 1977
51 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6 AL. 600V UG EA 8 1966
52 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6 AL. 600V UG EA 7 1966
53 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6 AL: 600V UG EA 2 1971 '
54 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6 AL. 600V UG EA 1 1973
55 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6 AL. 600V UG EA 2 1975
56 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6 AL. 600V UG EA 1 1977
57 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6 AL. 600V UG EA 3 1979
58 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6 AL. 600V UG EA 41 1980
59 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6 AL. 600V UG EA 27 1961 ..
-.
60 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6 AL. 600V UG EA 74 1962
61 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6 AL. 600V UG EA 10 1963
62 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6 AL. 600V UG EA 29 1964
63 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6 AL. 600V UG EA 41 1965
64 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6 AL. 600V UG EA 113 1966
65 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6 AL. 600V UG EA 67 1967
66 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6 AL. 600V UG EA 55 1966
67 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6 AL. 600V UG EA 14 1989
66 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6 AL. 600V UG EA 34 1990
69 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6AL. 600V UG EA 4 1991
70 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6 AL. 600V UG EA 5 1992
71 216 SERVICE ST. LT. #6 AL. 600V UG EA 1 1993
72 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 100W EA 27 1978
73 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 100W EA 4 1979
74 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 100W EA 1 1980
75 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 100W EA 1 1982
76 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 100W EA 16 1964
77 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 100W EA 5 1965
76 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 100W EA 26 1986
79 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 100W EA 16 1990
80 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 150W EA 4 1978
81 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 200W EA 3 1976
62 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 200W EA 2 1979
83 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 250W EA 4 1976 .'
84 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 70W EA 575 1978
85 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 70W EA 3 1979
66 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 70W EA 40 1960
2/8/95 Page 2 A2378.xLS
.
PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY
CITY OF DUBLIN STREETLIGHTS
INVENTORY
LINE
NO. ACCOUNT DESCRIPTION QTY YEAR
-
(a) (b) (c) (d)
87 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 70W EA 27 1981
88 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 70W EA 77 1982
89 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 70W EA 33 1983
90 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 70W EA 159 1984
91 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 70W EA 69 1985
92 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 70W EA 89 1986
93 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 70W EA 72 1987
94 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 70W EA 55 1988
95 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 70W EA 15 1989
96 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 70W EA 20 1990
97 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 70W EA 4 1991
98 217 LUMINAIRE HPSV 70W EA 5 1992
99 217 LUMINAIRE' HPSV 70W EA 2 1993
100 217 PHOTO CELL PART 17 TWIST LOCK EA 613 1978
101 217 PHOTO CELL PART 17 TWIST LOCK EA 9 1979
..: 102 217 PHOTO CELL PART 17 TWIST LOCK EA 41 1980
103 217 PHOTO CELL PART 17 TWIST LOCK EA 27 1981
104 217 PHOTO CELL PART 17 TWIST LOCK EA 78 1982
105 217 PHOTO CELL PART 17 TWIST LOCK EA 33 1983
106 217 PHOTO CELL PART 17 TWIST LOCK EA 175 1984
107 217 PHOTO CELL PART 17 TWIST LOCK EA 74 1985
108 217 PHOTO CELL PART 17 TWIST LOCK EA 115 1986
109 217 PHOTO CELL PART 17 TWIST LOCK EA 72 1987
110 217 PHOTO CELL PART 17 TWIST LOCK EA 55 1988
111 217 PHOTO CELL PART 17 TWIST LOCK EA 15 1989
112 217 PHOTO CELL PART 17 TWIST LOCK EA 36 1990
113 217 PHOTO CELL PART 17 TWIST LOCK EA 4 1991
114 217 PHOTO CELL PART 17 TWIST LOCK EA 5 1992
115 217 PHOTO CELL PART 17 TWIST LOCK EA 2 1993
116 217 SUSPENSION 12' EA 1 1966
117 217 SUSPENSION 12' EA 1 1971
118 217 SUSPENSION 12' EA 1 1973
119 217 SUSPENSION 12' EA 4 1975
120 217 SUSPENSION 12' EA 1 1984
121 217 SUSPENSION 30" EA 26 1964
122 217 SUSPENSION 30" EA 10 1965
123 217 SUSPENSION 30" EA 92 1966
124 217 SUSPENSION 30" EA 23 1967
125 217 SUSPENSION 30" EA 4 1968
126 217 SUSPENSION 30" EA 6 1969
. 127 217 SUSPENSION 30" EA 6 1970
128 217 SUSPENSION 30" EA 4 1972
129 217 SUSPENSION 30" EA 1 1974
2/8/95 Page 3 A2378.xLS
( PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY .
1
CITY OF DUBLIN STREETLIGHTS
INVENTORY
LINE
NO. ACCOUNT DESCRIPTION QTY YEAR
-
(a) (b) (c) (d)
130 217 SUSPENSION 30" EA 2 1977
131 217 SUSPENSION 30.' EA 3 1978
132 217 SUSPENSION 30" EA 3 1979
133 217 SUSPENSION 30" EA 21 1983
134 217 SUSPENSION 30" EA 129 1984
135 217 SUSPENSION 30" EA 29 1985
136 217 SUSPENSION 30" EA 2 1986
137 217 SUSPENSION 30" EA 5 1987
138 217 SUSPENSION 30" EA 1 1989
139 217 SUSPENSION 30" EA 2 1990
140 217 SUSPENSION 30" EA 2 1993
141 217 SUSPENSION 4' EA 1 1967
142 217 SUSPENSION 4' EA 9 1968
143 217 SUSPENSION 6' EA 1 1965
144 217 SUSPENSION 6' EA 20 1966
145 217 SUSPENSION 6' EA 125 1967 e-:
146 217 SUSPENSION 6' EA 252 1968
147 217 SUSPENSION 6' EA 9 1971
148 217 SUSPENSION 6' EA 1 1974
149 217 SUSPENSION 6' EA 6 1979
150 217 SUSPENSION 6' EA 41 1980
151 217 SUSPENSION 6' EA 26 1981
152 217 SUSPENSION 6' EA 78 1982
153 217 SUSPENSION 6' EA 10 1983
154 217 SUSPENSION 6' EA 43 1984
155 217 SUSPENSION 6' EA 8 1985
156 217 SUSPENSION 6' EA 1 1993
157 217 SUSPENSION 8' EA 10 1964
158 217 SUSPENSION 8' EA 1 1984
159 218 POLE SOLELY OWNED ". 25 FT EA 1 1967
160 218 POLE SOLELY OWNED 35 FT EA 1 1967
161 218 POLE SOLELY OWNED 35 FT EA 3 1978
162 218 POLE SOLELY OWNED 45 FT EA 1 1977
163 218 POLE CENTER BORED WOOD 30' EA 3 1985
164 218 POLE EMBEDDED CONCRETE WIO MAST 31' EA 16 1967
165 218 POLE FND WIO MAST ARM STEEL 28' EA 8 1964
166 218 POLE FND WIO MAST ARM STEEL 28' EA 9 1966
167 218 POLE FND WIO MAST ARM STEEL 28' EA 39 1~67
168 218 POLE FND WIO MAST ARM STEEL 28' EA 236 1968
169 218 POLE FND WIO MAST ARM STEEL 28' EA 8 1971
170 218 POLE FND WIO MAST ARM STEEL 28' EA 40 1980 .
171 218 POLE FND WIO MAST ARM STEEL 28' EA 26 1981
172 218 POLE FND WIO MAST ARM STEEL 28' EA 71 1982
2/8/95 Page 4 A2378.xLS
.'
.'~, PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY
CITY OF DUBLIN STREETLIGHTS
INVENTORY
LINE
NO. ACCOUNT DESCRIPTION QTY YEAR
-
(a) (b) (c) (d)
173 218 POLE FND WIO MAST ARM STEEL 28' EA 10 1983
174 218 POLE FND WIO MAST ARM STEEL 28' EA 23 1984
175 218 POLE FND WIO MAST ARM STEEL 28' EA 1 1993
176 218 POLE FND WIO MAST ARM STEEL 32' EA 7 1967
177 218 POLE FND WIO MAST ARM STEEL 32' EA 4 1968
178 218 POLE FND WIO MAST ARM STEEL 32' EA 2 1975
179 218 POLE FND WIO MAST ARM STEEL 32' EA 2 1982
180 216 POLE FND WIO MAST ARM STEEL 32' EA 10 1984
161 218 POLE FND WIO MAST ARM STeEL 35' EA 1 1967
182 218 POLE FND WIO MAST ARM STEEL 35' EA 2' 1968
183 218 POLE FND WIO MAST ARM STEEL 35' EA 1 1980
184 218 POLE WIO FND & MAST ARM ALUM 32' EA 1 1965
185 218 POLE W/O' FND & MAST ARM ALUM 32' EA 2 1966
186 218 POLE WIO FND & MAST ARM ALUM 32' EA 61 1967
..
.)
..
2/8/95
Page 5
A2378'xLS
~
"'Ill .
!i!?
( 0
~
...
c:i &i
Z;j
..0
cor::
.. c
a.. ";=
..
0
u
~ /u 0 00 0'" 00 I~
8J:~,...,
NCI-..,
:::;1Il
>- W /3
z -' ~ I~ 0 00 "'..,
;:) 0 ..,..,
< 0 ozwlll",en .....,
a.. .....,
~ W ""'CJ!:::!..,"'N
J: :::;1Il
OenO..!
Oi(/)~
o w." /~
-c"I-O ~ Iv ~ 0 00 0'" 0'"
a:_<.r::
I--'a:~ 8:r~..,N'" N
f;3t:;>-o ~~iii'" e:
ii:l~Cllii -'
o wa:
. zen N >- ~ IN 0 0 00 00 ON t
<ziiiCll a..
1/):::;1-"2 gJ:~..,
<1IlJ:t:: ...giii'"
CI~CJc
Q:::;IIl
0 l- /o
u: w
(3 w ~ 100 0 00 00 00
a: gJ:~N
< I-
a.. I/) ..,CJ-..,
:::;1Il
~ 100 0 00 0'" 00 Iv
gJ:~~ '<t
N~iii'" III
-' '"'!.
...
n
I/)W -' I/)
1--' < I-
J:~ I- J:
ClO 0 CJ
_ w I- :::;
-,-'J: m
<u.o ,...,,,, "',..., ~ u.
1-01/) ....., 0 00 ...,..., ..,CO III 0
Oa:w ..,.., ~'<t a:
I-wl- w
m< Cll
~a: ~
~>- ~
Zm Z
....I
<
I-
w =~ e~ @Q 0
....I B ii:'C2' I-
w~ --
.., 1-0 ... ...
<w 00
'" en a:J: <0 m ww I/)u.:
,..., 0 0 ~ ... J I ~~Lft~~
.., 0 I/) chcb ,j, ~~o~~~~~en
NNO -' ...J ....I
oi:~ .. .. .. .:;
z .S! :I .. .. ..
-.s = .! 0 '0 "0
... ... ... ... C1......_Cl..~~Q.. ...
.~ > ~ I- 00 0 88 08'800'8 0 II)
w Z 00 0 o 0000 g en
ii'1ii < I-O;::J 00 0 00 00 it 0 0;;: (5
Q...... ~ZO en en en en en mm ~mm en ~
< ';;; c ",co cQ co", cQ
.. 0 0<0 a.. a.. a.. a.. a.. a..a..za..a.. a.. ...
Q.- a: u ZZ Z zz zz zz Z
Q. II <
<0 .., .., ;:! .., .., ;:?;:! .., .., ;:!
1-1- 1-1- 1-1-
.'
'. .:~
.\
.
LAW OF"F"ICE
DONALD H. MAYNOR
JII. p-=-orCSSIONAl- l....w COR-DO RATION
3220 ALPINE ROAD. SUITE A
PORTOLA VALLEY. CALIFORNIA 94028
(415) 854+8898
;., ~: ':, :..:. ; ".' t:' .~.
, ' -
I~~'.( .f;: ,~}'.,~ "~: '~"'"
.'~ ...
FACSIMILE
(4IS)8S4+8774
January 19, 1996
~'I J~I
'- -' ~ ; ''-" ,.,
"- I . I ~.
Mr. Stephen Garber, Esq.
PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC COMPP~Y
77 Beale Street
San Francisco, CA 94120
Re: Alameda County street Light Acauisition
Dear Mr. Garber:
The purpose of this letter is to respond to your counter-
offer of a sales price of $9 million for PG&E's street lights,
which facilities are located within the pUblic entities that
comprise the Alameda County Street Light Acquisition group.
First, the group appreciates PG&E's willingness to reduce
its original offer to $9 million. Unfortunately, according to
our appraiser, Ms. Nancy Hughes, PG&E's proposed reduction in its
LS-l rates would reduce the value of the PG&E street lights to a
level that is much lower than what is reflected in PG&E's latest
counteroffer. Furthermore, based on our recent discussions with
persons involved in PG&E's general rate case, we have every
reason to believe that PG&E's proposed LS-l rate reduction (which
no party is opposing in the general rate case) will be adopted by
the CPUC in the next several months. The members of the Alameda
County street Light Acquisition group, therefore, respectfully
decline to accept PG&E's latest counteroffer of $9 million.
The group, however, is willing to purchase PG&E's
streetlights at a price based on Ms. Hughes' new appraised value
of PG&E's streetlights, which reflects the proposed decrease in
the LS-1 rates. I have enclosed:a copy of Ms. Hughes' appraisal
summary of November 1, 1995, which has been approved by each of
the group members. The group's new counteroffer of
$3,439,388.00, revokes all prior offers by the group or any of
its members.
If PG&E is willing to accept the group's counteroffer of
$3,439,388.00, please let us know as soon as possible. The
group's offer will remain open until 5:00 p.m. January 29, 1996.
pi< ~/~.J. ~ fJ! ~~ 1l
,r:':.-n~o~ ~ -..._"'\",
......_;:'\, ---
l-ctt* ~( ~if
Mr. stephen Garber, Esq.
December 20, 1995
Page 2
In the meantime, the members of the Alameda County street
Light Acquisition group will begin scheduling public hearings for
the adoption of Resolutions of Necessity. The group members are
doing this to avoid any additional delay in being placed on
PG&E's LS-2 rate tariffs, regardless of how the necessary status
of streetlight ownership is finally achieved, whether by
negotiation or condemnation. The adoption of Resolutions of
Necessity, therefore, does not rule out further negotiations.
Thank you again for your kind cooperation.
Sincerely,
~1){.
DONALD H. MAYNOR
DHM:cyc
CC: Alameda County street Light Acquisition Representatives
Nancy Hughes
Russell Hamm
C:\WP60\F\ACSlA\AlBANY\DOC1.SGl
e
e:.
.
..-"...
, -
APPRAISAL OF FACILITIES TO BE ACQUIRED FROM
PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY
BY THE
ALAMEDA COUNTY STREET LIGHT ACQUISITION GROUP
FAIR MARKET VALUE
November 1, 1995
Line Number Fair Market Value
No. Agency of Lights Value Per Light
1 Alban y 697 $63,201 $90.68
2 Dublin 1 ,354 133,689 98.74
3 Emeryville 515 43,249 83.98
4 Fremont 2,091 148,492 71.01
5 Ha yward 6,571 695,284 105.81
6 Livermore 3,199 278,418 87.03
7 Newark 1,896 166,502 87.82
8 Piedmont 691 46,930 67.92
.'.: 9 Pleasanton 4,416 489,599 110.87
10 San Leandro 3,872 283,206 73.14
11 Union City 2,280 232,985 102.19
12 Alameda County 6,739 857,833 127.29
13 Total 34,321 $3,439,388 $100.21
.
R. W. Beck
Pripi1rxrd mId Cml!idrlltinl
11/(,/Q5
~.f Ijt
.' ~<~:I;(/.
.I1~~~~~~~
iJ')I~ ~ ~_,
, ~.",. ~!~ .j))/
,.~ (:-~,//
'!.J~
CITY OF DUBLIN
PO. Box 2340. Dublin. Ca:'c,rnla 94568 · City Offices. 100 CIVIC Plaza. Dublin. cailforn,.
NOTICE OF EXEMPTION
DATE:
TO:
PREPARED BY:
PROJECT TITLE:
NAME OF PERSON OR AGENCY
CARRYING OUT THE PROJECT:
CONTACT PERSON:
SUBJECT:
PROJECT LOCATION:
PROJECT DESCRlPTION:
EXEMPT STATUS:
REASONS PROJECT IS EXEMPT:
Do: IstlileS I1ucampl
April 11, 1994
FILED
ALAMEDA COUNTY
JUN 0 9 19~4
~~::
County Clerk
County of Alameda
City of Dublin
Alameda County Street Light Acquisition
CIIBr'S ~'T~~:: C~ ~, Putt .. ~
I cu:fH'y tl-..-:~ 0: ~p,' of 'hi$. dtx:umofttWas ~
City of Dublin et the Ctt..~h~lse, Oakland, CA., for the
prescribed by f:Jw.
Elttutad at
Carol R. Cirelli, Sr. Planner ~, Ce. COUHTY o.suc
.~...f.f1CRY~TAL ~. CARN~
Categorical Exemption. .,:.,
County of Alameda and Cities of Albany, Dublin,
Emeryville, Fremont, Hayward, Livennore, Newark,
Piedmont, Pleasanton, San Leandro, and Union City.
The joint acquisition of all PG&E street lights currently in
place within the jurisdiction and boundaries of each of the
above cities and Alameda County.
-
Categorical Exemption, Section 15301(b), Class 1
Project consists of acquisition of all PG&E street lights
currently in place and to maintain the street lights with
only minor alteration of the current facilities during this
acquisition.
.
a+tfJ~'
Carol R. rrelli, Sr. Planner
.-.
Administration (510) 833-6650. City Council (510) 833-6605. Finane
Code Enforcement (510) 833-6620 · Engineering (51 (
Police (510) 833-6670 · Put-he Works (510) 833-6.
".r.. <W ~l.ll ~ l."', ;j.... .,..
't:1\nti ~li ~ .........J-".---
t\)o+1et- ert f)t.~~1\rtirl\
.'~,..
.'
*~ONMrnNTALDECLARATION
(CALIF. FISH AND GAME CODE SEC. 711.4)
NAME AND ADDRESS OF APPLICANT 1 LEAD AGENCY:
FOR COURT USE ONI.. Y
City of Dublin
1 00 Civic Plaza
Dublin. California 94568
Filing No. d / g:J If
,
CLASSIFICA nON OF ENVIRONMENTAL DOCUMENT:
CLERK'S USE ONI.. Y
1. NOTICE OF EXEMPTION/ST A TEMENT OF EXEMPTION PLU 117
[,J] A - STATUTORll..Y OR CATEGORICALLY EXEMPT
$25.00 (Twenty-Five Dollars) - CLERK'S FEE
Alameda County Street Light Acquisition
[ ] B.- DE MINIMUS IMPACT - CERTIFICATE OF FEE PLU 117
EXEMPTION REQUIRED
$25.00 (Twenty-Five Dollars) - CLERK'S FEE
.
::\ 2. NOTICE OF DETERMINATION - FEE REQUIRED
,.
[ ] A - NEGATIVE DECLARATION
$1,250 (Twelve Hundred Fifty Dollars) PLU 116
STATE FILING FEE
$25.00 (Twenty-Five Dollars) - CLERK'S FEE
[] B - ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT
$850 (Eight Hundred Fifty Dollars) PLU 115
STATE FILING FEE
$25.00 (Twenty-Five Dollars) - CLERK'S FEE
3. [ ] OTIffiR (SPECIFY) PLU 117
$25.00 (Twenty-Five Dollars) - CLERK'S FEE
i * THIS FORM MUST BE COMPLETED AND .SUBMITTED WITH ALL ENVIRONMENTAL
DOCUMENTS Fll..ED WITH THE ALAMEDA COUNTY CLERK'S OFFICE.
FOUR COPIES OF ALL NECESSARY DOCUMENTATION ARE REQUIRED FOR FILING
PURPOSES.
APPLICABLE FEES MUST BE PAID AT TIIE TIME OF FILING AN ENVIRONMENTAL
DOCUMENT WlTII THE ALAMEDA COUNTY CLERK'S OFFICE.
MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO: ALAMEDA COUNTY CLERK
e- Rev. 1/15/91 .1056C