Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
6.3 MAD 83-2 PubHear
l - CITY OF DUBLIN AGENDA STATEMENT City Council Meeting Date: July 26, 1993 SUBJECT: Public Hearing: Landscaping and Lighting District No. 83-2 (Tract 4719) Report by: Public Works Director Lee Thompson EXHIBITS ATTACHED: 1) opy of notice and newsletter sent to property owners 2) ,,List of protests received (copies of actual protests to be available at meeting for review) 3) /Engineer's Report (Alternate A - as preliminarily approved) 4) /Resolution approving Engineer's Report (Alt. A), confirming diagram and assessment, and ordering levy of assessment. 5) /Assessment Diagram 6) , Copy of July 22, 1993 Notice to Residents regarding request for landscaping work on Stagecoach Road. 7) /Alternate B Engineer's Report showing higher assessment. 8) / Alternate resolution approving engineer's report (Alt. B), confirming diagram and assessment, and ordering levy of assessment (for higher assessment) 9) / Schematic plan details for the relandscaping of Stagecoach Road slopes RECOMMENDATION: 1) Open public hearing V - Receive Staff report and public comment A/e )) Question Staff and the public 4) Continue public hearing to meeting of August 9, 1993 5) Give Staff additional direction as appropriate FINANCIAL STATEMENT: The 1993-94 assessment as preliminarily approved in the Preliminary Engineer's Report is proposed to be $228.72 per single-family lot and $38.68 per multi-family (condominium) lot (total of$21,351.36 for Amador Lakes). An alternate plan for an increased assessment for landscape work on the interior would be $265.36 per single-family lot. The assessment per multi-family lot would remain at $38.68 since the single-family homes provide 100% of the funding for the interior slopes. DESCRIPTION: The Conditions of Approval for development of Tract 4719 required that a homeowners' association be formed to maintain certain common landscaping improvements within the Tract. Landscaping and Lighting Assessment District No. 1983-2 was formed at the request of the developer as an alternative to providing landscaping maintenance through the Amador Lakes and Dublin Hills Estates homeowners' associations. Scope of Work and Assessment Spread This District maintains landscaping and irrigation on the slopes along Stagecoach Road and also on the "interior" slopes of the Dublin Hills Estates development on Agate Way and Coral Way. The cost of maintenance of the Stagecoach Road landscaping is spread 60% to the Amador Lakes development, divided among the 552 condominium lots, and 40% to the Dublin Hills Estates development, divided among the 150 single-family lots. The "interior slopes" maintenance is spread among the 150 single-family lots only. New Assessment District Regulations State Law previously required that one annual public hearing be held for 1972 Act Lighting and Landscaping Assessment Districts, and that a 10-day notice of the hearing be published in a local ITEM NO. . COPIES TO: Ron Nahas CITY C L E R K clicI kIJOl-1,2InI 5 1 newspaper and posted in the City's three posting places. Staff has typically exceeded those requirements by mailing a notice and newsletter to the property owners approximately two weeks prior to the hearing date. The State's noticing and hearing requirements changed in 1993 to require that 45-day notices be mailed to all property owners affected by the assessment district, and that two public hearings be held. The first public hearing is for the purpose of taking testimony only; no action is to be taken by the City Council until the second public hearing. Protests Received In accordance with State Law, Staff mailed notices to property owners in this District on Thursday, June 24, 1993 (Exhibit 1). As of the date of writing this Staff Report, 6 single-family protests had been received. Staff estimates that the area of property owned by those protesting is approximately 2.4% of the total assessable property area in this assessment district. State Law provides that a protest consisting of owners of over 50% of the land area of assessable property would cause automatic abandonment of the assessment for 1993-94. Proposed Assessment The District diagram remains the same as last year's. Based on the approved Preliminary Engineer's Report, the proposed assessment for the 1993-94 Fiscal Year is $55,659.36, which is approximately $7,681.92 lower than last year's assessment. This is due to a one-time assessment increase for 1992- 93 to pay for additional landscaping replacement on the interior slopes and to develop a schematic plan for the relandscaping of the Stagecoach Road slopes: Proposed Relandscaping of the Stagecoach Road Slopes The landscape architectural firm of David Gates and Associates was retained to develop schematic plans (Exhibit 9) for the three large Stagecoach Road slopes to improve the aesthetics of the slopes and to design the landscaping so as to reduce future water and maintenance costs. The chronic District problem has been that the area of landscaping to be maintained in this District is relatively large for the number of property owners who must pay the maintenance costs. The budgets have only allowed for watering, fertilizing, weeding, and a small amount of plant material replacement. This District has been plagued with problems such as drought, ground squirrels, snails, heavy freeze, and a vandalism problem higher than any other part of Dublin. The budgets have not been able to afford the massive renovation needed to keep the landscaping in first-class condition. The new schematic plan developed by David Gates and Associates was reviewed with the homeowners who attended the neighborhood meeting on July 15th (10 people representing 7 homes, plus a representative from the Amador Lakes Apartment development). This plan would accentuate the corner monument areas (15) with colorful perennial flowers and flowering trees, would place a hedgerow at the upper fence line on drip or bubbler irrigation, provide a row of bushes to outline the upper edge of the existing Vinca groundcover on the lower 20 feet of the slopes, provide new tree clusters, and would return the upper middle one-third to one-half of the slopes to non-irrigated native grasses. This plan will be presented and reviewed at this first public hearing. The estimated cost for these improvements is in the $80- to $100,000 range, and the savings in water and maintenance would be in the $7- to $8,000 range per year. The consensus of the homeowners at the neighborhood meeting was to increase the assessment for the single-family homes to $300 for this Fiscal Year to begin making improvements to the slopes, and that the first priority would be the corner monument areas. Unfortunately, Mr. Ron Nahas, who represents the Amador Lakes development, was not able to attend the neighborhood meeting. Staff has since talked to Mr. Nahas to obtain his feelings toward the landscape upgrade and resulting costs. The Amador Lakes development would be paying 60% of the additional costs based on the formula that the District was established on. Mr. Nahas feels that there is not enough return in savings for the proposed expenditure and is not in favor of increasing the assessment. He feels the assessment should be set as approved in the preliminary Engineer's Report. He has, however, offered to take over the maintenance of the strip of landscaping along the sidewalk fronting Amador Lakes for three years to save the District money, which could then be used for adding landscaping on the Stagecoach slopes. This savings to the District would be about $1,250 per year. Since Amador Lakes represents approximately 40% of the District for protest purposes, it would not be prudent to approve this higher assessment at this time and risk a majority protest. Page 2 I' '1 As an alternative to raising the assessments for the Stagecoach Road slopes, a proposal has been made to leave the assessments the same as the 1992-93 assessments for the single-family homes and use the money to further improve the interior slopes on Agate Way and Coral Way. This would increase the proposed assessment from $228.68 to $265.36 per single family home and would raise $5,232. An Alternate B Engineer's Report and revised Resolution which reflect these changes have been included for review. Recommendation Staff recommends that the City Council open the public hearing, receive Staff's presentation, take testimony from Staff and the public, and continue the public hearing to the meeting of August 9, 1993. Staff also requests that the City Council provide any additional direction, as appropriate, regarding the proposed assessment alternatives. At the August 9th meeting, the Council will to take additional testimony and then to act upon the Engineer's Report for the 1993-94 fiscal year. a:(ad)I83-2183-2ph • Page 3 1 t NOTICE OF ASSESSMENT LANDSCAPING AND LIGHTING MAINTENANCE ASSESSMENT DISTRICT 83-2 (STAGECOACH ROAD) This assessment district funds the maintenance of landscaping improvements along Stagecoach Road and on the "interior slopes" of Jade Circle/Agate Way and Topaz Circle/Coral Way. The district was formed as an alternative to utilizing a homeowner's association to maintain the landscaping. The activities funded by this assessment district include irrigation maintenance(including utility costs), weeding, pruning, fertilizing, and other activities associated with maintenance of landscapes. The assessment for this district is spread between the property owners of the Amador Lakes Apartments, who pay 60% of the cost of Stagecoach Road landscape maintenance, and the property owners of the 150 single-family homes of the Dublin Hills Estates development, who pay 40% of the cost of Stagecoach Road landscape maintenance and 100% of the cost of the interior slopes landscape maintenance. The assessment for the 1993-94 tax year is proposed to be as follows: Single-family lots: $228.72 per lot; Amador Lakes apartment lots: $38.68 per apartment The above figures reflect the estimated cost for maintenance in Fiscal Year 1993-94 but do not include funds for revising the existing landscaping. If you are interested in paying an increased assessment in order to fund relandscaping of this assessment district(similar to the increase requested for 1992-93), please let us know either by letter or at the informational meeting. The amount of the assessment must ultimately be approved by the City Council. ENGINEER'S REPORT Copies of the Preliminary Engineer's Report for this assessment district are available at the City Offices, 100 Civic Plaza, Dublin, California 94568. The Engineer's Reports explain the scope of work, a breakdown of the costs that are proposed to be paid by the assessment district, and the method of proportioning the assessments between the single-family and apartment/condominium lots. INFORMATIONAL MEETING An informational meeting will be held on July 15, 1993, at 7:00 p.m. in the Regional Meeting Room of the Dublin Civic Center, 100 Civic Plaza, for the purpose of answering questions and discussing the activities which have taken place in this assessment district during the past year and those activities planned for the future. Property owners are encouraged to attend this informational meeting. If you are unable to attend but wish to provide input, please feel free to call or write the Public Works Department prior to the meeting. PUBLIC HEARINGS Two public hearings will be held for the purpose of hearing protests regarding this assessment. At the first hearing, on July 26, 1993, the City Council will take testimony from the public. At the second hearing, on August 9, 1993, the City Council will again take testimony and then consider and act upon the Engineer's Reports. The public hearings will be held at regular City Council meetings, which begin at 7:30 p.m. These meetings will be held in the Council Chambers of the Dublin Civic Center, 100 Civic Plaza, Dublin. PROTESTS If you wish to protest this assessment, your protest must be made in writing and must be sent to the City of Dublin, 100 Civic Plaza, Dublin, California 94568. Protests must be received no later than the close of the second public hearing as listed above. Your protest should include both the street address of the property and the assessor's parcel number(APN) of the property. The APN is shown on the mailing label for this notice. You may use the form below and/or write a letter which includes the information on the form. The Landscaping and Lighting Act of 1972 provides that a majority protest, which would consist of property owners of over 50% of the land area of the property being assessed, would cause the abandonment of the assessment. Please feel free to call the Public Works Department at(510) 833-6630 if you have any questions. PROTEST-Landscaping and Lighting Maintenance Assessment District 83-2 (Stagecoach Road) I/we, , protest the assessment under Landscaping and Lighting Maintenance Assessment District#83-2 proposed to be levied on the property assigned Parcel Number - - - located at in the City of Dublin. (address) I am/we are owner(s) of the above parcel: (signature) (signature) If you are not listed as owner(s)on the last equalized roll,you must provide written evidence r I be liable to pay the proposed assessment. STAGECOACH ROAD(TRACT 4719) LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE ASSESSMENT DISTRICT NEWSLETTER FACTS ABOUT THE ASSESSMENT DISTRICT This assessment district was formed in 1983 for the purpose of maintaining certain landscaping improvements along Stagecoach Road and on the"interior slopes"of the Dublin Hills Estates development(Coral Way and Agate Way). The following areas are being maintained by the City at the present time: • Landscaping and irrigation within the road right-of-way and within a public easement along Stagecoach Road between Amador Valley Boulevard and the northerly City Limit. • Slopes and landscaping and irrigation of the slopes within a public easement for those slope areas to the rear of Lots 80 through 86 and 37 through 48 of Tract 4719. These are the"interior slopes"which face houses on Agate Way and Coral Way. In order to arrive at the annual assessment,estimated maintenance costs for the ensuing year are divided among residents of the single-family homes of Dublin Hills Estates and the owners of the Amador Lakes Apartments as follows: • Sixty percent(60%)of the annual cost of maintaining the landscaping within and along Stagecoach Road has been assigned to the 552 apartment/condominium lots of Amador Lakes,distributed on an equal basis. The remaining 40%of this annual cost has been divided equally among the 150 single-family lots in Dublin Hills Estates. • The cost of maintaining the excavated slopes,concrete culverts,and landscaping on the interior slopes of the single-family area(Agate Way and Coral Way)is divided evenly among the 150 Dublin Hills Estates lots. The monies collected through assessments are accounted for separately from other City funds. These funds can only be used for specified expenses within the boundaries of the Assessment District. LANDSCAPING For Fiscal Year 1992-93,property owners requested and the City Council approved a one-time increase in the assessment in order to fund some plant replacements that were not otherwise funded and also to obtain the services of a landscape architect to prepare a preliminary plan to relandscape the Stagecoach Road slopes. The intent of the plan is to provide a landscape which is less maintenance intensive and also drought tolerant. David Gates and Associates was chosen by a committee of property owners,and he is presently working on the plan. It is hoped that a report on the plan can be made at the July 15th neighborhood meeting. To date,35 trees have been replaced along Stagecoach Road. A volunteer project is planned for June 26th to plant approximately 800 star jasmine plants in the planter strip along the Coral Way and Agate Way interior slopes. IRRIGATION Since last year,the City has experienced a 9%increase in the cost of water from the Dublin San Ramon Services District, and we are anticipating another increase in January of 1994. Unfortunately,vandalism of irrigation heads,while not as bad as in past years,is still a problem. The irrigation systems installed in this District were installed to water erosion control grasses,not permanent landscaping. The result is a less-than-efficient system. The City's maintenance department is appreciative of residents who have called regarding broken sprinklers. Our response to these requests will continue to be immediate so that water won't be wasted. PARK IMPROVEMENTS The cost of park maintenance for the Dougherty Hills Open Space and Stagecoach Park,is paid entirely by the City and is not charged to the assessment district. The City's park masterplans include a number of future improvements for the Dougherty Hills Park(the"hill"to the east of Stagecoach Road). To date,trails have been cut to allow hiking on the hill. Due to the City's present budget constraints,the Five Year Capital Improvement Program currently lists any future plans or improvements for this area as unfunded. The residents of Topaz Circle petitioned the City Council,Zone 7 Flood Control,and the Dublin San Ramon Services District to aid in providing trees and bushes along the faces of the Dougherty Hills slopes which front Topaz Circle. The City Council allotted$17,000,and DSRSD and Zone 7 have allotted$11,000 to landscape the access to the water reservoir. The neighbors have provided the labor to install the plant materials and irrigation,and this project is nearly complete. The City will be responsible for the maintenance of these new improvements as part of the park maintenance budget. If you have any questions about the proposed assessment or the maintenance activities in this district,or if you wish to report an irrigation problem,please feel free to call the City's Public Works Department at 833-6630. • PROTESTS RECEIVED - STAGECOACH LANDSCAPING & LIGHTING ASSESSMENT DISTRICT 83-2 As of: July 22, 1993 • Name Address APN Astrow 6754 Onyx Place 941-2769-050-00 Azar 7674 Turquoise Street 941-2769-004-00 Cearley 6740 Pearl Place 941-2769-040-00 Goldstein 7375 Quartz Circle 941-2755-046-00 Moresi 7691 Topaz Circle 941-2769-084-00 Witham 6742 Onyx Place 941-2769-051-00 r obeepro.9is Alternate "A" As Preliminarily Approved CITY OF DUBLIN LANDSCAPING AND LIGHTING DISTRICT NO. 1983-2 (TRACT 4719) FISCAL YEAR 1993-94 ENGINEER'S REPORT CONTENTS 1. Assessment: Including Scope of Work, Estimate of Costs, Assessment Roll, and Method of Apportioning. 2. Assessment Diagram • ASSESSMENT WHEREAS, on January 25, 1993, the City Council of the City of Dublin, California, pursuant to the provisions of the Landscaping and Lighting Act of 1972, adopted its Resolution Directing Preparation of Annual Report for Maintenance Assessment District 1983-2 for the maintenance of improvements more particularly therein described; and WHEREAS, said Resolution directed the undersigned to prepare and file a report pursuant to Section 22565, et. seq., of said Act; NOW, THEREFORE, the undersigned, by virtue of the power vested in me under said Act and the order of the Council of said City, hereby make the following assessment to cover the portion of the estimated cost of the maintenance of said improvements and the cost and expenses incidental thereto, to be paid by said District. ESTIMATE OF COSTS (1) (2) (3) As Filed As Preliminarily As Finally Approved Approved Cost of Maintenance $ 52,500.00 $ 52,500.00 Incidental Expenses $ 13,468.36 $ 13,468.36 TOTAL COST: $ 65,968.36 $ 65,968.36 Estimated 1993-94 Interest Income Applied to 1993-94 Operating Costs: $ (430.00) $ (430.00) Est. Surplus from 1992-93 Fiscal Year $ (9,879.00) $ (9,879.00) NET TO BE ASSESSED FOR FISCAL YEAR 1993-94 $ 55,659.36 $ 55,659.36 As required by said Act, a diagram is hereto attached showing the exterior boundaries of said landscaping maintenance assessment district and also the lines and dimensions of each lot or parcel of land within said landscaping maintenance assessment district as the same existed at the time of the passage of said resolution, each of which lots or parcels having been given a separate number upon said diagram. I do hereby assess the net amount to be assessed upon all assessable lots or parcels of land within said landscaping maintenance assessment district by apportioning that amount among the several lots or parcels in proportion to the estimated benefits to be received by each such lot or parcel from the maintenance of said improvements, and more particularly set forth in the list hereto attached and by reference made a part hereof. Said assessment is made upon the several lots or parcels of land within said landscaping maintenance assessment district in proportion to the estimated benefits to be received by said lots or parcels respectively from the maintenance of said improvements. The diagram and assessment 2 numbers appearing herein are the diagram numbers appearing on said diagram, to which reference is hereby made for a more particular description of said property. Each lot or parcel of land assessed is described in the assessment list by reference to its parcel number as shown on the Assessor's Maps of the County of Alameda for the Fiscal Year 1993- 94 and includes all of such parcels excepting those portions thereof within existing public roads or rights of way to be acquired in these proceedings for public road purposes. For a more particular description of said property, reference is hereby made to the deeds and maps on file and of record in the office of the County Recorder of said County. Because the names of the several owners are unknown to me, I hereby place the word "unknown" opposite the number of each lot of parcel of land assessed, the amount assessed thereon, and khe number of the assessment. Dated: May 24, 1993 City Engineer • 3 ENGINEER'S COST ESTIMATE FISCAL YEAR 1993-94 The estimated cost for the maintenance of improvements described in this Report for Fiscal Year 1992-93 is as follows: Maintenance • Street and Slopes, Stagecoach Road: $33,569.00 • Slopes, Interior: 18,931.00 $52,500.00 Incidentals • Engineer's Report and proceedings: $ 1,108.00 • Cost of Collection (County of Alameda): 946.21 • Delinquencies: 1,665.15 • Contingencies/Reserve: 9349.00 $13,468.36 TOTAL: $65,968.36 4 • • METHOD OF APPORTIONING Sixty percent (60%) of the annual cost of maintaining the landscaping within and along Stagecoach Road has been assigned to the 552 condominium lots within the multifamily portion of the original Tract 4719, disributed on an equal basis. The balance of this annual cost has been divided equally among Lots 1 through 150, inclusive, of Tract 4719. The cost of maintaining the excavated slopes and concrete culverts together with its landscaping on the interior slopes of the single-family area (excluding those slopes and concrete culverts adjacent to Stagecoach Road) shall be evenly spread over Lots 1 through 150 of Tract 4719. Lots 152 and 153, being park and open space, shall have a zero assessment. Lots 154 and 155, being public agency owned, shall have a zero assessment. 5 • SCOPE OF WORK The scope of work shall be the maintenance of landscaping and irrigation within the road right-of-way and within a public easement along Stagecoach Road between the limits of Amador Valley Boulevard and the northerly City Limit. Further, the scope of work shall include the maintenance of the slopes and landscaping and irrigation of the slopes within a public easement for those slope areas to the rear of Lots 80 through 86 and 37 through 48, all within Tract 4719. 6 ASSESSMENT ROLL Amount of Assessment Assessment & Lot No. Property Owners 1993-94 Tax Year Lots 1-150 Tr. 4719 Unknown $228.72/lot = $34,308.00 Lot 152 Tr. 4719 Unknown -0- Lot 153 Tr. 4719 Unknown -0- Lot 154 Public-Owned -0- Lot 155 Public-Owned -0- Lots 1-552 Tr. 5180 Unknown $ 38.68/d.u. 21,351.36 TOTAL: $55,659.36 7 CITY OF DUBLIN LANDSCAPING AND LIGHTING MAINTENANCE ASSESSMENT DISTRICT 83-2 CERTIFICATIONS FISCAL YEAR 1993-94 I, the City Clerk of the City of Dublin, California, hereby certify that the foregoing Engineer's Report, including Assessment, in the amounts set forth in Column (1), with the diagram thereto attached, was filed with me on May 24, 1993. i_� i_ .:Si OL I, the City Clerk of the City of Dublin, California, hereby certi' that the foregoing Assessment, with the diagram thereto attached, was preliminarily approved and confirmed by the City Council of said City by its Resolution No. 62-93 duly adopted by said Cr fr it on 4, 1993. SiI S 1 I, the City Clerk of the City of Dublin, California, hereby - -fy that the foregoing Assessment, with the diagram thereto attached, was finally approved and confirmed by the City Council of said City by its Resolution No. -93, duly adopted by said Council on August 9, 1993. I, the City Clerk of the City of Dublin, California, hereby certify that a certified copy of the Assessment and diagram was filed in the office of the County Auditor of the County of Alameda, California, on , 1993. 8 RESOLUTION NO. -93 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL' OF THE CITY OF DUBLIN APPROVING ENGINEER'S REPORT, CONFIRMING DIAGRAM AND ASSESSMENT, AND ORDERING LEVY OF ASSESSMENT CITY OF DUBLIN LANDSCAPING AND LIGHTING MAINTENANCE ASSESSMENT DISTRICT 83-2 (STAGECOACH ROAD) WHEREAS, by its Resolution No. 21-93, a Resolution Directing Preparation of Annual Report for City of Dublin Landscaping and Lighting Maintenance Assessment District No. _83-2 (the "District"), this Council designated the City Engineer as Engineer of Work and ordered said Engineer to make and file a report in writing in accordance with and pursuant to the Landscaping and Lighting Act of 1972; and WHEREAS, said report was made and fired with the City Clerk and duly considered by this Council and found to be sufficient in every particular, whereupon it was determined that said report should stand as Engineer's Report for all subsequent proceedings under and pursuant to the aforesaid Resolution and that July 26, 1993 and August 9, 1993, at 7:30 p.m. in the Council Chambers, Dublin Civic Center, 100 Civic Plaza, Dublin, California, were appointed as the time and place for a hearing by the Council on the question of the levy of the proposed assessment, notice of which hearing was mailed, published and posted in accordance with Government Code Section 54954.6; and WHEREAS, at the appointed time and place, said hearings were held, and all persons interested desiring to be heard were given an opportunity to be heard, and all matters pertaining to said levy were heard and considered by this Council, and this Council thereby acquired jurisdiction to order said levy and confirmation of diagram and assessment prepared by and made a part of the report of said engineer to pay the cost and expenses thereof; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Dublin does hereby approve that: . (a) The property owners owning more than fifty percent of the area of assessable land within the District had not, at the conclusion of said hearing, filed written protests against the said proposed levy, or against the Engineer's Estimate of costs and expenses, or against the maps and description, or against the diagram or the assessment to pay for the costs and expenses thereof; (b) The public interest, convenience, and necessity require that said levy be made; (c) The District benefited by said improvements and to be assessed to pay the costs and expenses thereof, and the exterior boundaries thereof, are as shown by a map thereof filed in the office of the City Clerk, which map is made a part hereof by reference thereto. PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this 9th day of August, 1993. AYES: NOES: ABSENT: . Mayor ATTEST: City Clerk a:(ad)183-2183-21evy !� I�esvl.utz.a,n, � 4' yc . • • CEGENO 11:7 "• .- • .i { =.v T/oc/Mwdory • -- O Exisfn9 Momnrnf • _ .. -so., P1/a AL6/c /J/Yy con)! sae.E Arm o,v.;•, Elm t Ne. 99.E. ea+bt./y?vtor GF.lirw./ 0 200 400 600 ;; Je;A�h• r ` t/ !/ / AO.Mar 7 lip AIs of Agar. SCALE Si FEET J `J I! -I�;{ TRACT 4719 - Brian, - d . LI / kn.rcn•w AlySO.°• AC FC FWO Z0VE7 --esaw 1�� .f 1 ,VtWitlT'l. 154 �=1 A g O Nle•/l:frN1-' /53 _� \ m o NS AO 4 7113 NN'/)ilo•N {{tl1 Nso:V'.J'N ' li ` r^ G r N.1 iV1V'MT IA-" I...., •j I 1NlVJt'N i✓ /!N I�'•.. e)f/ I•'` �.A7!!X7 _ 9�(.` ��� 9 N1f/%N'w• ` I �tI7 NNJIYlY I NNY/IlM )I (,I i /kJ 00 : i wwary arl/ `\'‘, n!m I� / ,l.,,At).,aei!• =�\ -.4s• (..n ',. I L.`\ I W rt �)iilrr/ i ,� ` I R• •c DS/tSO NI/b/bl.'I..... { ' •1.,'N':"'t \1 MAW/3W 1 y !./al Ar ��• ti F i7N 4 1 eK S•/aM I�. b... 1�:• 1Q7 �\•6 .t• .8., W \ , IInrst.+n ag � w/:rem xwvtan• � 1\ �%li�:in�'a� �+�''�&"■a+ y iazira»v I, j �� ��'-.7N nuu �, mm©© �� r//A.x.lsr.TO le) A gTat.. `a �� E I INM1u:flf NlJY7%771 A ��I/: /./.•ff[17E• e) Y( ��� , 1s a �pttttt NN:vii7vl,,,. C1RCL ,w)r /x�f ,` TOPAZ ,C/ r/::A/ YriY . •.,! p6 um t•/.:r)tr�� RCCg F/�• •W.A7 ,f. • MOO ,`•.• w.)t 1" •lel& ��.INUb)rr A.,'/!./ lily It.faar 001,1124® /lwM•NX•Y1a92'I.... ® ./� VI'Y IMG/h1YV! 1.:0.1';! � .wYYS1t)•I.1 N!•t•� ��p Q/Ie.Ae It)/ COIIAL Q• NSJ1'ril A• O . © �� • ©� Vitt �m \ 11111:11' NAy�®•` msaetire l� , © OVA I ��-''��•-''r' 15S B•nievY)r I.... C yia) t•!/a �i t Y 4 2�� i ;IT:" ;Oat STAGECOACH \�•'—"r'Lf!'"�'�J ® © $ �tIN�!'.ubt 1 20 / �� / / ;IT:"I" _ lets I R' 11'O�� �© �i•v�vD• �' i • ^��r...rd 3 �ti91.t9 v a W®�� Rp•1 D ..nf \ f AAVVItrc w w .7—I •A' 1PA� 51 ® t fA ; e•10rou t A� ram al ®e /� .1.l+Sa nanvras,�t t..iy! 1/Sa :t�!le /.1. %L•tx07 .1.' IC �•S� it J T•tIJ7Y(re '‘,1.�aq L':<j tPt ; . .10OO57j .T"' t m=®®a®® �© 2 I '•...e)e1/ �� ,Ci 1C• * • 4 ' 8 a•�)Tt a I ...rnb tJ•e Lt•• �z :::e::T a, Nx ;'$NLYIS')YN t V 'tEd e^Lrb $i:�•-....T...< .. xN.p '% . EEt 19 c .Nis. - 1.1C� 9O wa© SR`�IIB I `. [ n.e.10`/fJ ® . �.l1 .re•fl.r ■, ,r I, �•,19.551 .f b` yW 11�.P� i t).4.'1,;. /I.N L..fGe G\ .Y ,® �V•(ill II�� `try.•• Zjje.! RAEOEZAll.A - IE. NY q�.;1:::',�� DETAIL A 1 $I �L %. SNEEt 1 pP 1 �� , P c1f� �MPA I+ WO SCALE , : • A '� ,saf- ealT"t"� ASSESSMENT DIAGRAM Z $ • N65°P'° LANDSCAPING AND LIGHTING• % DISTRICT 1983-2 TRACTS 4719 81 5180 tpo' CITY OF DUBLIN :4 ALAMEDA COUNTY, CALIFORNIA ii �F/SQ�/lfapAU4S SANTINA a THOMPSON INC. JUST, 1919 TSVZSIONI ASS T 5160 OISTRICT LOTS 1-] OF TRACT 5160 7Aje.NonN.r)sn/Gi/e of J/fe�eana•1l2ac)d CIVIL ENGINEERS 77 r' WERE SUBDIVIDED INTO CONDOMINIUMS 'ten as //SJ4 J0•t7L AtEsfaJShavn CONCORD, CALIFORNIA 04 AS AS SHOWN ON DETAIL A OF SHEET 2. on /.t///6,41B4. - FISCAL YEAR 1993/94 SHEET I OF 2 SHEETS CDJ 215 ASSESSMENT DIAGRAM DETAIL A NOTES: THE ASSESSMENT DISTRICT LOT NUMBERS ARE COMPOSED ors a) A Street Lighting �•�Maintenance POUR DIGIT BUILDING NUMBER FOLLOWED BY EACH INDIVIDUAL UNIT Assessment District 83-2 LETTER; OR E) A ONE DIGIT AREA NUMBER FOLLOWED BY THE I.ETECA . •COLD(' TOR TIE COMMON AREAS. • CITY OF DUBLIN E H A D ASSESSMENT I. ALAMEOA COUNTY, CALIFORNIA O O O . DISTRICT COMDL � AREA FISCAL YEAR 1993/94 O O 0 Q' IDT , P G B C \ NUMBER: SCREEN '1'- 200• •8670 8467C .. - lconn. c BLDG 867 ,.,° 9 �1 t MOVOO.30V1S 1 °C2�A'ax-t)4'•.. M3tl093DV15 • n .,� °l'e \+.^i,)(1•I'�Yi• •• 0 Y' 5 _• _\'oz°< -1)5-D-F „ODC?).: —O u a °Ca Cam)-a �° u,5 J'x -O�)- °>C i ▪ �, m( ". e °CiX0'F' : "OT.3 ,,��. ," Cam, ° � .C C =J ° rnt A =▪rte =C�J" „ox,,...ggr\� rC' J° ���(p;�_ °r`?s`=J r�.':mC O�;1• �c `C�-a' m .x p • �. - =®f✓ ' \l/\J 4 -QXD w S\Vo- ._gc.: ' \e)° t -C:-.)a.m•=�.0 L - �� ,J l�l JJ "\pN����° mc�jc�" /\r���' _/�/1m °\'J\ ° ° 7C a ii u ` • I`-C�yay//C��•� :i r(a W P 1% .( C f . XXX� i k ° S.• T.Orint. (n lo .r1 • ... n ; ..GA.il .'CY?)'Sr 'Z '7; .°( Cvx)RX:- (:".K::::.u�j 1 0)1W XT 0)0X) . (C',iCi)e) ' CXJ • =OCR, °, ;�(.) _' I CC� CX� r XX? ?)z Ir( " 'CSC) 4 % C)VIX_ !z.• R E ' r 'CXJ°�° M1 g 7 ' =C•)(�r �d), <O,� C C^ )5 ° "C/y�,yCrM��,.... _ )°a =1/^``{'tl`I°x- �s 0 t `U;...,r :_ • • °aryl:. ° .' sT,7�l I -cm..' ,:. -1-1Kl�, 9 =C]rn° `CrX^Y X� ,dB1%I: { -. = " . -()Mm .rv&1+ : °tin) r, °- "l.t ,�or °mJ• d.Va s a •( - •/ 1 , =l)h"J R s,...J • al • - S .-C,7, J . :,X -(?)®°,.. \^ ° 0n _ • . ` =c&()- � ,_ _( c X .: CJCJ": � _ �° • =�X 1'• °C'�a .' a •c�kP -(v/�;.Z X7 =Oc?D°a rte, • • DETAIL A • SHEET 2 OF 2 CO3315 NOTICE TO PROPERTY OWNERS STAGECOACH ROAD ASSESSMENT DISTRICT July 22, 1993 Dear Property Owner: This letter has a two-fold purpose: first, to remind you of the Assessment District Public Hearings on Monday, July 26th and August 9th, at 7:30 p.m. at the Civic Center(100 Civic Plaza in Dublin), and secondly, to let you know the results of the July 15th neighborhood meeting. Last year, an additional assessment of$45.00 was approved for the 1992-93 fiscal year for the purpose of(1) filling in plant material on the Agate Way and Coral Way interior slopes, and(2)hiring a landscape architect to prepare a conceptual plan for relandscaping the Stagecoach Road slopes. The plant material was installed through a volunteer project at the end of June. The conceptual plan prepared by David Gates and Associates was reviewed by the homeowner committee on July 13th and presented at the neighborhood meeting on July 15th. This plan proposes to retain and enhance the existing trees and ground cover along the bottom of the slope at Stagecoach road, provide a strip of shrubbery at the top of the slope along the existing fence, and allow the center portion of the slope to return to native grasses. The existing irrigation would be modified or replaced with more appropriate, water-saving devices. In addition, it is proposed to emphasize the entries at the corners by using colorful plantings. This would result in a more aesthetic view at the street level and save money for irrigation and maintenance(see enclosed sheets). The proposed 1993-94 assessment of$228.72, which is$36.64 less than the 1992-93 assessment, includes funds for maintenance of existing landscaping but does not include funds to implement any of the Stagecoach Road relandscaping plan. At the neighborhood meeting, it was proposed to increase the assessment in order to begin the work in the Spring of 1994. The consensus of the property owners at the neighborhood meeting was to increase the assessment to$300 per single- family home to generate additional monies to begin the implementation of Stagecoach Road relandscaping. Mr. Ron Nahas, who represents the Amador Lakes apartments and who would be responsible for 60% of the increased costs, has objected on the basis that the the estimated long-range maintenance savings would not justify the relandscaping expenditure. The estimated cost of the total slope relandscaping is in the range of$80-to $100,000, and the annual maintenance and water savings is estimated to be in the range of$7-to$8,000 per year. As an alternate to the above increases, it has been suggested that the single-family homes be assessed at the same rate as was assessed in 1992-93 ($265.36). This would generate an additional$5,232 to be used on the upgrading of the two interior slopes (Agate Way and Coral Way). City Staff will be presenting the options at the City Council meetings on July 26th and August 9th. We encourage you to attend this meeting and present your views. If you cannot attend either of the meetings; you may respond in writing prior to the August 9th meeting. No final decisions will be made until the close of the public hearing on August 9th. If you have any questions, please feel free to call my office at(510) 833-6630. Sincerely, Lee S. Thompson Public Works Director LST/gr r 77—• :77 .,t7 a:(ad)183-2183-21tr h Ira_ On-n nt.-rO'la2.oPER.T%) OcutJeZS Alternate "B" Increase single-family assessment to match 1992-93 assessments CITY OF DUBLIN LANDSCAPING AND LIGHTING DISTRICT NO. 1983-2 (TRACT 4719) FISCAL YEAR 1993-94 REVISED ENGINEER'S REPORT CONTENTS 1. Assessment: Including Scope of Work, Estimate of Costs, Assessment Roll, and Method of Apportioning. 2. Assessment Diagram 691Aa.a.VS (2& - ArLf ASSESSMENT WHEREAS, on January 25, 1993, the City Council of the City of Dublin, California, pursuant to the provisions of the Landscaping and Lighting Act of 1972, adopted its Resolution Directing Preparation of Annual Report for Maintenance Assessment District 1983-2 for the maintenance of improvements more particularly therein described; and WHEREAS, said Resolution directed the undersigned to prepare and file a report pursuant to Section 22565, et. seq., of said Act; NOW, THEREFORE, the undersigned, by virtue of the power vested in me under said Act and the order of the Council of said City, hereby make the following assessment to cover the portion of the estimated cost of the maintenance of said improvements and the cost and expenses incidental thereto, to be paid by said District. ESTIMATE OF COSTS As(1) (2) (3) Filed As Pr liminarily As Finally Approved Approved REVISED TOTALS Cost of Maintenance $ 52,500.00 $ 52,500.00 $ 57,732.36 Incidental Expenses $ 13,468.36 $ 13.468.36 $ 13,732.00 TOTAL COST: $ 65,968.36 $ 65,968.36 $ 71,464.36 Estimated 1993-94 Interest Income Applied to 1993-94 Operating Costs: $ (430.00) $ (430.00) $ (430.00) Est. Surplus from 1992-93 Fiscal Year $ (9,879.00), $ (9,879.00) $ (9,879.00), NET TO BE ASSESSED FOR FISCAL YEAR 1993-94 $ 55,659.36 $ 55,659.36 $ 61,155.36 As required by said Act, a diagram is hereto attached showing the exterior boundaries of said landscaping maintenance assessment district and also the lines and dimensions of each lot or parcel of land within said landscaping maintenance assessment district as the same existed at the time of the passage of said resolution, each of which lots or parcels having been given a separate number upon said diagram. I do hereby assess the net amount to be assessed upon all assessable lots or parcels of land within said landscaping maintenance assessment district by apportioning that amount among the several lots or parcels in proportion to the estimated benefits to be received by each such lot or parcel from the maintenance of said improvements, and more particularly set forth in the list hereto attached and by reference made a part hereof. Said assessment is made upon the several lots or parcels of land within said landscaping maintenance assessment district in proportion to the estimated benefits to be received by said lots or • parcels respectively from the maintenance of said improvements. The diagram and assessment numbers appearing herein are the diagram numbers appearing on said diagram, to which reference is hereby made for a more particular description of said property. Each lot or parcel of land assessed is described in the assessment list by reference to its parcel number as shown on the Assessor's Maps of the County of Alameda for the Fiscal Year 1993- 94 and includes all of such parcels excepting those portions thereof within existing public roads or rights of way to be acquired in these proceedings for public road purposes. For a more particular description of said property, reference is hereby made to the deeds and maps on file and of record in the office of the County Recorder of said County. Because the names of the several owners are unknown to me, I hereby place the word "unknown" opposite the number of each lot of parcel of land assessed, the amount assessed thereon, and the number of the assessment. Dated: May 24, 1993 Engineer • 1 • ENGINEER'S COST ESTIMATE FISCAL YEAR 1993-94 The estimated cost for the maintenance of improvements described in this Report for Fiscal Year 1992-93 is as follows: Maintenance • Street and Slopes, Stagecoach Road: $33,569.00 • Slopes, Interior: 18,931.00 $52,500.00 Additional Work on the interior slopes of Coral Way and Agate Way • Addition of trees and bushes along existing slopes $ 5,232.36 Incidentals • Engineer's Report and proceedings: $ 1,108.00 • Cost of Collection (County of Alameda): 946..21 1,040.00 • Delinquencies: ---13665.45 1,835.00 • Contingencies/Reserve: 9.749.00 $43-,468 46 $13,732.00 TOTAL: $65,-96836 $71,464.36 • METHOD OF APPORTIONING Sixty percent (60%) of the annual cost of maintaining the landscaping within;and along Stagecoach Road has been assigned to the 552 condominium lots within the multifamily portion of the original Tract 4719, disributed on an equal basis. The balance of this annual cost has been divided equally among Lots 1 through 150, inclusive, of Tract 4719. The cost of maintaining the excavated slopes and concrete culverts together with its landscaping on the interior slopes of the single-family area (excluding those slopes and concrete culverts adjacent to Stagecoach Road) shall be evenly spread over Lots 1 through 150 of Tract 4719. Lots 152 and 153, being park and open space, shall have a zero assessment. Lots 154 and 155, being public agency owned, shall have a zero assessment. • SCOPE OF WORK The scope of work shall be the maintenance of landscaping and irrigation within the road right-of-way and within a public easement along Stagecoach Road between the limits of Amador Valley Boulevard and the northerly City Limit. Further, the scope of work shall include the maintenance of the slopes and landscaping and irrigation of the slopes within a public easement for those slope areas to the rear of Lots 80 through 86 and 37 through 48, all within Tract 4719. ASSESSMENT ROLL , Assessment & Amt of Assmt Revised Lot No. Property Owners 1993-94 FY Assessment Lots 1-150 Tr. 4719 Unknown $-22$-7.2flet = $-3¢,- $265.36/lot = $39,804.00 Lot 152 Tr. 4719 Unknown -0- -0- Lot 153 Tr. 4719 Unknown -0- -0- Lot 154 Public-Owned -0- -0- Lot 155 Public-Owned -0- -0- Lots 1-552 Tr. 5180 Unknown $- 8:68I - --2-1-5-35-173.6 $38.68/d.u. = $21,351.36 TOTAL: $557659-36 $61,155.36 • • CITY OF DUBLIN LANDSCAPING AND LIGHTING MAINTENANCE ASSESSMENT DISTRICT 83-2 CERTIFICATIONS FISCAL YEAR 1993-94 I, the City Clerk of the City of Dublin, California, hereby certify that the foregoing Engineer's Report, including Assessment, in the amounts set forth in Column (1), with the diagram thereto attached, was filed with me on May 24, 1993. I, the City Clerk of the City of Dublin, California, hereby certi y that the foregoing Assessment, with the diagram thereto attached, was preliminarily approved and confirmed by the City Council of said City by its Resolution No. 62-93 duly adopted by said Cod ncil on ' •y 24, 1993. I, the City Clerk of the City of Dublin, California, hereby!rtify that the foregoing Assessment, with the diagram thereto attached, was finally approved and confirmed by the City Council of said City by its Resolution No. -93, duly adopted by said Council on August 9, 1993. I, the City Clerk of the City of Dublin, California, hereby certify that a certified copy of the Assessment and diagram was filed in the office of the County Auditor of the County of Alameda, California, on , 1993. RESOLUTION NO. -93 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DUBLIN APPROVING ENGINEER'S REPORT, CONFIRMING DIAGRAM AND ASSESSMENT, AND ORDERING LEVY OF ASSESSMENT CITY OF DUBLIN LANDSCAPING AND LIGHTING MAINTENANCE ASSESSMENT DISTRICT 83-2 (STAGECOACH ROAD) WHEREAS, by its Resolution No. 21-93, a Resolution Directing Preparation of Annual Report for City of Dublin Landscaping and Lighting Maintenance Assessment District No. 83- 2 (the "District"), this Council designated the City Engineer as Engineer of Work and ordered said Engineer to make and file a report in writing in accordance with and pursuant to the Landscaping and Lighting Act of 1972; and WHEREAS, said report was made and filed with the City Clerk and duly considered by this Council and found to be sufficient in every particular, whereupon it was determined that said report should stand as Engineer's Report for all subsequent proceedings under and pursuant to the aforesaid Resolution and that July 26, 1993 and August 9, 1993, at 7:30 p.m. in the Council Chambers, Dublin Civic Center, 100 Civic Plaza, Dublin, California, were appointed as the time and place for a hearing by the Council on the question of the levy of the proposed assessment, notice of which hearing was mailed, published and posted in accordance with Government Code Section 54954.6; and WHEREAS, at the appointed time and place, said hearings were held, and all persons interested desiring to be heard were given an opportunity to be heard, and all matters pertaining to said levy were heard and considered by this Council, and this Council thereby acquired jurisdiction to order said levy and confirmation of diagram and assessment prepared by and made a part of the report of said engineer to pay the cost and expenses thereof; and WHEREAS, property owners in said District have requested that the assessment be increased in order to fund additional work in the District; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Dublin does hereby approve that: (a) The property owners owning more than fifty percent of the area of assessable land within the District had not, at the conclusion of said hearing, filed written protests against the said proposed levy, or against the Engineer's Estimate of costs and expenses, or against the maps and description, or against the diagram or the assessment to pay for the costs and expenses thereof; (b) The public interest, convenience, and necessity require that said levy be made; (c) The District benefited by said improvements and to be assessed to pay the costs and expenses thereof, and the exterior boundaries thereof, are as shown by a map thereof filed in the office of the City Clerk, which map is made a part hereof by reference thereto. • (d) The Engineer's Report shall be as revised to include the additional assessment for work within the District. PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this 9th day of August, 1993. AYES: NOES: ABSENT: Mayor ATTEST: City Clerk a:(ad)183-2183-21evy I ZONE 3-RESIDENTIAL EDGE • Introduce medium-sized,low maintenance shrub mass to screen fences from road. - existing fences / • Conserve irrigation-switch to emitter or bubbler system at each shrub. ►' " I ZONE 4-Wrap Around Zone W Improve irrigation coverage and infill slopes > 1 —� with groundcover,shrubs,and trees. 41, XV¢(J @, ;� `�.. \�� ate' a ,. �� a" ff aiat_x .ti t' a t tif STAGECOACH ` „ 0...,..(._ __?. !..Y\_ '-, `I 1\ROAD t g:-.2,:,:241111-_=, .;..--,-.V existing trees 1\ . VI/ -• ZONE S.MID SLOPE • Conserve irrigation budget-delete middle row of heads. • Hydrosced with annual grasses-mow I time/year. • ZONE I-NEIGHBORHOOD ENTRIES • Drier soil will reduce ground squirrel habitat. ZONE 2-STREETSCAPE EDGE . • Maintain 20' ± lush green edge with existing irrigated . Strengthen neighborhood identity,image,with special groundcover. planting treatment. • Screen views upslope with evergreen hedge. . Introduce seasonal color. • Introduce tree Clusters to reduce mass of hillside yet protect . Add street trees,groundcover at"wrap around" slopes. views. • Add seasonal color. • •. t . ti STAqECOACII ROAd ' LANdSCApE IMpROVEMENTS 44> CITY OF DUBLIN, CALIFORNIA .GAS DAVID L. GATES & ASSOCIATES 7.9 93 :ll_ PLANNING LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE URBAN DESIGN 2040 TASSAJARA LANE,DANVILLE,CA 94526(510)736.8176 .., \ 111.-- ....---' . .'4 .• r k << _' Orli T Low Flowering _ _° Shrubs1 • _� i �F Clusters of Small Scale Ill c�--- Flowering /7 Trees With Seasonal Interest Existing Fence 1 Perennials r�lC �\' Small"frees With Seasonal r �' /_ ' ,_— Interest `� —7 Existing Homes-Protect Views lL L. Existing Groundcover&Trees 1 I Existing Slope-No Additional Planting ,,._x First Phase l\ 1\- Existing Low Entry Wall • Low Flowering Shrubs&•IN (7--- . Perennials in Front of Wall • t . TYPICAL PLAN @ CORNER IMPROVEMENTS . TYPICAL SECTION,@ CORNER IMPROVEMENTS 1R= 1.-0' 1/8.._ 1.-0' STAgECOACI-I ROAd / LANdSCApE IMPROVEMENTS • CITY OF DUBLIN, CALIFORNIA A Ii Existing homes Infill existing trees with row of shrubs-drip or bubbler Existing homes irrigation At 1MM Position trees to preserve views from homes while screening homes/fences from road . �,k;l Position trees to preserve views from homes while screening homes/fences from road �. 7 r.- Existing fence Existing fence I ' AI Willa lit l �� �l� � —Existing Street Tree edge-Pistache.r . • I ....,:, J Existing Star Jasmine Existing street tree ,t�J. f' edge-Tulip Tree or ��/�r�-, L- `. Evergreen Ash `".._� .- '�'P f, . 10'(±) I "''i$ Infill existing Gazania with masses of shrubs, `PA._. 7.,&. "1 I aFl1,ei` Existing groundcover groundcover,and trees. + ;. . • Hydroseed slope with non-irrigated a 2,,, ,,// __ .n. annual grasses vim.-t ,��'v �+- �= Add continuous evergreen hedge to screen views of bare hillside I Adjust irrigation to spray narrower zone / • 20'(t) TYPICAL SECTION at STAGECOACH ROAD TYPICAL SECTION at AGATE&CORAL WAY I • • STAgECOACI-1 ROAd / LANdSCApE I M pROVEM ENTS CITY OF DUBLIN, CALIFORNIA °ATC6 DAVID L.GATES&ASSOCIATES 4 ...o r..s.t....xm. xr 7.15.93 o.xrnsr.e...s:60101.16.i.. NORTH