Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout10-09-2008 Draft HCAC Min HERITAGE AND CULTURAL ARTS COMMISSION Minutes CITY OF DUBLIN October 9, 2008 The October 9, 2008 meeting of the Heritage and Cultural Arts Commission was called to order at 7:00 p.m. at the Dublin Civic Center, Dublin, California, by Chair Swalwell. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Chair Swalwell led the Pledge of Allegiance. ROLL CALL Commissioners Present: Swalwell, Carr, Acuff, Mack, Vonheeder-Leopold, Lussie, Halket Commissioners Absent: None ORAL COMMUNICATIONS - None APPROVAL OF MINUTES On a motion by Cm. Acuff, seconded by Cm. Mack, and by a vote of 7-0-0, the Commission voted to approve the minutes of September 11, 2008 as presented. WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS - None PUBLIC HEARING 6.1 Amendment to Fee Resolution Mr. John Hartnett, Heritage and Cultural Arts Manager, presented the specifics of the item as outlined in the Staff Report. Commission Comments: Chair Swalwell opened the Public Hearing and no comments were received. On a motion by Cm. Lussie, seconded by Cm. Halket and by a vote of 7-0-0, the Commission voted to adopt the Resolution Adopting a Fee Schedule for Heritage and Cultural Arts Programs. UNFINISHED BUSINESS 7.1 Brav Commons Pubiic Art Mr. John Hartnett, Heritage and Cultural Arts Manager, presented the specifics of the item as outlined in the Staff Report. Chair Swalwell asked if there was anyone from the public who would like to address the Bray Commons Public Art issue. Public Speaker #1 identified himself as Rod Bugawan (3290 Maguire Way, Dublin). Mr. Bugawan advised that the artwork creates constant metal crashing noises and keeps him awake at night. Mr. Bugawan advised that the City's General Plan regarding noise levels states that the decibel level must not DRAFT H&CAC Minutes - October 9, 2008 Page 2 of 4 exceed 50 or less during the hours of 10:00 PM to 7:00 AM and therefore, by the City's own rules, this art piece is non-compliant. Mr. Bugawan was also concerned that the sharp metal pieces could hurt someone if they fall from the art project. Mr. Bugawan did not feel that this type of art belonged in a park with a children's area nearby, as it is much too dangerous and causes noise pollution in the immediate area around this art piece. Mr. Bugawan would like another sound test completed between the ardinance hours of 10:00 PM to 7:00 AM. Mr. Bugawan provided the Commission with a sampling of the leaves that he advised had already fallen from the artwork. Mr. Hartnett advised that he has been to the park several times to check for fallen metal leaves, but has not found any in the past few months, nor have any been turned in by Staff. Public Speaker #2 identified himself as John Zukoski (3385 Dublin Blvd). Mr. Zukoski advised that his number one and two concerns with this art project are noise pollution and the safety issue regarding the fallen leaves. Mr. Zukoski did not feel that coating the leaves would help alleviate the noise created by this art piece. Mr. Zukoski suggested moving the art piece to Devaney Square which has a similar feel and look of Bray Commons. Mr. Harnett advised that relocating the art piece to another park is not a viable option at this time. Mr. Zukoski stated that any money spent on this art project should come out of the Public Art fund and not from the City of Dublin's General Fund account. Mr. Zukoski suggested encircling the piece with plexiglass to reduce the safety issue of children standing under the art piece and being struck by a falling metal leaf and possibly reducing the sound. Commission Comments: Cm. Lussie felt that the public had legitimate reasons for wanting this art piece modified or removed from the area. Cm. Lussie felt this art piece is a discomfort to the residents as well as a safety issue. Cm. Lussie did not feel confident that the coating of the leaves would help but did not want to remove any of the leaves as she felt this would compromise the art piece. Chair Swalwell stated that he does not doubt that the art piece might be loud. Chair Swalwell suggested putting twist ties on the metal leaves to keep them from falling. Chair Swalwell felt that relocating the art would be too costly. Chair Swalwell also reminded everyone that this art was pre-approved before it was installed and therefore, moving the art piece at this time would set precedence for other projects being removed after the public's opportunity for input has passed. Cm. Acuff suggested removing some of the metal leaves to reduce the leaves banging against each other. Cm. Acuff liked the idea of coating the metal with some sound muffling material and using the twist ties or other device on all of the leaves to ensure none fall down and harm anyone. Mr. Hartnett advised that the artist is willing to work with the City to get these issues resolved and is open to ideas on how to accomplish this task. Cm. Halket felt removing some of the leaves were a viable option. Vice Chair Carr was concerned that plastic twist ties would become loose and fall with all of the movement involved with this art piece. Vice Chair Carr suggested coating the leaves with a sound muffling material and then run another noise test to see if this helps at all. I I DRAFT H&CAC Minutes- October 9, 2008 Page 3 of 4 Chair Swalwell advised that Mr. Hartnett has made several efforts to resolve these issues with the public and has diligently tried to resolve the problems with this art piece and moved for a vote by the Commission on this issue. On a motion by Cm. Acuff, seconded by Cm. Mack, and by a vote of 6-1-0, the Commission voted to recommend using a sound muffling material such as plastic on the metal leaves and to have the artist use twist ties or some other means to secure all leaves. Cm. Vonheeder-Leopold opposed the motion. NEW BUSINESS 8.1 Parks & Community Services Strategic Plan Mr. Paul McCreary, Assistant Director of Parks & Community Services, presented the proposed Parks & Community Services Strategic Plan as outlined in the Staff Report. Commission Comments: Cm. Acuff thanked Mr. McCreary for the report and felt that the plan was good in that it included a lot of open space which promotes the mental relaYation of our residents and gives them a sense that there are quiet places in Dublin to go and enjoy. Cm. Vonheeder-Leopold liked the ideas for the parks and downtown plans and felt we must stick to the plan and move forward. Cm. Vonheeder-Leopold would also like to see more acknowledgement of our non-profit sports leagues in the area, such as Dublin Little League and Dublin United Soccer League. Cm. Vonheeder-Leopold cautioned that much of the open space referred to in the Strategic Plan is privately owned and includes some restrictions of use to which the private owner is entitled. Vice Chair Carr appreciates and enjoys the bike and walking pathways. It makes Dublin more biking and walking friendly to the public. Chair Swalwell thanked Mr. McCreary for his hard work on this project and believes we should expand our work in promoting activities to various internet sites as well as to aid in advertising the City of Dublin's amenities and programs. Cm. Mack suggested more weekend dance classes for people who work during the week. Cm. Lussie liked the idea of partnering with private vendors such as gyms and spas to enable the City to offer more activities at flexible times for the community. Vice Chair Carr suggested sending marketing information by text to cell phones and liked the punch pass idea where someone could buy a 10-visit pass and go to any health and wellness class they wished to participate in instead of having them commit to a single activity for a six to eight week period of time. 9.1 Other Business Cm. Vonheeder-Leopold shared that she enjoyed the two park dedications last week and felt the equipment and safety material were state of the art. Chair Swalwell stated that he recently visited The Getty Museum in Los Angeles which is a beautiful park and facility inside and out. DRAFT H&CAC Minutes - October 9, 2008 Page 4 of 4 ADJOURNMENT Being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 8:40 p.m. Respectfully submitted, Christie Marks Senior Office Assistant APPROVED: Chairperson I I