HomeMy WebLinkAbout8-19-19 PCSC Meeting Agenda PacketAugust 19, 2019 Dublin Parks & Community Services Commission Agenda Page 1 of 3
REGULAR MEETING
Monday, August 19, 2019, 7:00 PM
Dublin Civic Center, 100 Civic Plaza
DUBLIN PARKS &
COMMUNITY SERVICES
COMMISSION
A G E N D A
• Agendas and Staff Reports are posted on the City’s Internet Website (www.dublin.ca.gov)
• A complete packet of information containing Staff Reports and exhibits relate to each item is available of public
review at least 72 hours prior to a Parks & Community Services Commission Meeting or, in the event that it is
delivered to Parks & Community Services Commission members less than 72 hours prior to a Parks &
Community Services Commission Meeting, as soon as it is so delivered.
1. CALL TO ORDER AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
2. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
2.1. Brief Informational Only Reports from the Youth Advisory and Senior Center
Advisory Committees
2.2. Public Comment
At this time, the public is permitted to address the Parks & Community Services Commission on non-agendized items.
Please step to the podium and clearly state your name for the record. COMMENTS SHOULD NOT EXCEED THREE (3)
MINUTES. In accordance with State Law, no action or discussion may take place on any item not appearing on the posted
agenda. The Parks & Community Services Commission may respond to statements made or questions asked, or may
request Staff to report back at a future meeting concerning the matter. Any member of the public may contact the
Recording Secretary’s Office related to the proper procedure to place an item on a future Parks & Community Services
Commission agenda. The exceptions under which the Parks & Community Services Commission MAY discuss and/or take
action on items not appearing on the agenda are contained in Government Code Section 54954.2(b)(1)(2)(3).
3. CONSENT CALENDAR
Consent Calendar items are typically non-controversial in nature and are considered for approval by the Parks &
Community Services Commission with one single action. Members of the audience, Staff or the Parks & Community
Services Commission who would like an item removed from the Consent Calendar for purposes of public input may request
the Chair to remove the item.
3.1. Minutes of the June 17, 2019 Meeting of the Parks and Community Services
Commission
The Commission will consider approval of the minutes of the June 17, 2019 meeting
of the Parks and Community Services Commission.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Approve the minutes of the June 17, 2019 meeting of the Parks and Community
Services Commission.
3.2. June PCS Department Monthly Report
The Commission will receive the Department Monthly Report on classes, activities,
and events conducted during the month of June 2019.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Receive the report.
3.3. July PCS Department Monthly Report
August 19, 2019 Dublin Parks & Community Services Commission Agenda Page 2 of 3
The Commission will receive the Department Monthly Report on classes, activities,
and events conducted during the month of July 2019.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Receive the report.
3.4. Dublin Library Quarterly Report: April - June 2019
The Commission will receive a quarterly report for the Dublin Library.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Receive the report.
4. WRITTEN COMMUNICATION - NONE
5. PUBLIC HEARING - NONE
6. UNFINISHED BUSINESS - NONE
7. NEW BUSINESS
7.1. Jordan Ranch Neighborhood Park Art Selection
The Parks and Community Services Commission will make a recommendation on
public art for Jordan Ranch Park.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Recommend the public artwork proposed by Yoshio Taylor for City Council
approval.
7.2. Butterfly Knoll Park Art Selection
The Parks and Community Services Commission will make a recommendation on
public art for Butterfly Knoll Park.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Recommend the public artwork proposed by Joey Rose for City Council approval.
7.3. Sean Diamond Park Art Selection
The Parks and Community Services Commission will make a recommendation on
public art for Sean Diamond Park to the City Council.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Recommend the public artwork proposed by Saori Ide and Jonathan Russell from
Ride Art Studio for City Council approval.
8. OTHER BUSINESS
Brief information only reports from the Commission and/or Staff, including committee reports and reports by
the Commission related to meetings attended at City expense (AB1234).
9. ADJOURNMENT
This AGENDA is posted in accordance with Government Code Section 54954.2(a)
If requested, pursuant to Government Code Section 54953.2, this agenda shall be made available in appropriate
alternative formats to persons with a disability, as required by Section 202 of the Americans with Disabilities Act of
1990 (42 U.S.C. Section 12132), and the federal rules and regulations adopted in implementa tion thereof. To make
a request for disability-related modification or accommodation, please contact the City Clerk’s Office (925) 833 -
6650 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting.
Mission
August 19, 2019 Dublin Parks & Community Services Commission Agenda Page 3 of 3
The City of Dublin promotes and supports a high quality of life, ensures a safe and secure environment, and fosters
new opportunities.
Vision
Dublin is a vibrant city committed to its citizens, natural resources and cultural heritage. As Dublin grows, it will
balance history with progress, to sustain an enlightened, economically balanced and diverse community.
Dublin is unified in its belief that an engaged and informed community encourages innovation in all aspects of City
life, including programs to strengthen our economic vitality, and preserve our natural surr oundings through
environmental stewardship and sustainability. Dublin is dedicated to promoting an active and healthy lifestyle
through the creation of first-class recreational opportunities, facilities and programs.
Page 1 of 1
STAFF REPORT
PARKS & COMMUNITY SERVICES COMMISSION
DATE: August 19, 2019
TO: Honorable Chair and Commissioners
FROM:
La Shawn Butler, Parks & Community Services Director
SUBJECT:
Minutes of the June 17, 2019 Meeting of the Parks and Com munity
Services Commission
Prepared by: Roel Blanco, Senior Office Assistant
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY:
The Commission will consider approval of the minutes of the June 17, 2019 meeting of
the Parks and Community Services Commission.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Approve the minutes of the June 17, 2019 meeting of the Parks and Community
Services Commission.
FINANCIAL IMPACT:
N/A
DESCRIPTION:
The Parks and Community Services Commission will consider approval of the minutes
of the June 17, 2019 meeting of the Parks and Community Services Commission.
NOTICING REQUIREMENTS/PUBLIC OUTREACH:
N/A
ATTACHMENTS:
1. Minutes from the June 17, 2019 Parks and Community Services Commission
Meeting
3.1
Packet Pg. 4
PARKS & COMMUNITY SERVICES COMMISSION MINUTES
Monday, June 17, 2019
Parks & Community Services Commission June 17, 2019
Regular Meeting P a g e | 1
A Regular Meeting of the Dublin Parks & Community Services Commission was held on
Monday, June 17, 2019, in the Civic Center Council Chamber. The meeting was called
to order at 7:00 PM, by Chair Michelle Smith McDonald.
1. Call to Order and Pledge of Allegiance
Attendee Name Title Status
Michelle Smith McDonald Commissioner Chair Present
Matthew Giller Commissioner Present
Joseph Washington Commissioner Present
Sameer Hakim Commissioner Present
Kristin Speck Commissioner Present
Shaina Goel Student Representative Present
Cm. Smith McDonald asked Student Representative Goel to lead the Pledge of
Allegiance.
2. Oral Communications
2.1. Brief Informational Only Reports from the Youth Advisory and Senior
Center Advisory Committees
Student Representative Goel reported on the May 22, 2019 Youth Advisory
Committee meeting.
Committee Member Connie Mack reported on the June 6, 2019 Senior Center
Advisory Committee meeting.
2.2. Public Comment
2.3. Parks and Recreation Master Plan Update Status Report
La Shawn Butler, Parks and Community Service Director, presented the specifics
of the item as outlined in the staff report and invited representatives from Green
Play and Land Design to provide an update on the Parks and Recreation Master
Plan.
Art Thatcher of Green Play and Paula Narvaez of Land Design provided an
update.
Cm. Smith McDonald opened the floor for questions.
3.1.a
Packet Pg. 5 Attachment: 1. Minutes from the June 17, 2019 Parks and Community Services Commission Meeting (PCSC June 17, 2019 Meeting Minutes)
Parks & Community Services Commission June 17, 2019
Regular Meeting P a g e | 2
The Commissioners asked about the survey results, need for a multi-use facility,
and connecting the eastern and western sides of Dublin.
Mr. Thatcher, Ms. Narvaez and staff responded to the Commissioners' questions.
3. Consent Calendar
3.1. Minutes of the May 20, 2019 Meeting of the Parks and Community Services
Commission.
Approved as presented.
3.2. May 2019 Parks and Community Services Department Monthly Report.
Receive the report.
RESULT: ADOPTED [UNANIMOUS]
MOVED BY: Kristen Speck, Commissioner
SECOND: Sameer Hakim, Commissioner
AYES: Giller, Smith McDonald, Goel, Washington, Hakim, Speck
4. Written Communication - None
5. Public Hearing - None
6. Unfinished Business - None
7. New Business
7.1. Dog Park Replacement Art Selection
Ms. Butler presented the specifics of the item as outlined in the staff report.
Cm. Smith McDonald opened the floor for discussion.
The Commissioners discussed each proposals' design and impact on space and
infrastructure, maintenance schedule, and budget.
ACTION:
On a motion by Cm. Hakim, seconded by Student Rep. Goel, and by a vote of 6-
0-0, the Commission voted to recommend the public artwork by Tellart for City
Council approval.
3.1.a
Packet Pg. 6 Attachment: 1. Minutes from the June 17, 2019 Parks and Community Services Commission Meeting (PCSC June 17, 2019 Meeting Minutes)
Parks & Community Services Commission June 17, 2019
Regular Meeting P a g e | 3
RESULT: ADOPTED [UNANIMOUS]
MOVED BY: Sameer Hakim, Commissioner
SECOND: Shaina Goel, Student Representative
AYES: Giller, Smith McDonald, Goel, Washington, Hakim, Speck
7.2. Review of Capital Improvement Program for the Dublin Historic Park Master
Plan
Ms. Butler presented the specifics of the item as outlined in the staff report .
Cm. Smith McDonald opened the floor for questions.
The Commissioners asked about the cemetery, options to upgrade or enhance
current services and infrastructure, and adding public artwork and exhibits.
ACTION:
On a motion by Cm. Giller, seconded by Cm. Washington, and by a vote of 6-0-0,
the Commission voted to recommend to City Council the removal of phases two,
three and four of the Historic Park Master Plan with an expressed interest in
adding public artwork, outdoor interpretive signage or other self-guided history
displays, and some type of a memorial garden or wall wher e community
members can honor loved ones with an engraved brick or some similar tribute.
RESULT: ADOPTED [UNANIMOUS]
MOVED BY: Matthew Giller, Commissioner
SECOND: Joseph Washington, Commissioner
AYES: Giller, Smith McDonald, Goel, Washington, Hakim, Speck
7.3. Batting Cages Policy and Fee Structure
Ms. Butler presented the specifics of the item as outlined in the staff report.
Cm. Smith McDonald opened the floor for questions.
The Commissioners asked about the rate structure compared with other cities,
estimated use, and oversight of the facility.
Ms. Butler and Bridget Amaya, Assistant Parks and Community Services
Director, responded to the Commissioners' questions.
Cm. Smith McDonald opened the floor for public comment.
Ramesh Immaddi of Cricket for Cubs gave a brief background on the success his
organization has had and commented that he would like to have no time limit set
3.1.a
Packet Pg. 7 Attachment: 1. Minutes from the June 17, 2019 Parks and Community Services Commission Meeting (PCSC June 17, 2019 Meeting Minutes)
Parks & Community Services Commission June 17, 2019
Regular Meeting P a g e | 4
to rent the cages. He stated that without the time limit his organization can offer
more opportunities for members practice with coaches.
Cm. Smith McDonald opened the floor for discussion.
The Commissioners discussed the usage requirements, priority for use, access
for individual use, and monitoring usage.
ACTION:
On a motion by Cm. Smith McDonald, seconded by Cm. Washington, and by a
vote of 6-0-0, the Commission voted to recommend the proposed Cricket Batting
Cages Policy and Fee Structure with a yearly evaluation to City Council for
approval.
RESULT: ADOPTED [UNANIMOUS]
MOVED BY: Michelle Smith McDonald, Commissioner
SECOND: Joseph Washington, Commissioner
AYES: Giller, Smith McDonald, Goel, Washington, Hakim, Speck
8. Other Business
The Commissioners provided brief informational reports on public art committees for
Jordan Ranch Park and Clover Park and the Library Summer Program offering coupons
to the Wave.
The Commissioners thanked Student Representative Shaina Goel for her time and
service on the Parks and Community Services Commission.
Staff provided program and event updates.
9. Adjournment
Being no further business, the meeting was adjourned by Cm. McDonald at 9:19 PM.
Minutes prepared by Roel Blanco, Recording Secretary.
____________________________________________
Parks & Community Services Commission Chairperson
ATTEST:
______________________________________
La Shawn Butler
Parks and Community Services Director
3.1.a
Packet Pg. 8 Attachment: 1. Minutes from the June 17, 2019 Parks and Community Services Commission Meeting (PCSC June 17, 2019 Meeting Minutes)
Page 1 of 7
STAFF REPORT
PARKS & COMMUNITY SERVICES COMMISSION
DATE: August 19, 2019
TO: Honorable Chair and Commissioners
FROM:
La Shawn Butler, Parks & Community Services Director
SUBJECT:
June PCS Department Monthly Report
Prepared by: La Shawn Butler
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY:
The Commission will receive the Department Monthly Report on classes, activities, and
events conducted during the month of June 2019.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Receive the report.
DESCRIPTION:
The Parks and Community Services Department strives to develop and implement
quality programs that strengthen community image, provide recreational experiences,
and encourage healthy lifestyles. This is accomplished by offering innovative
recreational and social activities and programs. Following is a summary of the classes,
activities, and events held in the month of June 2019.
ADMINISTRATIVE
The FY 19-20 fee schedule for Parks and Community Services was approved at the
June 18, 2019 City Council meeting. The Parks and Community Services Commission
reviewed the fees at the April 15, 2019 meeting.
The City’s agreement with Alameda County Library for library services at the Dublin
Public Library was also approved with the same number of open hours per week.
RECREATION DIVISION
The City hosted a number of Summer Camps and Camp Connectors. The following
chart is a comparison of Summer Camp registration during the month of June:
Camp Name 2019 2018
3.2
Packet Pg. 9
Page 2 of 7
East Bay Explorers 142 129
Camp Sunrise 98 160
Camp Emerald Glen 116 132
Camp Shamrock 93 90
Camp Connector EG
PM
30 31
Camp Connector AM 73 98
Camp Connector
Noon
23 70
Camp Connector PM 105 143
The Dublin L.E.A.D. (Leadership-Experience-And-Development) program is open to
teens entering seventh grade or higher. Participants receive training on a variety of job-
related skills including resume writing, job search techniques and interview skills.
Additional topics include how to lead an activity, how to engage participants, water
safety skills, playground park safety and supervising participants. Teens who
participated in past teen volunteer programs for more than two summers had an active
role in coordinating and implementing weekly camp activities, coordinating weekly
trainings and mentoring new volunteers. Fifty-three teens participated during the month
of June.
On Friday, June 26, the Adult Bocce League began with games being held on Friday
evenings at the bocce courts at Fallon Sports Park. The league will conclude the week
of August 19.
Teams 2019 2018
Wednesday League 4 8
Friday League 8 8
On Monday, June 3, the Little Lovies Session began with all program days (Mondays -
Thursdays) filled to capacity with 12 youth. A waiting list was established for each
program day. Session I ended on Thursday, July 18.
Little Lovies 2019 2018
Session I registration 48 42
The following chart provides sports fields hours, facility (includes: classes, meetings and
private rentals) and picnic area rentals for the month of June:
Facility, Picnic Area
and Field Names
June
Rentals or
Rental Hours
Civic Regional Meeting Room 26
Dublin Senior Center 84
Library Community Room 19
3.2
Packet Pg. 10
Page 3 of 7
Library Program Room 16
Heritage Park Kolb Barn 13
Heritage Park
St Raymond Church
1
Shannon Community Center 42
Stager Community Gymnasium 24
Alamo Creek Park 12
Heritage Park 5
Emerald Glen Park 51
Kolb Park 9
Schaefer Ranch Park 11
Shannon Park 11
Dublin Sports Grounds Fields 1051.5
Fallon Sports Park Fields 616.91
Emerald Glen Fields 443.5
Ted Fairfield Fields 16
SPECIAL EVENTS
Every Thursday, the Dublin Farmers’ Market is held at Emerald Glen Park from 4:00 to
8:00pm. The market schedule includes themed Family Nights, Community Nights and
Green Dublin Nights, as well as entertainment, crafts, and representation by local
businesses. On June 6, the City had an estimated attendance of more than 2,200, in
large part a concert featuring the band “Super Diamond”, a tribute to Neil Diamond,
which is the largest Farmers’ Market for the 2019 season thus far.
On Friday, June 14, the Department’s Picnic Flix began with the feature film Disney’s
Tarzan; estimated attendance was 400. Local businesses were on site with giveaways
and prizes, as well as food vendors including Lucille’s BBQ serving up dinner and snack
items. This was the first of three movies in the Summer series with Coco scheduled on
July 26 and Incredibles 2 on August 30.
On June 29 and June 30, the sold-out Family Campout was held at Emerald Glen Park
with 220 participants. Campers played lawn games, made arts & crafts, explored the
park with a nature presentation, and campfire entertainment by the Alameda County 4 -
H Puppeteers. Dinner and breakfast were served to campers, as well as a campout
favorite, s’mores. Future campouts are scheduled at Alamo Creek park in July and
Schaeffer Ranch Park in August.
SENIOR CENTER
The Dublin Senior Center strives to create a rewarding social and recreational
environment that serves the needs/interests of seniors in our community. The following
is a summary of attendance and participation at the Dublin Senior Center during the
month of June 2019:
Program June 2019 May 2019
3.2
Packet Pg. 11
Page 4 of 7
General attendance, via door counter 9,000 9,250
Programs/activities attendance, via enrollment and drop-ins 2,051 2,308
Volunteer hours worked 955 999
Lunches Served 588 871
Services Date Participants
First-time Visitor Tours given June 16
Eyeglass Cleaning by Kaiser Permanente 6/3 38
Foot Care Health Screening by Senior Support of Tri-Valley 6/3 9
Diabetes Support Group 6/4 5
Bread & Food Distribution M/W/F 360
Deaf Support Group 6/13 32
Finding Wellness Workshop by Senior Support of Tri-Valley 6/18 10
Hearing Aid Cleaning provided by Connect Hearing 6/19 5
HICAP Counselor appointments 6/26 1
SPECIAL EVENTS AND TRIPS
On Saturday, June 1, 11 people attended a trip to the San Francisco Zoo. The trip
included transportation and entry fee.
On Wednesday, June 12, Avesta Development Group sponsored a table from 10:30 am
- 1:00 pm for seniors to provide comments on artwork going in the new memory care
facility, Elegance Dublin, being built across the street from the Dublin Senior Center.
On Friday, June 21, Blue Fuzion, a jazz ensemble made up of Dublin High School
students, played at lunch for 30 seniors.
On Thursday, June 27, the Dublin San Ramon Services Water District sponsored a
table from 10:00 am - 11:45 am to provide information about and register seniors who
qualify for the Low-Income Assistance program.
Rentals
6/23 - Graduation Party
6/29 - Church Service
HERITAGE PARKS & MUSEUMS
Rentals
6/1 - Picnic rental, birthday party
6/1 - Memorial Service in Old St. Raymond Church
6/2 - Picnic rental, birthday party
6/8 - Celebration of life in the Sunday School Barn
6/15 - Picnic rental, community gathering
3.2
Packet Pg. 12
Page 5 of 7
On June 5, 20, and 26, volunteers from the Dublin Heritage Park Garden Group worked
in the flower and vegetable gardens by pulling weeds trimming plants and planting new
vegetables for the summer.
Exploring Dublin’s First Inhabitants continued in the Little Classroom of Murray School
House.
On June 23, the “Celebrating Spring Sports” event took place at the Dublin Camp Parks
Military History Center. Visitors were able to enjoy conversations with the curators,
music, refreshments, and view the new exhibit.
On Saturday, June 1, participants in the Hands-on-History Program had the opportunity
to learn about native Ohlone tribes by making a Tule Boat model craft.
On Thursday, June 13, the Academic Plus Summer School Program visited Heritage
Park and Museums. 35 youth and five adults participated in guided tours of the park
grounds, cemetery, Old Saint Raymond’s Church, and Murray School House.
During the week of June 24-28, Dublin Pioneer Camp was offered to youth ages 3-12
years old. Participants were able to experience pioneer life and learn about Dublin’s
pioneering families by participating in games, crafts, and activities at the park.
WAVE
The Wave Waterpark opened for daily operations on June 1st and is currently open daily
from 11:00am to 6:00pm until August 11th.
Admission Type June 2019
Waterpark Admissions over 40” 11,550
Waterpark under 40” 1676
Waterpark under 2 years 944
Group Tickets 220
Military 543
Total Admissions 14,933
Birthday Party Program
The Wave birthday party package consists of admission to the Waterpark, a reserved
outdoor party area, pizza or hot dogs, juice, snacks, plates and napkins, and a novelty
item per paid guest. Thirty-eight Birthday Party Packages were purchased during the
month of June.
Private Rentals
The Wave Community Room as well as any of the amenities of the Water Park,
individually or any combination, including a complete park buyout are available to rent
during non-public hours. The Community Room and Natatorium are available for rent
year-round. The Slide Tower, Splash Zone and Sports Pool are available May through
3.2
Packet Pg. 13
Page 6 of 7
September and are closed in winter from October through April. This month there were
two rentals held in the Community Room.
Swim Lessons
The Wave Swim School is open year-round in the Natatorium. Lessons are available
for beginning through advanced levels and for children ages six months up to adult
level. The Natatorium provides a comfortable indoor swimming environment and was
specifically designed as a teaching pool with three teaching bays, a zero -depth
gradually sloped ramp, and lap swim lane space. The swim school curriculum was
developed and designed specifically for The Wave Swim School.
Level 2019
Parent/Child 94
Preschool (ages 3 to 5) 217
Youth (ages 6 to 12) 432
Teen & Adult 39
Total Registration 782
Dublin Green Gator and Junior Green Swim Teams
The Dublin Green Gator Swim Team began in 1989 at the Dub lin Swim Center and this
season is celebrating its 30th anniversary. The team began practice in May for the 2019
season and the first meet was held on June 8. The team is at capacity with 143
participants enrolled. The Championship Meet occurred on July 20 at Las Positas
College.
The Junior Green Gators began practice on June 4 and meet on Tuesday, Wednesday
and Thursday evenings from 6:00pm to 8:00pm.
Fitness Swimming (Lap Swimming, Junior Lap Swimming and Water Walking)
The Wave’s Fitness Swimming includes lap swimming for adults, Junior lap swimming
for ages 10+, and water walking. Fitness Swimming is offered Monday through
Saturday mornings, Monday through Thursday and Sunday evenings. Lap swimming,
Junior Lap Swimming and Water Walking Participants have the option to purchase a
daily admission fee, or a Fitness Convenience Pass for pre -paid admissions at a
discounted rate. Kick boards and pull buoys are available for participants during Fitness
Swimming hours.
Admission Type 2019
Lap Swim Daily Visit 178
Convenience Pass Visits 746
Convenience Passes 37
Aqua Aerobics
Aqua Aerobics is a low impact, easy paced fitness class which improves cardio fitness,
tones and sculpts. The class uses the natural resistance and buoyancy of water to
provide a wide variety of conditioning benefits with no impact on joints. No swimming is
required. Aqua Aerobics is offered Mondays and Wednesdays, 7:00 PM - 7:50 PM.
3.2
Packet Pg. 14
Page 7 of 7
Register Type 2019
Resident 26
Non-Resident 12
Total Registration 38
STRATEGIC PLAN INITIATIVE:
N/A
NOTICING REQUIREMENTS/PUBLIC OUTREACH:
N/A
ATTACHMENTS:
N/A
ATTACHMENTS:
None.
3.2
Packet Pg. 15
Page 1 of 7
STAFF REPORT
PARKS & COMMUNITY SERVICES COMMISSION
DATE: August 19, 2019
TO: Honorable Chair and Commissioners
FROM:
La Shawn Butler, Parks & Community Services Director
SUBJECT:
July PCS Department Monthly Report
Prepared by: La Shawn Butler
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY:
The Commission will receive the Department Monthly Report on classes, activities, and
events conducted during the month of July 2019.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Receive the report.
DESCRIPTION:
The Parks and Community Services Department strives to develop and implement
quality programs that strengthen community image, provide recreational experiences,
and encourage healthy lifestyles. This is accomplished by offering innovative
recreational and social activities and programs. Following is a summary of the classes,
activities, and events held in the month of July 2019.
ADMINISTRATIVE
The new online registration system, ActiveNet went live on July 30, 2019 successfully
with assistance from both the Finance and IT departments. The new system will give
customers 24/7 access to activities from any computer, tablet, or smartphone;
convenience and security, no waiting in line to register, easy-to-view activity, facility,
and event information, and the ability to create and manage their own wish list.
RECREATION DIVISION
The City hosted a number of Summer Camps and Camp Connectors thus month.
Camp Name 2019 2018
East Bay Explorers 190 177
Camp Sunrise 117 189
3.3
Packet Pg. 16
Page 2 of 7
Camp Emerald Glen 59 92
Camp Shamrock 44 33
Camp Connector AM 51 42
Camp Connector
Noon
24 28
Camp Connector PM 79 75
The week of July 8, the Adult Softball League began games on Tuesday evenings for
the Men’s League and Thursday evenings for Coed League. Games are held at Fallon
Sports Park on the Softball fields and will conclude on September 17, 2019.
Teams 2019 2018
Tuesday’s Men’s League 8 13
Thursday’s Coed League 8 14
On Monday, July 22, 2019 the Little Lovies Session began with all program days
(Mondays - Thursdays) filled to capacity. A waiting list was established for each
program day. Session II ends on Thursday, August 29, 2019.
Little Lovies 2019 2018
Session II registration 48 44
The following chart provides sports fields hours, facility (includes: classes, meetings and
private rentals) and picnic area rentals for the month of July:
Facility, Picnic Area
and Field Names
July
Rentals or
Rental Hours
Civic Regional Meeting Room 35
Dublin Senior Center 71
Library Community Room 48
Library Program Room 33
Heritage Park Kolb Barn 41
Heritage Park
St Raymond Church
2
Shannon Community Center 47
Stager Community Gymnasium 63
Alamo Creek Park 7
Heritage Park 7
Emerald Glen Park 46
Kolb Park 9
Schaefer Ranch Park 9
Shannon Park 9
Dublin Sports Grounds Fields 462
Fallon Sports Park Fields 958
Emerald Glen Fields 379.82
Ted Fairfield Fields 16
3.3
Packet Pg. 17
Page 3 of 7
SPECIAL EVENTS
Every Thursday, the Dublin Farmers’ Market is held at Emerald Glen Park from 4:00 to
8:00pm. The market schedule includes themed Family Nights, Community Nights and
Green Dublin Nights, as well as entertainment, crafts, and representation by local
businesses. On July 11, 2019 a concert featuring the tribute band “Fleetwood Mask”,
had an estimated attendance combined with the Farmers’ Market of more than 4,500,
which is the highest attendance this season.
On July 13-14, 2019 a Family Campout was held at Alamo Creek Park with 179
participants. Campers played lawn games, made arts & crafts and participated in a
basketball clinic led by several Junior Warriors coaches. A campfire sing-along was led
by Bingo Schmingo. Dinner and breakfast were served to campers, as well as a
campout favorite, s’mores. A future campout is scheduled at Schaeffer Ranch Park in
August.
SENIOR CENTER
The Dublin Senior Center strives to create a rewarding social and recreational
environment that serves the needs/interests of seniors in our community. The following
is a summary of attendance and participation at the Dublin Senior Center during the
month of July 2019:
Program July 2019 June 2019
General attendance, via door counter 8,681 9,000
Programs/activities attendance, via enrollment and drop -ins 2,165 2,051
Volunteer hours worked 999 955
Lunches Served 538 588
Services and Workshops Date Participants
First-time Visitor Tours given July 1
Eyeglass Cleaning by Kaiser Permanente 7/9 12
AARP Smart Driver Course - 8 hours 7/9 & 7/16 12
Tri-Valley Rainbows 7/18 13
Bread & Food Distribution M/W/F 490
Deaf Support Group 7/11 6
Better Business Bureau Scams Workshop 7/10 6
Hearing Aid Cleaning provided by Connect Hearing 7/24 2
SPECIAL EVENTS AND TRIPS
Open Heart Kitchen completed a marketing mailing campaign on behalf of the Dublin
Senior Center congregate daily lunch program. The marketing piece titled “Free Healthy
Lunch” was mailed to all Dublin residents ages 60 and older with restricted incomes.
On July 8, 2019 the Alameda County Healthy Homes Department gave seniors
3.3
Packet Pg. 18
Page 4 of 7
information about home repair grant funding available for qualified Dublin and other
residents that own a home and or residential properties in Alameda County.
On July 23, 2019 Sunrise Senior Living of San Ramon and Pleasanton sponsored an
ice-cream social for 125 seniors. Ice-cream, toppings and volunteer help were all
provided by Sunrise Senior Living for this free event.
On July 24, 2019 staff attended the Dublin Ranch Seniors Annual Summer BBQ to
promote Dublin Senior Center programs, activities and inform attendees about the
Senior Fee Assistance program.
Rentals
7/13 - Memorial
7/14 - First Communion
7/27 - Wedding Anniversary
HERITAGE PARKS & MUSEUMS
Rentals
7/6 - Picnic rental, family gathering
7/13 - Picnic rental, baby shower
7/19 - Barn rental, wedding rehearsal dinner
7/21 - Picnic rental, birthday party
7/24 - Barn rental, DHPA meeting
7/24 - Church rental, HOA meeting
Services
On July 3, 10, 24 and 31, 2019 volunteers of the Dublin Heritage Park Garden
Group worked in the flower and vegetable gardens pulling weeds, trimming
plants and planting new vegetables for the summer.
Exhibits
Exploring Dublin’s First Inhabitants continued in the Little Classroom of Murray
School House.
Spring Sports at Camp Park continued at the Dublin Camp Parks Military History
Center.
Events
On July 12, 2019 the DIVCO Milk Truck Display and ice cream social took place
at Heritage Park. Community members had the opportunity to view vintage milk
trucks, enjoy ice cream, barbeque, live music, and take tours of the Kolb House.
This event was put on by the DIVCO Club of America and the Dublin Historical
Preservation Association. An estimated crowd of more than 300 attended the
event.
On July 25 and 26, 2019 Tri-Valley Young Performers Summer Camps provided
performances of “Mary Poppins, Jr.” at Heritage Park.
Hand on History
On July 6, 2019 eight participants had the opportunity to learn about native
3.3
Packet Pg. 19
Page 5 of 7
Ohlone tribes by making Tule Boat model crafts and participating in seed and nut
grinding using old mortars and pestles.
Tours
On July 31, 2019 a private summer camp group of 12 kids and two adults
participated in the Heritage Park Tour and Activities program.
Camps
During the month of July, Heritage Park hosted three youth summer cam ps. They
were Tri-Valley Young Performers, Acrylic Painting, and Kinder Drama.
THE WAVE
WATERPARK
The Wave Waterpark opened for daily operations on June 1, 2019 and is currently open
daily from 11:00am to 6:00pm through August 11, 2019
Admission Type July 2019
Waterpark Admissions over 40” 13,410
Waterpark under 40” 1255
Waterpark under 2 years 1157
Group Tickets 845
Military 432
Total Admissions 17,099
BIRTHDAY PARTY PROGRAM
The Wave Birthday Party Program consists of a package including a reserved outdoor
party area, admission to the Waterpark, choice of pizza or hot dogs, juice, snacks,
plates, napkins, and a commemorative novelty item per paid guest. Parties are offered
at 11:00am to 2:00pm or 2:30pm to 5:30pm every day from June 1, 2019 through
August 11, 2019. Parties are available only on weekends after August 11, 2019 through
September. Beginning in October, parties will transition to the indoor Natatorium from
October until May.
Party Packages July 2019
Birthday Parties 28
PRIVATE RENTALS
The Wave Community Room as well as any of the amenities of the Water Park,
individually or any combination, including a complete park buyout are available to rent
during non-public hours. The Community Room and Natatorium are available for rent
year-round. The Slide Tower, Splash Zone and Sports Pool are available May through
September and are closed in winter from October through April.
3.3
Packet Pg. 20
Page 6 of 7
Area: July 2019
Community Room 2
Full Waterpark Buyout 3
Total Rentals 5
SWIM LESSONS
The Wave Swim School is open year-round in the Natatorium. Lessons are available
for beginning through advanced levels and for children ages six months up to adult
level. The Natatorium provides a comfortable indoor swimming environment and was
specifically designed as a teaching pool with three teaching bays, a zero -depth
gradually sloped ramp, and lap swim lane space. The swim school curriculum was
developed and designed specifically for The Wave Swim School.
Level July 2019
Parent/Child 31
Preschool (ages 3 to 5) 113
Youth (ages 6 to 12) 240
Teen & Adult 23
Total Registration 407
DUBLIN GREEN GATOR AND JR GREEN GATOR SWIM TEAMS
On Saturday, July 20, 2019 the Dublin Green Gators concluded their season in first
place at the Championship Meet at Las Positas College. The team began in 1989 at the
Dublin Swim Center and this season celebrated its 30th anniversary as well as its 5th
consecutive League Championship.
The Junior Green Gators began on June 4 and held practice on Tuesday, Wednesd ay
and Thursday evenings from 6:00pm to 8:00pm. Their first intra-squad competition was
held on June 28, 2019 and their final meet was held on July 26, 2019.
FITNESS SWIMMING
Fitness Swimming at the Wave includes lap swimming for adults, junior lap swimming
for ages 10+, and water walking. Fitness Swimming is offered Monday through
Saturday mornings, and Sunday through Thursday evenings. Participants have the
option to pay a daily admission fee per visit or purchase a Fitness Convenience Pass
for pre-paid admissions at a discounted rate. Kick boards and pull buoys are available
for participants during Fitness Swimming hours.
Admission Type July 2019
Lap Swim Daily Visit 183
Convenience Pass Visits 522
3.3
Packet Pg. 21
Page 7 of 7
Convenience Passes 76
AQUA AEROBICS
Aqua Aerobics is a low impact, easy paced fitness class which tones, sculpts and
improves cardio fitness. The natural resistance and buoyancy of the water is used to
provide a wide variety of conditioning benefits with little or no impact on joints and no
swimming is required. Aqua Aerobics is offered Mondays and Wednesdays, 7:00 PM -
7:50 PM.
Register Type July 2019
Resident 26
Non-Resident 12
Total Registration 38
STRATEGIC PLAN INITIATIVE:
N/A
NOTICING REQUIREMENTS/PUBLIC OUTREACH:
N/A
AT TACHMENTS:
N/A
ATTACHMENTS:
None.
3.3
Packet Pg. 22
Page 1 of 2
STAFF REPORT
PARKS & COMMUNITY SERVICES COMMISSION
DATE: August 19, 2019
TO: Honorable Chair and Commissioners
FROM:
La Shawn Butler, Parks & Community Services Director
SUBJECT:
Dublin Library Quarterly Report: April - June 2019
Prepared by: Rhonda Franklin, Management Analyst II
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY:
The Commission will receive a quarterly report for the Dublin Library.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Receive the report.
FINANCIAL IMPACT:
N/A
DESCRIPTION:
Since opening in April 2003, funding for the Dublin Public Library has been a
partnership between Alameda County Library and the City of Dublin. The Library is
currently open 51 hours per week, excluding holidays, during which the Library operates
a circulation desk, and a variety of programs, activities, and events. On a quarterly
basis the Dublin Library provides a quarterly report that highlights Library related:
programs and services;
collaboration, partnerships, and community outreach;
statistical data; and
upcoming events and programs.
Attachment 1 provides the Library Quarterly Report for the period of April - June 2019.
NOTICING REQUIREMENTS/PUBLIC OUTREACH:
A copy of this Staff Report was provided to Alameda County Library.
ATTACHMENTS:
1. Dublin Library Quarterly Report
3.4
Packet Pg. 23
Page 2 of 2
3.4
Packet Pg. 24
Cindy Chadwick, County Librarian
Albany
Castro Valley
Centerville
Dublin
Fremont Main
Irvington
Newark
Niles
San Lorenzo
Union City
Learning Group
Dublin Library Quarterly Report
(April – June 2019)
Program and Service Highlights
In April, we held many events during Spring Break week. We hosted the Art is Education Family workshop,
a board game afternoon for families, and Puppet Art Theater Co. performed Bunny Boot Camp.
On May 1, we held a special craft time at the end of SMART (our early literacy program) in honor of the
50th anniversary of the publication of The Very Hungry Caterpillar!
Children’s staff put together a program for May 4. We had 107 participants, and the 501st Legion sent over
a Storm Trooper and Tai Fighter who posed with the group, and took a turn around the library.
Summer started on June 1 with over 100 children signing up to play the summer reading game. Children’s
staff hosted eight programs (120 people attended each), including Wildmind Science, who gave a
presentation about rainforest animals, and highlighted four of their rescued animals.
Our second teen escape room was a success – we launched the Imprisoned at Hogwarts room on June 20,
and ran it three days for multiple groups. Close to 100 people participated in the escape room over the
three days. Most groups were successful in escaping the room, and everyone had a great time.
Palo Alto and Concord VA mobile outreach vans launched monthly visits, providing help with eligibility
and enrollment for various veteran’s benefits and offering information and services to area veterans.
A variety of new adult programs including Indian classical dance performance, making air plant t errariums,
cross-stitch and craft with pressed flowers were introduced this quarter.
New People, Initiatives, and Activities
Librarians interviewed 60+ teens for summer reading volunteer positions. At the end of June, teen
volunteers had completed 200 hours of community service.
We also accepted almost 70 middle school volunteers to run the summer reading game table, and at the
end of June, volunteers had completed 260 hours of community service.
A new teen librarian, Sigriet Ferrer joined the Dublin library this quarter. In addition, Alisa Haggerty,
currently pursuing MLIS at San Jose State library school was recruited as Youth Services Intern to help
support children’s services. Alisa’s internship will end in the middle of August 2019.
3.4.a
Packet Pg. 25 Attachment: 1. Dublin Library Quarterly Report (Dublin Library Quarterly Report: April - June 2019)
Collaboration , Partnerships, and Community Outreach
Overbooked, the 7th/8th grade book discussion group, co-hosted by Dublin High School librarian held the
last meetings of the school year. Almost thirty students participated between the three schools.
Valley High School came to the library for a class visit on May 14. Mary Ayers gave them a tour, and talked
about some of the relevant databases and online resources that the library offers.
ABODE staff (a non-profit group offering housing support services) in Dublin brought a group of children
and parents in to the library for a short story time and library tour. The group also signed up to play the
Summer Reading Game.
Dublin library staff participated in local librarian’s meetup hosted by Los Positas college librarian. In
addition, Shammi did a presentation about library resources at the request of English Language
Development Specialist from Dublin/Frederiksen Elementary school.
Coming Up Next Quarter
Collaborate with the City to offer a second Fixit Clinic and with volunteers to teach adult arts and crafts.
Work with California Writer’s Club Tri-Valley Branch to plan the second annual Local Author Showcase.
Recruit veteran work-study students and volunteers to coach veterans and their families about benefits
available to them through Veterans Connect.
Plan a Teen program to make and personalize tote bag for Banned Book week.
In addition to the ongoing weekly SMART program, new stem themed programs, and additional story
times are being planned for the next quarter.
May the 4th A Very Hungry Caterpillar Magic Dan
3.4.a
Packet Pg. 26 Attachment: 1. Dublin Library Quarterly Report (Dublin Library Quarterly Report: April - June 2019)
Statistical Report
Facility Use This Quarter Last Year
Number of Items Borrowed 133,541 135,971
Number of Visitors 77,328 75,274
Average Daily Visitors 1,004 978
Public Computer Use 6,188 5,433
Volunteers
Number of Adult Volunteers 32 27
Number of Youth Volunteers 62 42
Total Hours Volunteered 599.8 774
Library Programs
For Adults 69 42
For Children 21 21
For Teens 10 4
Total Programs 101 67
Total Program Attendance 2,900 1,896
____________________________________
Cindy Chadwick
County Librarian
3.4.a
Packet Pg. 27 Attachment: 1. Dublin Library Quarterly Report (Dublin Library Quarterly Report: April - June 2019)
Page 1 of 3
STAFF REPORT
PARKS & COMMUNITY SERVICES COMMISSION
DATE: August 19, 2019
TO: Honorable Chair and Commissioners
FROM:
La Shawn Butler, Parks & Community Services Director
SUBJECT:
Jordan Ranch Neighborhood Park Art Selection
Prepared by: Rich Jochner, Recreation Supervisor
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY:
The Parks and Community Services Commission will make a recommendation on public
art for Jordan Ranch Park.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Recommend the public artwork proposed by Yoshio Taylor for City Council approval.
FINANCIAL IMPACT:
The adopted Capital Improvement Project budget for Jordan Ranch Park Art (PK0318)
is $46,980, with $41,000 budgeted for improvements. This will include the artist's fee as
well as all design, materials, fabrication, and installation costs. The funding source is the
Public Art Fund.
DESCRIPTION:
Jordan Ranch Park is a 4.9-acre neighborhood park nestled against open space,
dedicated in 2018. Amenities include two playground areas (for ages 2 -5 and 6 and
up); a basketball court; a grass volleyball court; a group picnic area with tables and
barbecues; spaces for informal family picnics; an open space meadow for informal
sports, games, and activities; trail access; water fountains; and restrooms.
There are five possible seat walls in the playground area, ranging in length from 10’ to
20’. The seat walls are 18”-24” tall. At a minimum, the longest seat wall, Bench A,
should have tile art. (Attachment 1) The seat walls have skateboard bumpers. It is
anticipated that skateboarders may attempt to skate on at least some of these walls,
particularly Benches D and E, which are adjacent to sidewalks
In May 2019, an ad-hoc art committee consisting of Robert Bennett, Kristen Speck,
Neelima Thamabala, Evelyn Zhang and Dipti Mallik reviewed portfolios of six tile artists,
including some prequalified and some invitational. They requested five artists submit
7.1
Packet Pg. 28
Page 2 of 3
site specific designs.
In June 2019, the committee reconvened with Robert Bennett, Evelyn Zhang,
Sangreetha Nagaraj and Felicia W ong present to hear design proposals from four
artists (or artist teams).
Artists were Arteclettica, Denise Hart, Rachel Rodi and Yoshio Taylor. A fifth artist semi-
finalist, Juan Lopez declined to submit a proposal.
Committee members were invited to personally rank the four submissions, on a scale
with one being their first choice and four being their last choice. In the initial ranking
vote, proposals from Denise Hart and Yoshio Taylor were tied for first place with two
first place votes each, but Yoshio Taylor had a higher overall average score.
After some discussion on the merits of each design, the committee recommended
Yoshio Taylor be selected as their choice.
Sacramento-based sculptor Yoshio Taylor’s design comprises decorative tiled
installations on low curved cement seating areas, set around the playground area on
Benches A and B. Each one comprises a design for the wall front, and on top of a
concrete substrate. The design will be educational as well as visually enriching. The
design will show some of the historical significance of Dublin and its surrounding area,
with an emphasis on nature. (Attachment 2)
The types of tile used will include handmade and carved relief terra -cotta tiles, with
representational images such as numbers, letters, h orses, trains, flowers and wildlife.
Imported porcelain tiles and glass tiles will represent water, and unglazed commercial
tiles will be used as a community involvement project with Dublin school children.
The Art Selection Committee felt strongly that the facade of Bench C should also be
decorated. They requested that the artist present an option for decorating benches A, B
and C, and noted a willingness to sacrifice some of the intricate carving detail in order to
stretch the budget to decorate three benches
As is Dublin’s practice, the proposal was reviewed by the City’s contract conservator
(Attachment 3) and City staff. The artwork is expected to be durable and low
maintenance. The conservator recommends minimizing exposure to water, obtaining
warranties for the tiling products, stockpiling replacement tiles and documenting the
piece thoroughly upon installation to ensure any future repairs preserve the artistic
vision.
The Heritage and Cultural Arts Commission considered this item at its July 11, 20 19
regular meeting and voted to advance the Yoshio Taylor proposal, 5 -0-0, on a motion by
Vice Chair Kathy Blackburn and seconded by Steve Minniear.
The Commission confirmed that the decorative tiles will be facing inward towards the
play areas; the seat wall side facing the landscaping will be without images; community
7.1
Packet Pg. 29
Page 3 of 3
members with historical knowledge of the City will be consulted; schools in the
surrounding area will be contacted so children can participate in designing ti les; and
Bench C (side facing playground only) will be added possibly sacrificing some of the
intricate carving detail in all of the benches in order to stretch the budget to decorate
three benches.
Staff, the ad-hoc art committee, and the Heritage and Cultural Arts Commission
recommend Yoshio Taylor’s design, be recommended to City Council as public art for
the Jordan Ranch Park.
STRATEGIC PLAN INITIATIVE:
N/A
NOTICING REQUIREMENTS/PUBLIC OUTREACH:
N/A
ATTACHMENTS:
1. Jordan Ranch Park Overhead View Showing Art Location
2. Yoshio Taylor Resume and Jordan Ranch Park Proposal
3. Art Conservator's Evaluation of Yoshio Taylor's Jordan Ranch Park Proposal
7.1
Packet Pg. 30
A
B
C
D
E
A - 19”H x 18”W x 51-52”L (5 sections)
B - 17-5/8”H x 17-18”W x 48”L (4 sections)
C - 18”H x 18”W x 60”L (2 sections)
D - 19”H x 18”W x 65”L (2 sections)
E - 20”H x 17.5”W x 55-56”L (2 sections)
All measurements are approximate and may vary based
on the curvature of the seat walls.
7.1.a
Packet Pg. 31 Attachment: 1. Jordan Ranch Park Overhead View Showing Art Location (Jordan Ranch Park Art Selection)
7.1.b
Packet Pg. 32 Attachment: 2. Yoshio Taylor Resume and Jordan Ranch Park Proposal (Jordan Ranch Park Art Selection)
7.1.b
Packet Pg. 33 Attachment: 2. Yoshio Taylor Resume and Jordan Ranch Park Proposal (Jordan Ranch Park Art Selection)
7.1.b
Packet Pg. 34 Attachment: 2. Yoshio Taylor Resume and Jordan Ranch Park Proposal (Jordan Ranch Park Art Selection)
7.1.b
Packet Pg. 35 Attachment: 2. Yoshio Taylor Resume and Jordan Ranch Park Proposal (Jordan Ranch Park Art Selection)
7.1.b
Packet Pg. 36 Attachment: 2. Yoshio Taylor Resume and Jordan Ranch Park Proposal (Jordan Ranch Park Art Selection)
7.1.b
Packet Pg. 37 Attachment: 2. Yoshio Taylor Resume and Jordan Ranch Park Proposal (Jordan Ranch Park Art Selection)
7.1.b
Packet Pg. 38 Attachment: 2. Yoshio Taylor Resume and Jordan Ranch Park Proposal (Jordan Ranch Park Art
7.1.b
Packet Pg. 39 Attachment: 2. Yoshio Taylor Resume and Jordan Ranch Park Proposal (Jordan Ranch Park Art
7.1.b
Packet Pg. 40 Attachment: 2. Yoshio Taylor Resume and Jordan Ranch Park Proposal (Jordan Ranch Park Art
7.1.b
Packet Pg. 41 Attachment: 2. Yoshio Taylor Resume and Jordan Ranch Park Proposal (Jordan Ranch Park Art
7.1.b
Packet Pg. 42 Attachment: 2. Yoshio Taylor Resume and Jordan Ranch Park Proposal (Jordan Ranch Park Art
Conservation Assessment
Date: 6-20-19
Client: City of Dublin, Attn: Tegan McLane, Rich Jochner
Job #: 2019/201
Object: Proposed Tiled Installations for Jordan Ranch Neighborhood Park, Dublin:
Detail of Proposed Design
Description and Materials:
Design Description:
is design by Yoshio Taylor comprises decorative tiled installations on low curved cement walls, intended to be seating areas,
set around a playground area in Jordan Ranch Neighborhood Park. Each one comprises a design for the wall front, and on top
of a concrete substrate.
Proposed Measurements:
A - 19”H x 18”W x 51-52”L (5 sections)
B - 17-5/8”H x 17-18”W x 48”L (4 sections)
C - 18”H x 18”W x 60”L (2 sections)
D - 19”H x 18”W x 65”L (2 sections)
E - 20”H x 17.5”W x 55-56”L (2 sections)
Preservation-Arts.com 510.808.7894 info@preservation-arts.com 743 47th Street #102, Oakland, CA 94609
7.1.c
Packet Pg. 43 Attachment: 3. Art Conservator's Evaluation of Yoshio Taylor's Jordan Ranch Park Proposal (Jordan Ranch Park Art Selection)
Conservation Assessment of Proposed Tiled artworks for Jordan Ranch Neighborhood Park, Dublin
Planned Location of Benches
Design:
Designs are in a preliminary stage, but the proposed decorative schemes are below. e artist’s vision is to integrate images of
nature, the importance of water in Dublin’s history (represented by blue tile), and the impact of the Transcontinental Railway
on the region in the form of images of trains and horses. Some of the tiles will be decorated by local children.
Detail of Design with Shamrock Motif (Artist Drawing)
Preservation-Arts.com Page 2 of 6
7.1.c
Packet Pg. 44 Attachment: 3. Art Conservator's Evaluation of Yoshio Taylor's Jordan Ranch Park Proposal (Jordan Ranch Park Art Selection)
Conservation Assessment of Proposed Tiled artworks for Jordan Ranch Neighborhood Park, Dublin
Artist Drawing of Proposed Designs for Front of 21’ wall (above), Top Surface (middle) and Front Surface of 16’ wall (below)
Tile Layout (see Artist Diagram Below):
e upper front surfaces of the benches and top surface will be primarily shades of imported blue porcelain and glass tile
measuring ¾ x ¾ x ¼”.
e top surface will also have an edging consisting of 4 x 4 x 1/4” glazed paver tiles.
e lower front decorative eld will be composed of handmade and carved terracotta relief tiles, 2-12” high and 1” thick.
Cross Section of Wall Construction
Preservation-Arts.com Page 3 of 6
7.1.c
Packet Pg. 45 Attachment: 3. Art Conservator's Evaluation of Yoshio Taylor's Jordan Ranch Park Proposal (Jordan Ranch Park Art Selection)
Conservation Assessment of Proposed Tiled artworks for Jordan Ranch Neighborhood Park, Dublin
Materials:
e artist provided the following information via email regarding the materials for attaching the tiles.
Mortar: Custom Building Products, Versabond forti ed thin-set mortar.
Grout: Custom Building Products, Poly blend, DeLorean gray sanded grout #165.
Sealer: Custom Building Products, Tile lab grout and tile sealer.
Concrete Cleaner: Scotts outdoor cleaner concentrate.
Assessment of Di erent Elements and Maintenance Issues:
Tiling and Material Choices:
1. in Set Mortar
e rst stage of installation is application of a thin set mortar. e artist is proposing to use Versabond forti ed thin-set
mortar by Custom Building Products. is product is a professional formula, all-purpose mortar, polymer-modi ed to
provide good bond strength for oor and tile projects. VersaBond® cures uickly even in cold climates and adheres to most
surfaces, exceeding ANSI A118.4 and A118.11 without the need for additives. It is suitable for the California temperatures and
is a dry, proprietary blend of Portland cement, copolymers, inorganic a regates and chemicals.
is is a commonly used thin set mortar used by artists for outdoor tile installations and will be suitable if the moisture
barrier recommendations are taken, and the manufacturer’s speci cations are followed.
2. Grout
e artist has su ested using Custom Building Products, poly blend, DeLorean gray sanded grout #165.
Polyblend® Sanded Grout is a dry, Portland cement based grout with silica sand, inorganic a regates and chemicals.
It has passed a number of Applicable Standards American National Standards Institute (ANSI) ANSI A108.10 & A118.6 of the
American National Standards for the Installation of Ceramic Tile ASTM International (ASTM) ASTM C109 Standard Test
Method for Compressive Strength of Hydraulic Cement Mortars (Using 2-in. or (50-mm) Cube Specimens) ASTM C531
Standard Test Method for Linear Shrinkage ASTM C580 Standard Test method for Flexural Strength ISO 13007-3 Approvals
Polyblend® Sanded Grout exceeds ANSI A118.6 standards.
Installation must conform to ANSI A108.10.
e di erence between a sanded grout and a non-sanded grout is thickness of the grout line and type of tile since sanded
grout is more likely to scratch a highly polished tile surface during appliction. Non-sanded grout is only suitable for a grout
line of up to ⅛” thick, so the sanded option may be a good choice based on the likely variation in size of grout lines from
handmade terracotta relief tiles.
3. Sealer
e artist is recommending Tile lab grout and tile sealer, by Custom Building Products. I could not nd this product, but the
company recommends a water based uoropolymer called A ua Mix® Sealer’s Choice® Gold to be used with the other two
products listed above. is is the most protective of their sealants and works by reducing the porosity of the grout to reduce
staining. Fluoropolymers are one of the most high performance coatings currently available in the li uid coatings industry,
and it can be reapplied in the future.
Preservation-Arts.com Page 4 of 6
7.1.c
Packet Pg. 46 Attachment: 3. Art Conservator's Evaluation of Yoshio Taylor's Jordan Ranch Park Proposal (Jordan Ranch Park Art Selection)
Conservation Assessment of Proposed Tiled artworks for Jordan Ranch Neighborhood Park, Dublin
4. Warranties
Warranties are always worth obtaining if available and Custom Building Products do provide a limited one year warranty for
their products to the original owner. For commercial installations, longer warranties including lifetime warranties, can be
obtained so long as the system is all Custom Building Products, and it is pre-approved by the company and recommended
manufacturing speci cations are followed. e phone number to call is 1 800 272 8786.
5. Skilled Installers
e artist notes in the proposal that he and an assistant will be undertaking the tiling themselves, ‘unless they are not able to
do so’. Commercial warranties do not necessarily re uire the use of a certi ed tile contractors, 5 star NTCA contractor or
members of the National Tile Contractors Association, but the artist will have to meet all the re uired building codes and
TCNA guidelines.
Other Considerations:
Concrete Substrate:
e benches are formed from cast concrete, presumably with an iron armature. All are located with their backs to
landscaping, a combination of grass, dirt and plants. e watering system is unknown, but moisture holding materials such as
dirt will be in contact with the underside of the concrete slabs as well as the rear sides. In addition, the concrete could be in
direct contact from recycled water from irrigation systems.
Constant moisture against concrete can lead to a number of issues such as salt formation/e orescence on the concrete and
mortar that appears as white insoluble crystals and blanching of the color on tiles. Chloride ions in recycled water can also
lead to rusting of the iron rebar armature within the concrete, that expands the metal leading to cracks and ultimately losses
of concrete and tile.
e City can help by minimizing risks and long term maintenance costs by taking some precautions during the casting and
installation process:
●Installing a vapor barrier underneath the slab during casting
●Having an area of hard landscaping, 12-24” behind the benches to act as a barrier layer to moisture
●Installing a drip system so that no sprinkler water comes into contact with the artworks
●Applying a coating to the concrete before the mortar is applied. is should be compatible with the mortar used by
the artist. Since the artist is planning to use a Custom Building Products system, the same company should
recommend a sealer. e company currently recommends RedGard® Waterproo ng and Crack Prevention
Membrane.
Stockpiling Tiles:
Although tiled artworks are generally one of the most stable types of public art installations, one of the problems for long
term preservation is the availability of replacement tiles. Manufacturers o en change the range of colors of a particular line or
designs are phased out. Because of this, it is recommended for the City to re uest a stockpile of replacement tiles for repairs
over time. Edges tend to be the rst area where losses form, and so having a selection of tiles to choose from will extend the
life of the artwork and maintain the artist’s vision for the longest possible time.
e artist provided the following information on the tile suppliers:
Dal tile Sacramento, contact is DA for unglazed 4"x 4" edge unglazed tiles.
Cortopassi Tile and Stone Sacramento for the other tiles-contact is George.
Preservation-Arts.com Page 5 of 6
7.1.c
Packet Pg. 47 Attachment: 3. Art Conservator's Evaluation of Yoshio Taylor's Jordan Ranch Park Proposal (Jordan Ranch Park Art Selection)
Conservation Assessment of Proposed Tiled artworks for Jordan Ranch Neighborhood Park, Dublin
Skate Boarders:
Although the Park is hopefully gated, skateboarders can be very attracted to grinding along the edges of curved walls. is
results in loss and breakage of the tiles along the edges. e City should monitor this situation and consider some
clips/deterrents if this is seen to be happening. Since the benches are already formed, perhaps this can be monitored before
the tile is installed.
Documentation:
As damage and losses occur to the artwork over time, it is helpful to have a full detailed photographic record of the decorative
scheme in the archives to refer to. is can be undertaken by the conservators shortly a er installation.
Recommendations:
●Minimizing moisture in and against the concrete benches will ensure the long term preservation of this artwork and
minimize maintenance costs over the long term.
●Obtaining warranties for the tiling products is recommended, and will ensure that the tiling is installed according to
manufacturer's speci cations.
●Stockpiling tiles will ensure replacements are available in case losses occur.
●Documenting using detailed photography of the di erent sections will enable losses to be repaired accurately over
time, and ensure that the artistic vision is preserved.
Maintenance Budget:
Estimated Annual Maintenance:
To include surface cleaning, replacing missing tiles, and periodic recoating of the A ua Mix® Sealer’s Choice® Gold
NB: is assumes that there are no issues from moisture and all the recommendations noted above have been addressed.
Team of 2 people for one 8 hour day, with documentation, materials and travel:
Conservator- 8 hours x $120=$960
Technician- 8 hours x $95=$760
Documentation: 2 hours $240
Travel: $60
Materials: $150
Total : $2,120
*Every year, it is anticipated that the costs may increase as losses occur, and replenishing the sealer every two-three years.
Conclusions:
In general, the artwork looks well thought out with a good uality range of materials being proposed. With a few precautions
at the beginning, this artwork should re uire relatively low maintenance and last an extended period of time.
Preservation-Arts.com Page 6 of 6
7.1.c
Packet Pg. 48 Attachment: 3. Art Conservator's Evaluation of Yoshio Taylor's Jordan Ranch Park Proposal (Jordan Ranch Park Art Selection)
Page 1 of 3
STAFF REPORT
PARKS & COMMUNITY SERVICES COMMISSION
DATE: August 19, 2019
TO: Honorable Chair and Commissioners
FROM:
La Shawn Butler, Parks & Community Services Director
SUBJECT:
Butterfly Knoll Park Art Selection
Prepared by: Rich Jochner, Recreation Supervisor
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY:
The Parks and Community Services Commission will make a recommendation on public
art for Butterfly Knoll Park.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Recommend the public artwork proposed by Joey Rose for City Council approval.
FINANCIAL IMPACT:
The adopted Capital Improvement Project budget for the Butterfly Knoll Park Public Art
(PK0118) is $17,560 with $13,060 slated for payment to the artist from the Public Art
Fund.
DESCRIPTION:
Butterfly Knoll Park (Palisides Drive & Rosamund Hills) is a one-acre neighborhood park
nestled against open space. The park has yet to be built. Amenities will include two
playground areas (for ages 2-5 and 6 and up); group picnic areas with tables and
barbecues; spaces for informal family picnics; an open space meadow for informal
sports, games, and activities; trail access; butterfly-friendly flower garden, owl boxes
and water fountains.
Public art is intended for the proposed staircase façade and the side rails of the
staircase leading from the park to the street above totaling 170 square feet. (Attachment
1)
For this project, it was requested that the artist interact with the neighborhood residents,
especially children. This could include a design which has built -in areas to incorporate
images or words suggested by neighborhood residents; an opportunity for
7.2
Packet Pg. 49
Page 2 of 3
neighborhood residents to choose among images or colors proposed by the artist; a
plan for involving residents in the installation process; or any other outreach activities
proposed by the artist.
In July 2019, an art selection committee consisting of Dublin residents Catheryn Grier,
Steve Minniear, Michelle Smith McDonald, Dayna Tutino and Sawsan Wolski heard
design proposals from four artists who submitted as part of an open call. (Catheryn
Grier’s alternate, Sawsan Wolski, participated as a voting member to bring the
committee size to five people. Both members of one of the other primary-alternate pairs
were absent.)
Artists submitting proposals were Morgan Bricca, Suzanne Gayle, Juan Lopez and Joey
Rose.
Committee members were invited to rank the four submissions, on a scale with one
being their first choice and four being their last choice. In the initial ranking vote, the
proposal from Joey Rose received three first place votes, with Morgan Bricca receiving
the other two first place votes.
After some discussion on the merits of each design, the committee recommended Joey
Rose be selected as their choice.
Walnut Creek-based muralist Joey Rose’s design is dedicated to native, Bay Area
species of butterflies. The left wall is inspired by butterfly wings and the right wall is
inspired by the butterfly’s corresponding caterpillar. If you walk a straight line from a
caterpillar to a butterfly, the species will match. The paintings will wrap around the wall
at the top of the stairs to be seen at street level. Each stair leading up to the street will
be painted an individual color, enhancing the connection between the walls and creating
an eye-catching gradient. (Attachments 2 & 3)
Labeling or identifying each species (whether it be an interpretive sign or directly on the
wall) will make this piece engaging and educational.
The walls and steps will be primed and painted with high -quality, non-toxic exterior
mural paint. According to the artist, this should ensure that the painting doesn’t fade for
at least 15 years and maintenance should require only an occasional wash .
The community interaction component proposed by the artist is a public painting day.
Participants will be encouraged to fill the shapes with background colors. Participants
will receive seeds for native butterfly plants to grow in their own yard and one -of-a-kind
custom butterfly stickers designed by the artist.
As is Dublin’s practice, this proposed piece is being reviewed by the City’s contract
conservator and City staff.
The Heritage and Cultural Arts Commission considered this item at its August 8, 2019
regular meeting and voted to advance the Joey Rose proposal, 6 -0-0 on a motion by
7.2
Packet Pg. 50
Page 3 of 3
Commissioner Steve Minniear, and seconded by Commissioner Timea Iharosi.
NOTICING REQUIREMENTS/PUBLIC OUTREACH:
N/A
ATTACHMENTS:
1 - Butterfly Knoll Park Art Location
2 - Joey Rose’s Butterfly Knoll Park Art Proposal (written)
3 - Joey Rose’s Butterfly Knoll Park Art Proposal (conceptual)
7.2
Packet Pg. 51
Stairs - Approximately 30 sq ft. along the rise portion of the steps (7 steps @ 5” high 10’ wide)
Entry Wall— Approximately 140 sq ft. along visible façade of the wall (street entry and park walkway)
Attachment 1
7.2.a
Packet Pg. 52 Attachment: 1 - Butterfly Knoll Park Art Location (Butterfly Knoll Park Art Selection)
7.2.a
Packet Pg. 53 Attachment: 1 - Butterfly Knoll Park Art Location (Butterfly Knoll Park Art Selection)
7.2.b
Packet Pg. 54 Attachment: 2 - Joey Rose’s Butterfly Knoll Park Art Proposal (written) (Butterfly Knoll Park Art Selection)
7.2.b
Packet Pg. 55 Attachment: 2 - Joey Rose’s Butterfly Knoll Park Art Proposal (written) (Butterfly Knoll Park Art Selection)
7.2.b
Packet Pg. 56 Attachment: 2 - Joey Rose’s Butterfly Knoll Park Art Proposal (written) (Butterfly Knoll Park Art Selection)
Attachment 3
7.2.c
Packet Pg. 57 Attachment: 3 - Joey Rose’s Butterfly Knoll Park Art Proposal (conceptual) (Butterfly Knoll Park Art
7.2.c
Packet Pg. 58 Attachment: 3 - Joey Rose’s Butterfly Knoll Park Art Proposal (conceptual) (Butterfly Knoll Park Art
7.2.c
Packet Pg. 59 Attachment: 3 - Joey Rose’s Butterfly Knoll Park Art Proposal (conceptual) (Butterfly Knoll Park Art
7.2.c
Packet Pg. 60 Attachment: 3 - Joey Rose’s Butterfly Knoll Park Art Proposal (conceptual) (Butterfly Knoll Park Art
Page 1 of 3
STAFF REPORT
PARKS & COMMUNITY SERVICES COMMISSION
DATE: August 19, 2019
TO: Honorable Chair and Commissioners
FROM:
La Shawn Butler, Parks & Community Services Director
SUBJECT:
Sean Diamond Park Art Selection
Prepared by: Tyler Phillips, Recreation Coordinator
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY:
The Parks and Community Services Commission will make a recommendation on public
art for Sean Diamond Park to the City Council.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Recommend the public artwork proposed by Saori Ide and Jonathan Russell from Ride
Art Studio for City Council approval.
FINANCIAL IMPACT:
The adopted Capital Improvement Project budget for Sean Diamond Park Art (PK0418)
is $48,000, including $42,000 for improvements (payment to artist). The funding source
is the Public Art Fund. The design proposal budget will encompass the full $42,000
improvement budget.
DESCRIPTION:
Sean Diamond Park (4801 La Strada Drive) is a neighborhood park sitting adjacent to
Jose Maria Amador Elementary School. The park was dedicated on April 28, 2018.
Amenities include Dublin’s first zipline, playground area; a tennis court; a grass
volleyball court; a group picnic area with tables and barbecues; an open space meadow
for informal sports, games, and activities; park benches; and re strooms.
The artwork will be installed in the center of the park in the open circular area as shown
in the attached photographs (Attachment 1). This circular area has a diameter of 22
feet.
In May 2019, an art committee consisting of Kathy Blackburn, Michelle Smith
McDonald, Shweta Agrawal, Tejas Peesapati, and Hana Xu reviewed portfolios of six
artists, including some prequalified and some invitational. They requested four artists
7.3
Packet Pg. 61
Page 2 of 3
submit site specific designs.
In June 2019, the committee reconvened with Gina Gabrielle, Shweta Agrawal, and
Hana Xu present to hear design proposals from four artists (or artist teams).
Artists were Adan Romo, Colin Selig, Saori Ide & Jonathan Russell from Ride Arts
Studio, and Yoshio Taylor.
Committee members were invited to personally rank the four submissions, on a scale
with one being their first choice and four being their last choice. In the initial ranking
vote, artist team Saori Ide & Jonathan Russel had two first place votes and Yoshio
Taylor was a close second.
After some discussion on the merits of each design, the committee recommended Saori
Ide and Jonathan Russell as the first choice but also wanted to recommend Yoshio
Taylor as a possible alternate choice.
Saori Ide and Jonathan Russell’s design named DIAMOND is an 18’ high kinetic wind
sculpture made of stainless steel. This large sculpture features two diamond shapes,
one nestled inside of the other, that move with the wind in opposite directions. The base
of the sculpture is a four-sided tapered column with green diamond shaped folded
leaves around the top of the base, which are designed to cast shadow patterns on the
ground as the sun shines through them. (Attachment 2).
Yoshio Taylor’s design for Sean Diamond Park is being recommended as an alternate
option by the art selection committee. Yoshio Taylor’s proposal will use a combination of
bronze, steel, concrete, and hand-made-terra-cotta relief tiles. The sculpture will stand
at approximately 12 feet tall and a four-foot-wide concrete base. At the top of the
sculpture will be four bronze paper planes welded to the spiral and a curved stainless
steel loop form. The base will have several laser-cut clover designs. At the base of the
sculpture will be the terra-cotta relief tiles with images of the region’s wildlife, plants, and
names that have historical significance to Dublin. (Attachment 4).
One member of the Art Selection committee had concerns about Saori Ide and
Jonathan Russell’s piece's bright color and problematic feng shui. The diamond shape
has a point at the top and points at the midsection which, in Asian cultures, is
considered to represent a knife and therefore attract bad luck. Problematic feng shui
can be mitigated through design, so it was suggested that the artist be informed of the
concern and asked to mitigate. The Committee member also indicated that the points
might not be offensive when the piece is in motion; it was suggested the artist provide
an animated rendering to show the piece in motion. (Attachment 3)
As is Dublin’s practice, the proposals were reviewed by the City’s contract conservator
(Attachment 5) and City staff and based on these reviews, Staff concurred with the
committee’s recommendation of Saori Ide and Jonathan Russell. Their art proposal
works within the context and theme of the park, the work has permanence and will hold
7.3
Packet Pg. 62
Page 3 of 3
up well over a long period of time and will be safe for public display.
The Heritage and Cultural Arts Commission considered this item at its August 8, 2019,
regular meeting and voted to advance the Saori Ide and Jonathan Russell proposal, 5-
1-0. At that meeting, both artist groups presented their proposals.
NOTICING REQUIREMENTS/PUBLIC OUTREACH:
N/A
ATTACHMENTS:
1. Sean Diamond Park Overhead
2. Ride Art Studio - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal
3. Ride Art Studio - Sean Diamond Park Proposal Animation
5. Art Conservator Evaluation
4. Yoshio Taylor - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal
7.3
Packet Pg. 63
7.3.a
Packet Pg. 64 Attachment: 1. Sean Diamond Park Overhead (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
Saori Ide & Jonathan Russell RIDE ART, LLC www.rideartstudio.com
2410 Valley Street, Berkeley, CA 94702
Saori Ide: (415) 902-0343 saori@rideartstudio.com Jonathan Russell: (415) 902-4350 jr@rideartstudio.com
TEAM RESUME
PUBLIC AND PRIVATE ART COMMISSIONS
2019 Harvest: Roundabout Sculpture – Old Redwood Highway: Town of Windsor, CA ($150,000.)
– IN PROGRESS (Estimated completion date: December 2019)
2018 Transitions: series of 4 kinetic wind sculptures – City of Boise Vista Avenue Gateway Project: Boise, ID
($150,000.) – IN PROGRESS (Estimated completion date: August 2019)
2018 Energy Ring: kinetic wind sculpture - Marriot Hotel & Conference Center: Odessa, TX ($150,000.)
– IN PROGRESS (Estimated completion date: June 2019)
2018 Guiding Light: kinetic wind sculpture - RTD Westminster Station Plaza: Westminster, CO ($60,000.)
2017 Harmony Tree: kinetic wind sculpture - City Hall Plaza: Morgan Hill, CA ($100,000.)
2017 Passages: kinetic wind sculpture - Downtown Art Project: Brighton, CO ($150,000.)
2016 Songs of the Everglades: series of 8 kinetic wind sculptures - Port Everglades Cruise Terminal 4:
Fort Lauderdale, FL ($100,000.)
2015 Synthesis: kinetic wind sculpture - S. Delaware Street Project: San Mateo, CA ($100,000.)
2014 Reflections: kinetic wind sculpture - Lincoln Ave. Project: San Jose, CA (Budget: $60,000.)
2013 San Pablo Avenue Streetscape: series of 12 kinetic wind sculptures - San Pablo Ave. Streetscape
Project: El Cerrito, CA (Budget: $100,000.)
2012 Circles of Life - Union City Sports Center: Union City, CA (Budget: $100,000.)
2012 Unity: memorial and recognition sculpture – San Bruno City Park: San Bruno, CA (Budget: $50,000.)
2002 Artists Chair: Red - Palos Verdes Center for the Arts, Rancho Palos Verdes, CA
2001 Bodies in Progress - Yerba Buena Center for the Arts, San Francisco, CA – Jonathan Russell
2001 Artists Chair - Yerba Buena Center for the Arts, San Francisco, CA
2000 Bodies in Progress - Tacheles, Berlin Germany – Jonathan Russell
1999 Cod in the Wind - Commonwealth of Massachusetts Tetlow Park, Boston, MA (Budget: 50,000) –
Jonathan Russell
1996 Light Installation, Salem, MA. Cape Pond Ice Co Inc. – Jonathan Russell
1995 "NEW ENGLAND WOMAN OF THE YEAR " Sculpture - Commissioned by the MA Mental Health Assoc.
Currently installed in Boston Red Sox Club House - Fenway Park – Jonathan Russell
TEAM MEMBERS
Saori Ide – Lead Artist
Saori Ide, born in Japan, graduated from University of New Mexico with an emphasis in environmental sculpture and
installation art. Her strong contribution to our teamwork is her unique sense of space and design, organizational and
time management skills, budgeting and planning, and creating presentation materials.
Jonathan Russell
Jonathan Russell, graduated from Massachusetts College of Art, is a professor at the Academy of Art University in San
Francisco and the founder of the Red Metal Arts studio and JR Casting Co. His extensive knowledge of materials and
the technical aspects of problem solving guarantee safe and maintenance free public works.
We oversee all aspects of our projects, from creating structurally certified and engineered drawings, selection of
appropriate materials, fabrication in our own fully equipped studio and installation. Our fabrication materials are
chosen for their proven record of outdoor durability. Special consideration is given to issues of pedestrian safety, ADA
compliance and vandalism.
7.3.b
Packet Pg. 65 Attachment: 2. Ride Art Studio - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
DESIGN PROPOSAL COVERSHEET:
Public Art -Sean Diamon Park Art
Proposals will not be accepted after Monday, June 17, 2019, 5:00 p.m.
Artist: ___ S_a_o_r_i _ld_e_&_!J!.__o_n_a_th_a_n_R_u_s_se_l_l _________ _
Address: ---=2:.....:.4...:...1..:..0_V:....:a=-:..ll:..:eLy:....:S:..:t::_re::..:e:..:t:__ _____________ _
City: ____ B_er_k_e_le_..y.____ ______ State: __ C_A __ Zip: -------'9<-4_,__,7'-"0=2=--
Phone: 415-902-0343 Fax: ________ _
saori@rideartstudio.com . .
E-mail Address: jr~d io .co m ~sit e www.ndeartstud1o.com
s;gaawce of A,bst _:;5(yp~ Date, 06/15/2019
Please initial confirming you have read the City's standard Public Art Agreement (Attachment 2):
I have read the City's standard Public Art Agreement template and confirm that I am comfortable signing. ~ .
I have read the City's standard Public Art Agreement template and have attached any changes I request. __ _
Sean Diamond Art Project/ Proposal Instruct ions/ May 2 3, 2 019/ Pag e 4
7.3.b
Packet Pg. 66 Attachment: 2. Ride Art Studio - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
7.3.b
Packet Pg. 67 Attachment: 2. Ride Art Studio - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal (Sean
7.3.b
Packet Pg. 68 Attachment: 2. Ride Art Studio - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal (Sean
7.3.b
Packet Pg. 69 Attachment: 2. Ride Art Studio - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
DIAMOND: KINETIC WIND SCULPTURE
for Sean Diamond Park - Dublin, CA
BY SAORI IDE AND JONATHAN RUSSELL
NARRATIVE / CONCEPT:
We’re very pleased to submit our proposal for Sean Diamond Park. We recently visited and
were struck by how beautifully designed it is, with such great park amenities. When we
approached the proposed site, we noticed the open space and felt an enormous connection to
both the sky and the earth. We also loved the flowers that were all around the park and
especially around the sculpture site. We’d like to create an artwork that enhances this setting
and invites people, young and old, to enjoy this beautiful outdoor setting.
DIAMOND is an 18’ high kinetic wind sculpture made of stainless steel. This large iconic
sculpture features two diamond shapes, one nestled inside of the other, that move with the
wind in opposite directions. This colorful artwork, visible from a distance, will welcome
residents and visitors to Sean Diamond Park. It can be enjoyed from multiple vantage points,
such as a view while sitting on a nearby bench or when walking around and even when looking
directly upward. Every view will present a different mosaic and pattern of intertwining lines. The
base of the sculpture is a four-sided tapered column that reflects the idea of a half diamond.
The green diamond shaped folded leaves around the top of the base represent individual
community members coming together to embrace and support each other. As the sun shines
through them, they cast beautiful patterns on the ground.
The tree like form of our sculpture signifies growth and resilience as it stands firmly rooted in
the ground and reaches upwards. The flower like diamond shapes represent both seeds and
blossoms; celebrating the accomplishments of this community.
7.3.b
Packet Pg. 70 Attachment: 2. Ride Art Studio - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
We have made many large wind sculptures in the past. Utilizing wind derived movement has
become an important visual tool for establishing a unique presence for our sculptures.
Elements set in motion by the wind give a moment of delightful surprise and heightened
effect. It creates an instant bonding with viewers and stimulates what we like to think of as a
nonverbal conversation.
Diamonds in many cultures signify purity, clarity and wisdom. Native Americans considered
diamonds to be signatures of the butterfly, which they often identified as a sign of immortality.
Butterflies live in migratory patterns, traveling hundreds of miles to return to their homes.
Along with immortality and being true to oneself, the diamond symbolism conveys messages
of rebirth, revival, and transformation. With these ideas in mind, we pay homage to Army Staff
Sergeant Sean Diamond for his service and the sacrifices he made for his family and
community. People will remember him as they come and enjoy the park and our perpetually
moving sculpture. It will truly be, for one and all, the “Diamond Park.”
MATERIALS:
UPPER SCULPTURE
- Outer diamond: Powdercoated stainless steel in orange
- Inner diamond: Powdercoated in stainless steel in blue
- Diamond leaves: Powdercaoted stainless steel in green
LOWER SCULPTURE
- Orbital sanded stainless steel
BEARINGS: Ceramic hybrid radial bearings
DIMENSIONS:
OVERALL DIMENSIONS: 18’ high x 9’6” diameter
BASE OF THE SCULPTURE: 18” square at the bottom and 8” square at the top
DIAMOND SHAPE: 8’ high x 6’6” diameter
7.3.b
Packet Pg. 71 Attachment: 2. Ride Art Studio - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
18’
8’
10’
9’ 6” dia.
6’ 6” dia.
Top view
18”
DIAMOND: Dimensions and Scale
7.3.b
Packet Pg. 72 Attachment: 2. Ride Art Studio - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
Top view
DIAMOND: Movement
7.3.b
Packet Pg. 73 Attachment: 2. Ride Art Studio - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
INSTALLATION PROCEDURE:
The sculpture will be delivered onsite in three separate pieces.
Using a small crane or articulating forklift, these pieces will be lifted into place and secured to a
previously installed footing. Estimated installation time: 6 hours
MAINTENANCE:
This sculpture will require minimal maintenance. At the cities discretion, the powdercoated moving
elements can be cleaned once a year with soap and water. The stainless steel base can be cleaned with
Walter X-Force Universal Cleaner.
In case of graffiti markings, this can easily be removed by orbital sanding with 100 grit pads.
PUBLIC INTERACTION / SAFETY MEASURES:
The public is encouraged to walk around and under the sculpture. We have raised the moving elements
high above the ground in order to avoid issues of safety and vandalism.
TIMELINE:
MILESTONE 1: Design Phase (1 month)
Submit schematic drawings along with an engineer stamped foundation drawing
MILESTONE 2: Fabrication (5 months)
Fabrication of artwork
MILESTONE 3: Delivery and Installation (1-2 days)
Estimated Installation Date: January 2020
7.3.b
Packet Pg. 74 Attachment: 2. Ride Art Studio - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
PROPOSED FOOTING DESIGN:
7.3.b
Packet Pg. 75 Attachment: 2. Ride Art Studio - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
PRELIMINARY BUDGET:
Descriptions Cost Total
Materials 8,000.00
All Materials 8,000.00
Design Fee 2,500.00
Artists Design Fees (Final Design Phase: Schematic and
Mechanical Drawings / Presentation / Meetings) 2,500.00
Licenses and Permits 400.00
City Permits 250.00
Business License 150.00
Professional Fees 2,800.00
Structural Enginner's Fee 2,000.00
Lawyer Fees 800.00
Insurance 800.00
Liability 800.00
Subcontractors 5,000.00
Waterjet cutting 3,000.00
Powdercoating 2,000.00
Fabrication 8,500.00
Labor 8,500.00
Site Preparation 3,300.00
Subcontractor: Footing 3,000.00
Signage / Plaque 300.00
Transportation 300.00
Drayage / Insurance 300.00
Installation 3,200.00
Labor 1,800.00
Equipment Rental 1,400.00
Overhead Expenses 3,000.00
Studio Rent 2,000.00
Utilities 300.00
Consumable Supplies 300.00
Travel Expenses ($100 x 2) 200.00
Community Outreach Activities 200.00
Artists' Fee (10%) 4,200.00
Total: $42,000.00
7.3.b
Packet Pg. 76 Attachment: 2. Ride Art Studio - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
Conservation Assessment
Date: 7-7-19
Client: City of Dublin, Attn: Tegan McLane and Tyler Phillips
Object: Proposed Artwork for Dean Diamond Park, Dublin by Saori Ide and Jonathan Russell
Detail of Proposed Design-Artist Provided
Preservation-Arts.com 510.808.7894 info@preservation-arts.com 743 47th Street #102, Oakland, CA 94609
7.3.d
Packet Pg. 77 Attachment: 5. Art Conservator Evaluation (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
Conservation Assessment of Proposed Sculpture By Saori Ide and Jonathan russell for Sean Diamond Park, Dublin
Description and Materials:
is design by Saori Ide and Johnathan Russell is a kinetic sculpture consisting of two interlocking diamond shapes that spin
in opposite directions mounted on a tall tapering stainless steel base column.
Proposed Measurements:
Height 18 feet and Diameter 9’ 6” feet.
Location:
e sculpture will be located in the Diamond Park in a circular seating area on a hard landscaping surrounded by a path with
benches and landscaping and trees (see image below).
Design:
e artist’s concept is ‘ e tree like form of our sculpture signi es growth and resilience as it stands rmly rooted in
the ground and reaches upwards. e ower like diamond shapes represent both seeds and blossoms; celebrating the
accomplishments of this community.’ Both the kinetic part of the sculpture and the four sided column are diamond inspired
motifs relating to the naming of the park.
Design Concept (Artist Rendering)
Preservation-Arts.com Page 2 of 5
7.3.d
Packet Pg. 78 Attachment: 5. Art Conservator Evaluation (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
Conservation Assessment of Proposed Sculpture By Saori Ide and Jonathan russell for Sean Diamond Park, Dublin
Artist Design with Dimensions
Materials:
e following are presented as materials for the sculpture:
UPPER SCULPTURE
- Outer diamond: Powder-coated stainless steel in orange
- Inner diamond: Powder-coated in stainless steel in blue
- Diamond leaves: Powder-coated stainless steel in green
LOWER SCULPTURE
- Orbital sanded stainless steel
BEARINGS: Ceramic hybrid radial bearings
Preservation-Arts.com Page 3 of 5
7.3.d
Packet Pg. 79 Attachment: 5. Art Conservator Evaluation (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
Conservation Assessment of Proposed Sculpture By Saori Ide and Jonathan russell for Sean Diamond Park, Dublin
Assessment of Di erent Elements and Maintenance Issues:
Choice of Metals:
e proposed design of this sculpture is primarily of stainless steel. e artists su est that the column will be four sided and
taper to the top, and the bearing housings and upper kinetic elements will also be stainless. e consistency of material
throughout is good and should prevent any galvanic corrosion issues arising.
It is recommended that a higher grade of stainless steel such as 316 or 316L is used to ensure long term stability, and it is
advised for the surface to be passivated. is is important for the column since a circular grinding pattern is being proposed.
In general, the more rough the surface of the steel, the more crevices exist for corrosion to form and a circular pattern is
generally the most di cult to maintain. e use of 316 or 316L will help with minimizing corrosion formation and all welds
should be ground as smooth as possible.
Fasteners and Welding:
e welding rod and any fasteners should be matched to the exact grade of metal to prevent galvanic corrosion.
Kinetic Elements
e upper part of the sculpture is formed of two interlocking stainless steel diamond cut outs. ese will spin in opposite
directions via a bearing system. e proposed bearings are ceramic hybrid radial bearings which should last a long time in the
outdoor environment. It is recommended for the City to have the artists provide the exact speci cations for the archives,
recommended lubricant and maintenance protocol, and provide an extra set of bearings for replacement.
Structural Review
One of the failings of tall kinetic sculptures such as this is that their velocity can destabilize the bolts that attach it to the
ground. It is therefore essential to have a structural engineer who is experienced with kinetic artworks undertake a wind
study of the location and provide stamped and guaranteed drawings for the installation. We have seen kinetic sculptures that
were structurally designed deinstalled within a relatively short period of time because they pull the bolts out of the footing,
are loud and begin to frighten the public if they spin too fast appearing dangerous.
Powder Coating:
Although powder coating is inexpensive, conservators usually do not recommend powder coating as a paint system since it
tends to chalk out (fade) and fail uicker than high performance li uid coatings. A high performance li uid coating with
appropriate primer will retain its color, be more durable and be easier to inpaint losses and undertake repairs if necessary.
All li uid coatings should be applied to the speci ed manufacturers thickness to be e ective and dry lm thicknesses should
be measured and noted in the archives in addition to the exact paint system. It is also recommended for the collection to
re uest sprayed out metal coupons of the colors to keep in the archives so that fading of the colors can be monitored.
Ability to Maintain the Sculpture:
All kinetic sculptures must be designed with a mechanism to stop the parts from moving, otherwise the artwork cannot safely
be maintained and cleaned. e height of the sculpture will re uire a boom or sca old to maintain. It is therefore important
to ensure that the pathways and access around the sculpture can accommodate this size of e uipment.
e green diamond shapes may cause an issue with reaching the upper interior elements of the sculpture if they protrude out
too far. e artist should consider this in the nal design to allow access for cleaning all surfaces.
Preservation-Arts.com Page 4 of 5
7.3.d
Packet Pg. 80 Attachment: 5. Art Conservator Evaluation (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
Conservation Assessment of Proposed Sculpture By Saori Ide and Jonathan russell for Sean Diamond Park, Dublin
Landscaping:
All landscape should be drip system and no sprinklers should be used in the vicinity. Recycled water tends to contain
chlorides that can cause ferrous corrosion uickly to form on stainless steel, and also mineral deposits that deposit insoluble
white salts on the surface.
Recommendations:
●Careful structural review and wind study of the area to design footings.
●Design of access ways to enable a boom to be driven up to the sculpture.
●Careful photo documentation of the bearing mechanism and detailed guidelines for changing out and lubricating
the bearings.
●Stockpiling a set of spare bearings and correct lubricant.
● e recommended minimum grade of stainless steel for fabrication is 316. e same for weld rod and fasteners.
● e use of a high performance li uid coating rather than a powder coat system.
Maintenance Budget:
Estimated Basic Annual Maintenance:
Team of 3 people for one 8 hour day, with documentation, materials and travel:
Conservator- 9 hours x $120=$1,080
Conservator- 9 hours x $120=$1,080
Technician- 9 hours x $95=$855
Documentation: $120
Boom Rental and pick-up and Delivery: $1,200
Travel: $60
Total : $4,395
*Major repairs will be assessed as they arise and are separate to this. .
Conclusions:
is sculpture is likely to be a successful installation if the structural review is su ciently thorough and the recommendations
above are followed. It will re uire annual maintenance to keep the sculpture in good order, although maintenance costs will be
higher than normal because of the necessity for a boom.
Preservation-Arts.com Page 5 of 5
7.3.d
Packet Pg. 81 Attachment: 5. Art Conservator Evaluation (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
Conservation Assessment
Date: 7-7-19
Client: City of Dublin, Attn: Tegan McLane and Tyler Phillips
Object: Proposed Artwork for Dean Diamond Park, Dublin
Detail of Proposed Design-Artist Drawing
Preservation-Arts.com 510.808.7894 info@preservation-arts.com 743 47th Street #102, Oakland, CA 94609
7.3.d
Packet Pg. 82 Attachment: 5. Art Conservator Evaluation (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
Conservation Assessment of Proposed Sculpture By Yoshio Taylor for Sean Diamond Park, Dublin
Description and Materials:
is design by Yoshio Taylor comprises a rusted steel support column attached to a concrete base with inlaid tiles, and a 5’ cast
bronze spiral mounted on top of the column interwoven with a stainless steel bent rod along which four bronze ‘paper’
aeroplanes are attached.
Proposed Measurements:
Height 12 feet and Diameter 4 feet
Location:
e sculpture will be located in the Diamond Park in a circular seating area on a hard landscaping surrounded by a path with
benches and landscaping and trees.
Design:
e artist’s concept is to re ect the interests of Sean Diamond a er whom the park is named and the heritage of Dublin. e
four aeroplanes represent Diamond’s love of ying and four children, and the clover leaf is the obvious reference to the City
emblem.
Design Overview (Artist Drawing)
Preservation-Arts.com Page 2 of 7
7.3.d
Packet Pg. 83 Attachment: 5. Art Conservator Evaluation (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
Conservation Assessment of Proposed Sculpture By Yoshio Taylor for Sean Diamond Park, Dublin
Artist Schematic
Preservation-Arts.com Page 3 of 7
7.3.d
Packet Pg. 84 Attachment: 5. Art Conservator Evaluation (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
Conservation Assessment of Proposed Sculpture By Yoshio Taylor for Sean Diamond Park, Dublin
Materials:
e following are presented as materials for the sculpture:
Bronze (Planes and Main Spiral)
Stainless Steel (Curving Spiral Rod to Support the Aeroplanes)
Welded Steel (Base Support-Laser Cut with Painted Interior Edges
Concrete (Base)
Hand-Made Relief Terracotta Tiles (Upper Surface of Concrete Base and Inset into Vertical Sides of Base)
Assessment of Di erent Elements and Maintenance Issues:
Choice of Metals:
is proposed sculpture combines a number of di erent metals that will be interaction with each other. Although most of the
year this will probably be ne so long as no landscaping water can reach the metal, the issue will be in the winter when rains
begin with the rainwater creating a galvanic reaction which will preferentially corrode the most anodic or reactive metal. e
galvanic table is a useful guide when combining metals and showing possible corrosion reactions. Here are a few guidelines for
fabrication to avoid preferential corrosion of the sculpture:
●Stainless steel should be of a higher grade such as 316 or 316L and it is advised for the surface to be passivated and
electropolished. e smoother the surface is polished, the less likely corrosion will form on the surfaces. Mirror
nishes always perform better than textured ones on stainless steel.
●Silicon Bronze should be patinated and waxed prior to installation, and will re uire annual maintenance to preserve
the intended patina color.
●Correct choice of welding rod between dissimilar materials is crucial to long term stability, and it should be matched
to the most cathodic or stable of the two metals to be joined.
●In all other cases where the same metal is being welded, the rod should match the exact grade of metal for best
performance.
●Fasteners should also be matched to the most cathodic material to prevent corrosion and failure.
● e weathering steel base will re uire good drainage around the bottom to prevent pooling which leads to spalling
and thinning of the metal.
● e weathering steel will also create rust ‘run o ’ during cleaning and periods of rain, and so to prevent unsightly
staining of the concrete, it is recommended to use a terracotta colored or a darker grout color and completely tile the
sides of the concrete base.
Aeroplanes: ere is a uestion of whether the artist is going to choose powder coated steel or bronze for the aeroplane
elements of the sculpture. A paint system will galvanically protect a mild steel although usually conservators do not
recommend powder coating as a paint system since it tends to chalk out and fail uicker than high performance li uid
coatings and the sculpture will need deinstallation for repainting. It may be a better choice in terms of long term preservation
and maintenance to choose bronze for the planes, and for the artist to explore the range of available patinas, since the
sculpture should be on an annual maintenance anyway.
Tiling Installation:
is artist is primarily known for his ceramics and public art installations using ceramic tiles. It is therefore anticipated that
the tiles themselves will be well formed and installed correctly. Preservation Arts Director Rowan Geiger has been in contact
with the artist about another proposed tile installation in the City of Dublin and obtained the artists’ preferred materials for
the terracotta tiles.
Preservation-Arts.com Page 4 of 7
7.3.d
Packet Pg. 85 Attachment: 5. Art Conservator Evaluation (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
Conservation Assessment of Proposed Sculpture By Yoshio Taylor for Sean Diamond Park, Dublin
1. in Set Mortar
e rst stage of installation is application of a thin set mortar. e artist is proposing to use Versabond forti ed thin-set
mortar by Custom Building Products. is product is a professional formula, all-purpose mortar, polymer-modi ed to
provide good bond strength for oor and tile projects. VersaBond® cures uickly even in cold climates and adheres to most
surfaces, exceeding ANSI A118.4 and A118.11 without the need for additives. It is suitable for the California temperatures and
is a dry, proprietary blend of Portland cement, copolymers, inorganic a regates and chemicals.
is is a commonly used thin set mortar used by artists for outdoor tile installations and will be suitable if the moisture
barrier recommendations are taken, and the manufacturer’s speci cations are followed.
2. Grout
e artist has su ested using Custom Building Products, poly blend, DeLorean gray sanded grout #165.
Polyblend® Sanded Grout is a dry, Portland cement based grout with silica sand, inorganic a regates and chemicals.
It has passed a number of Applicable Standards American National Standards Institute (ANSI) ANSI A108.10 & A118.6 of the
American National Standards for the Installation of Ceramic Tile ASTM International (ASTM) ASTM C109 Standard Test
Method for Compressive Strength of Hydraulic Cement Mortars (Using 2-in. or (50-mm) Cube Specimens) ASTM C531
Standard Test Method for Linear Shrinkage ASTM C580 Standard Test method for Flexural Strength ISO 13007-3 Approvals
Polyblend® Sanded Grout exceeds ANSI A118.6 standards.
Installation must conform to ANSI A108.10.
e di erence between a sanded grout and a non-sanded grout is thickness of the grout line and type of tile since sanded
grout is more likely to scratch a highly polished tile surface during appliction. Non-sanded grout is only suitable for a grout
line of up to ⅛” thick, so the sanded option may be a good choice based on the likely variation in size of grout lines from
handmade terracotta relief tiles.
3. Sealer
e artist is recommending Tile lab grout and tile sealer, by Custom Building Products. I could not nd this product, but the
company recommends a water based uoropolymer called A ua Mix® Sealer’s Choice® Gold to be used with the other two
products listed above. is is the most protective of their sealants and works by reducing the porosity of the grout to reduce
staining. Fluoropolymers are one of the most high performance coatings currently available in the li uid coatings industry,
and it can be reapplied in the future.
4. Warranties
Warranties are always worth obtaining if available and Custom Building Products do provide a limited one year warranty for
their products to the original owner. For commercial installations, longer warranties including lifetime warranties, can be
obtained so long as the system is all Custom Building Products, and it is pre-approved by the company and recommended
manufacturing speci cations are followed. e phone number to call is 1 800 272 8786.
5. Skilled Installers
e artist may be undertaking the tiling himself. Commercial warranties do not necessarily re uire the use of a certi ed tile
contractors, 5 star NTCA contractor or members of the National Tile Contractors Association, but the artist will have to
meet all the re uired building codes and TCNA guidelines.
Preservation-Arts.com Page 5 of 7
7.3.d
Packet Pg. 86 Attachment: 5. Art Conservator Evaluation (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
Conservation Assessment of Proposed Sculpture By Yoshio Taylor for Sean Diamond Park, Dublin
Other Considerations:
Concrete Substrate:
e base is formed from cast concrete, presumably with an iron armature. Although separated from the landscaping on the
park design by a path, any landscaping should be drip system rather than sprinklers to prevent water hitting the concrete.
Constant moisture against concrete can lead to a number of issues such as salt formation/e orescence on the concrete and
mortar that appears as white insoluble crystals and blanching of the color on tiles. Chloride ions in recycled water can also
lead to rusting of the iron rebar armature within the concrete, that expands the metal leading to cracks and ultimately losses
of concrete and tile.
e City can help by minimizing risks and long term maintenance costs by taking some precautions during the casting and
installation process:
●Installing a vapor barrier underneath the slab during casting
●Ensuring ade uate area of hard landscaping around the sculpture base to act as a barrier layer to moisture
●Installing a drip system so that no sprinkler water comes into contact with the artworks
●Applying a coating to the concrete before the mortar is applied. is should be compatible with the mortar used by
the artist. Since the artist is planning to use a Custom Building Products system, the same company should
recommend a sealer. e company currently recommends RedGard® Waterproo ng and Crack Prevention
Membrane.
Stockpiling Tiles:
Although tiled artworks are generally one of the most stable types of public art installations, one of the problems for long
term preservation is the availability of replacement tiles. Manufacturers o en change the range of colors of a particular line or
designs are phased out. Because of this, it is recommended for the City to re uest a stockpile of replacement tiles for repairs
over time. Edges tend to be the rst area where losses form, and so having a selection of tiles to choose from will extend the
life of the artwork and maintain the artist’s vision for the longest possible time. e artist could also consider how to provide
a sacri cial edge that can easily be replaced of damage occurs.
Skate Boarders:
Skateboarders can be very attracted to grinding along the edges of curved walls, and can cause huge and fre uent damage to
artworks, that results in loss and breakage of the tiles along the edges. e City and artist should consider this possibility and
develop a strategy to address/minimize potential issues and maintenance problems.
Documentation:
As damage and losses occur to the artwork over time, it is helpful to have a full detailed photographic record of the decorative
scheme in the archives to refer to. is can be undertaken by the conservators shortly a er installation.
Height of the Sculpture:
e current design of the sculpture places the lowest aeroplane element at 5 ½ feet above the base. If an adult stands on the
base, they will be able to hold and swing onto the stainless steel and lowest aeroplane uite easily. is may result in the or
damage to the aeroplane. Although this may not happen, it seems a good idea to have a couple of extra aeroplanes cast at the
time of fabrication to act as a stockpile for replacement. ese will be stored by the City. e other alternative is to redesign
with more height to the column to raise up the lower aeroplane. However, this should be carefully considered because
currently this artwork can be maintained from ladders. Above 12 feet, the use of larger e uipment such as boom or scissorli
is necessary, resulting in more cost for maintenance and landscaping design that will accommodate access for a boom.
Preservation-Arts.com Page 6 of 7
7.3.d
Packet Pg. 87 Attachment: 5. Art Conservator Evaluation (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
Conservation Assessment of Proposed Sculpture By Yoshio Taylor for Sean Diamond Park, Dublin
Recommendations:
●A moisture barrier beneath the concrete base will assist in long term preservation.
● e height of the sculpture should be reviewed and if increased, the access for machinery re uires review by the
City.
●Ensuring that no water is against the sculpture or base will lower risk of corrosion of concrete armature, and salt
formation on the tiles.
●Careful attention to grades of metals used during fabrication and weld rods for dissimilar metals is vital to lower
long term costs.
● e use of patinated bronze over powder coated aeroplane elements is recommended, and stockpiling two extra.
●Obtaining warranties for the tiling products is recommended, and will ensure that the tiling is installed according to
manufacturer's speci cations.
●Stockpiling tiles will ensure replacements are available in case losses occur.
●Considering how to minimize damage from skateboards.
●Documenting using detailed photography of the di erent sections will enable losses to be repaired accurately over
time, and ensure that the artistic vision is preserved.
Maintenance Budget:
Estimated Basic Annual Maintenance:
Team of 3 people for one day, with documentation, materials and travel:
Conservator- 9 hours x $120=$1,080
Conservator- 9 hours x $120=$1,080
Technician- 9 hours x $95=$855
Documentation: $120
Travel: $60
Total : $3,195
*Every year, it is anticipated that the costs may increase as losses occur. Major repairs will be separate to this.
Conclusions:
is sculpture is likely to be a successful installation and although it will re uire annual maintenance to keep the bronze in
good order and the intended color, maintenance should be minimal if the recommended guidelines are followed. e main
consideration is the height of the sculpture, which should be discussed with the collection, and potential damage to the edges
of the concrete.
Preservation-Arts.com Page 7 of 7
7.3.d
Packet Pg. 88 Attachment: 5. Art Conservator Evaluation (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
7.3.e
Packet Pg. 89 Attachment: 4. Yoshio Taylor - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
7.3.e
Packet Pg. 90 Attachment: 4. Yoshio Taylor - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
7.3.e
Packet Pg. 91 Attachment: 4. Yoshio Taylor - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
7.3.e
Packet Pg. 92 Attachment: 4. Yoshio Taylor - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
7.3.e
Packet Pg. 93 Attachment: 4. Yoshio Taylor - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
7.3.e
Packet Pg. 94 Attachment: 4. Yoshio Taylor - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
7.3.e
Packet Pg. 95 Attachment: 4. Yoshio Taylor - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)
7.3.e
Packet Pg. 96 Attachment: 4. Yoshio Taylor - Resume and Sean Diamond Park Proposal (Sean Diamond Park Art Selection)